OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Basil

#1590
I'm expecting them to report much of a muchness as they have reported before but higher village and care operational losses offset by perhaps a very modest improvement in property gains.  Net, net, more of the same or very similar to the past.
QuoteHope Oceania report a lot better than what Arvida have reported  Winner
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/422074/attachment/407732/422074-407732.pdf
In 1H FY24 receipts from customers were $107.4m but payments to employees and suppliers were $121.5m so they lost $14.1m ($28.2m on an annualized basis), from their village and care operations in the six-month period.  See page 21.
This worsened to cash outflow loss from core operations of $55.4m for the full year to 31 May 2024, see page 22
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/431667/attachment/419254/431667-419254.pdf

It will be interesting to see how much these village and care operational losses have worsened in the current six-month period.  Just as well they will do so well from property, (or will they?), they will be able to mask this ever-worsening problem so that most will overlook it as an inconsequential issue, but I would suggest in doing so, many are ignoring the elephant in the room in that there's no money in care or village operations, in fact it's a huge problem that keeps getting worse.

I think the losses from village operations and provision of care are now so bad, this is the reason nobody wants to take over OCA.
Capitalize annual cash losses on village operations in FY24 of $55m at say 8.5 times, (ignoring the alarming rate they are growing at, which itself is a very serious concern), and that's $467.5m off NTA right there.  That's 64.6 cps on 723.67m shares.  Jarden website claims OCA reckon NTA is $1.41 per share.
I reckon adjusted for capitalized losses on village and care operations the net effective NTA is $1.41 - 64.6 cps = 76.4 cps.
Roughly about where the share price is.  I think the market is a lot more efficient when pricing these shares than many others think it is.

More to the point when valuing shares, it's all about the no growth eps of circa 8.5 cps.  Until they can prove then can grow eps, I think this is destined to stay moribund around its IPO price forever and a day.  With little if anything in the way of dividends from this property company, because of the cash burned in operating it, to me this means capital invested is "dead money"

Just my way of valuing shares, (and I seem to have done okay over the years), but others will have different ways of arriving at their fair value and that's perfectly fine and good luck with that.

Untamed

Probably the most transparent and honest results narrative I have seen since I first invested in OCA. Some here will pick it to pieces no doubt, but it is clear that the new CEO has her finger on the pulse, and a very clear understanding of what needs to happen. I am pleased to see the introduction of a resident centred care framework, and a focus on sales expansion, and debt gearing.

I think Suzanne can do what is needed, to turn OCA into the business it always had the potential to be.

winner (n)

Quote from: Basil on Nov 20, 2024, 06:13 PMIn 1H FY24 receipts from customers were $107.4m but payments to employees and suppliers were $121.5m so they lost $14.1m ($28.2m on an annualized basis), from their village and care operations in the six-month period.  See page 21.
This worsened to cash outflow loss from core operations of $55.4m for the full year to 31 May 2024, see page 22
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/431667/attachment/419254/431667-419254.pdf


H125 numbers Receipts $106.0m and payments to employees and suppliers $129.4m

Your loss of $14.1m last year has expanded to $23.4m this year

But they 'restated' F24 numbers and the $14.1m was really only $4.8m ...oops things really are worse. Restate to try and show continuing operations ..like don't count the things given away

Untamed

Quote from: winner (n) on Nov 22, 2024, 09:22 AMH125 numbers Receipts $106.0m and payments to employees and suppliers $129.4m

Your loss of $14.1m last year has expanded to $23.4m this year

But they 'restated' F24 numbers and the $14.1m was really only $4.8m ...oops things really are worse. Restate to try and show continuing operations ..like don't count the things given away

Do you ever look for the positive in anything? Nobody was expecting a financially significant result. You and I both know that Brent had "lost his way," so it was pretty obvious that whoever took over, was going to have their work cut out. Suzanne has only been in the role for four months.

What I was looking for, was an indication that Suzanne is working on turning things around - and that her goals were inline with my own. She is, and they are, so I am satisfied with this result, and now have some confidence that we will see progress and improvement from this point on. Give the woman a chance.

Your mileage obviously varies, but maybe just try to show a little optimism.




ValueNZ

Quote from: winner (n) on Nov 22, 2024, 09:22 AMH125 numbers Receipts $106.0m and payments to employees and suppliers $129.4m

Your loss of $14.1m last year has expanded to $23.4m this year
Didn't realise profit and losses were calculated on a cash basis.

BlackPeter

Quote from: Untamed on Nov 22, 2024, 08:58 AMProbably the most transparent and honest results narrative I have seen since I first invested in OCA. Some here will pick it to pieces no doubt, but it is clear that the new CEO has her finger on the pulse, and a very clear understanding of what needs to happen. I am pleased to see the introduction of a resident centred care framework, and a focus on sales expansion, and debt gearing.

I think Suzanne can do what is needed, to turn OCA into the business it always had the potential to be.


Agreed - the presentation is refreshingly open and honest. Hey, they even publish the occupancy of the Helier (and no, its not flash). And yes, they did some selling down of unoccupied stock, but still lots to do. They say acknowledgment of the issues is the first step to improvement - and I think as well the new CEO deserves a chance.

Untamed

Can anyone tell me who this Aaron dude is, currently asking questions on the live presentation? I didn't catch which broker he represents. Bit of a rude, disrespectful fellow, whoever he is. His questions are valid, but his attitude is not.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Untamed on Nov 22, 2024, 11:44 AMCan anyone tell me who this Aaron dude is, currently asking questions on the live presentation? I didn't catch which broker he represents. Bit of a rude, disrespectful fellow, whoever he is. His questions are valid, but his attitude is not.
Forsyth Barr.

https://www.forsythbarr.co.nz/contact/meet-the-team/aaron-ibbotson


Basil

#1599
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/442413/attachment/432562/442413-432562.pdf

Good to see a reduction in the level of corporate B.S.and ESG nonsense, from frankly an abhorrent level with Brent.
QuoteH125 numbers Receipts $106.0m and payments to employees and suppliers $129.4m
The cash burn at a village operational level is a deep systemic issue that all in this sector are grappling with and it seems clear to me that the greater the level of care in the business model the worse the problem is.  With the Govt strapped for cash its hard to see how they can possibly arrest this ever-increasing problem and returns from care seem destined to be very poor for the foreseeable future. 
They're moving towards 50% care so despite some reduction in the level of care facilities during the half, there's a long way to go.
How I see it. They're always going to be the runt of the litter because of the systemic unresolvable problem that the returns on care are appallingly low.  I don't see that ever changing.

Underlying profit is down, not flat as I expected.  Things have got worse, not better as many others were predicting.  Never mind, next year will be their year and the WAHS are going to win the NRL too so you can bet the ranch on both those things happening  ;)   New CEO has a vast mountain of work to do over the next 5 years.  Will she be somewhat more successful in her endeavors than the last two CEO's who have failed so miserably?  I doubt it.

My view remains unchanged from that expressed a couple of days ago
"More to the point when valuing shares, it's all about the no growth eps of circa 8.5 cps.  Until they can prove then can grow eps, I think this is destined to stay moribund around its IPO price forever and a day.  With little if anything in the way of dividends from this property company, because of the cash burned in operating it, to me this means capital invested is "dead money"
It looks like there's no dividends for the foreseeable future.


Untamed

Quote from: Basil on Nov 22, 2024, 12:25 PMNew CEO has a vast mountain of work to do over the next 5 years.  Will she be somewhat more successful in her endeavors than the last two CEO's who have failed so miserably?  I doubt it.

Congratulations Basil! Once again, you have met all my expectations, and have responded exactly as I anticipated. One thing's for sure, there are never any surprises with you. You are solidly, and consistently predictable.  ;D

Fortunately, some of us are still willing to give Suzanne a chance to "do better." You may end up being the one who is surprised. We will see.


Basil

#1601
Quote from: Untamed on Nov 22, 2024, 12:36 PMYou may end up being the one who is surprised. We will see.
No worries about the current lackluster performance, the future is going to be so much better ;D ...wait, haven't we heard that before?  Yes we have, every single time they have ever issued a report lol   To their credit, at least they are finally, (after all the endless years of B.S., deliberate obfuscation and concealment), being open about the seriousness of the challenges they face.    I see meaningless ESG stuff has been shifted from leading off in the presentation with multiple pages of stuff, to one page at the end of the latest investor presentation where it belongs.  I suppose that at least signals a change in their focus which is at least making a start on trying to fix their mess.

Untamed

Quote from: Basil on Nov 22, 2024, 12:43 PMTo their credit, at least they are finally, (after all the endless years of B.S., deliberate obfuscation and concealment), being open about the seriousness of the challenges they face.    I see meaningless ESG stuff has been shifted from leading off in the presentation with multiple pages of stuff, to one page at the end of the latest investor presentation where it belongs.  I suppose that at least signals a change in their focus which is at least making a start on trying to fix their mess.


Which is precisely the point I was making in my previous post. Suzanne has been in the role just under four months. (ESG stuff aside, as it is the least of my concerns), this is the most transparent and honest report I have seen in the time I have been a holder. It is also the first time I have seen clear goals outlined, and a very clear commitment to reduce debt and improve sales. You are right - we haven't seen that for a long time. So maybe just give Suzanne some slack, so she can work towards "fixing the mess" - and remember, it isn't her mess she needs to fix.

It is a bit like politics, only for some reason, people have more patience with political parties trying to fix the previous party's "mess" than they do for CEO's doing the same. Which is a bit ridiculous.

Basil

#1603
Agreed, the presentation kicked off with the leading headline "Oceania must continue to sell down unsold stock, and reduce leverage"  She's also recognized the need for a cost out program.

I would have thought these things should have been glaringly obvious to the last CEO especially with his background as an investment banking director with Jarden.  All Brent and Katheryn for that matter too, seemed to want to do was to disguise the problems and / or sweep them under the carpet and pretend problems didn't exist.

Third line into the presentation reads thus: "Sales is a core issue for the business that we need to urgently and structurally address"  This is exactly what I have been saying on both forums for years and its great she sees the matter as one of urgency.
Where was Brent in confronting this most urgent matter? 

While its good that OCA now appears to have a CEO that can actually see the wood for the trees and isn't blinded my mindless thinking that as long as residents have the best of everything, it will all work out fine in the end, there is no quick fix / silver bullet here and getting the good ship Oceania, (actually that's quite a good name for a ship eh), back on an even keel is likely to be a multiyear project.

Even then, the business is stuck with far more care in its business model than others in this sector and as I have said many times before, no matter how you slice and dice it, there's very little money in care.   Anyway, good luck with it. I will leave it at that and let the share price do the talking.

Untamed

Quote from: Basil on Nov 22, 2024, 04:35 PMAgreed, the presentation kicked off with the leading headline "Oceania must continue to sell down unsold stock, and reduce leverage"  She's also recognized the need for a cost out program.

I would have thought these things should have been glaringly obvious to the last CEO especially with his background as an investment banking director with Jarden.  All Brent and Katheryn for that matter too, seemed to want to do was to disguise the problems and / or sweep them under the carpet and pretend problems didn't exist.

Third line into the presentation reads thus: "Sales is a core issue for the business that we need to urgently and structurally address"  This is exactly what I have been saying on both forums for years and its great she sees the matter as one of urgency.
Where was Brent in confronting this most urgent matter? 

While its good that OCA now appears to have a CEO that can actually see the wood for the trees and isn't blinded my mindless thinking that as long as residents have the best of everything, it will all work out fine in the end, there is no quick fix / silver bullet here and getting the good ship Oceania, (actually that's quite a good name for a ship eh), back on an even keel is likely to be a multiyear project.

Even then, the business is stuck with far more care in its business model than others in this sector and as I have said many times before, no matter how you slice and dice it, there's very little money in care.

Yep, I agree with pretty much all of that. I don't expect a quick fix. As you rightly said, the "fix" is going to take time to bear fruit. As long as I see forward progress from here on in, I am willing to be patient.

As for care. There was actually quite a bit of new information provided around that. I am pleased that they are continuing to include care, and I think a 50/50 split between care and independent living is appropriate and achievable. This is the first report that has mentioned any specific care "framework" and I am very happy that they are now developing one, with a visible person centred care focus. That is exactly how it should be. Some of the care related notes I made included:

"New care suite sales outperformed our expectations with 51 new care suites sales during the period. This reflects our excellent reputation for provision of care, founded on our everything we do."

"Our offer sets itself apart in the market for its resident centred approach, based on our Clinical Excellence Strategy. To support this we elevated our Director of Clinical Governance role to the Executive table. We continue to innovate when it comes to resident care, expanding our care offering to a continuum of care. We have extended our clinical excellence through the Nurse Practitioner Model. We are refining our development pipeline to ensure that resident wellbeing and care is at the heart of everything we do, delivering and planning developments that optimise residents' care and comfort, including the expansion of care suites and couples care suites"


She also said they are working on a new price structure which will be published on 13th December. I assume she meant "published" for both potential customers and investors.

This is also the first time I have seen the CEO specifically recognise investors, with this comment:

"while we deleverage, and right size the business and operational costs to improve returns to shareholders."

I know you hate care as an investor, but care will never be up for debate. Retirement villages without care, won't survive for much longer - if there are even any out there. Continuity of care is the priority for most prospective customers. I would hazard a guess that it is more important to most of them, than price and fees. OCA just has to get creative to ensure care becomes more profitable. Suzanne said as much today.

I feel more positive about the future of OCA than I have in a long time. I think this CEO will work for customers and investors. I never felt that Brent did.