OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Shareguy

Have not looked at this for a while. Have been looking at broker expectations going forward. Both Jarden and FB see growth. Mind you they could both be wrong.

2024 actual normalised eps 8.7 cps

Jarden 2025f eps 10.5 cps and 14.9 cps 2026

Fbar 2025f eps 10.5 cps and 12.6 cps 2026

Will be looking for any change in strategy with the new ceo
Debt and inventory in the spotlight.

Interest rates on the way down is a key positive. Just need signs that the housing market is turning.


winner (n)

Quote from: Shareguy on Oct 28, 2024, 07:31 AMHave not looked at this for a while. Have been looking at broker expectations going forward. Both Jarden and FB see growth. Mind you they could both be wrong.

2024 actual normalised eps 8.7 cps

Jarden 2025f eps 10.5 cps and 14.9 cps 2026

Fbar 2025f eps 10.5 cps and 12.6 cps 2026

Will be looking for any change in strategy with the new ceo
Debt and inventory in the spotlight.

Interest rates on the way down is a key positive. Just need signs that the housing market is turning.



Thanks shareguy

The eps forecasts are interesting ...Oceania will need to increase sales a lot to achieve them ...especially that guess by Jardens of 14.9 cents in 2026

Be good if Oceania did nearly double underlying profit in 2 years

winner (n)

#1562
Couldn't resist adding Jarden forecast to my EPS chart

Could mean Brent was pretty useless and Suzanne is the lucky one

Let's see how it all goes ...maybe an indication in a months time

You cannot view this attachment.

Shareguy

Quote from: winner (n) on Oct 28, 2024, 08:16 AMThanks shareguy

The eps forecasts are interesting ...Oceania will need to increase sales a lot to achieve them ...especially that guess by Jardens of 14.9 cents in 2026

Be good if Oceania did nearly double underlying profit in 2 years

I agree. Jardens research (Arie Dekker) is top notch. Jarden have it on a PE of 5.3 for FY26. Not long to wait for some clarity.

Basil

#1564
Quote from: Shareguy on Oct 28, 2024, 09:53 AMI agree. Jardens research (Arie Dekker) is top notch. Jarden have it on a PE of 5.3 for FY26. Not long to wait for some clarity.
Those eps forecasts seem extremely optimistic to me given their long-established track record of zero earnings growth and well-known intense pressure on the business through appallingly low returns on care.  The only way I can see of them getting anywhere within a mile of there in FY26 is with a massive boom in the real estate market both in terms of price and volumes sold.   Even if that happened that sets them up for the next down leg of the cycle as property becomes even more heinously overpriced relative to average income than it already is. You got some shares and backing his research with your own capital mate ?
For what it's worth I think the shares are about fair value and with no dividends and the prospect of only a very minimal unimputed yield going forward, other assets in the property sector are preferred.  Worth remembering that international investors would have run the ruler over the entire sector in recent years and in the takeover of both MET and ARV, both those acquiring companies chose to leave Oceania on the shelf.

Untamed

#1565
These are the two paragraphs of interest to me:

QuoteAs Kiwis age, their retirement needs will be contingent on their financial position, which will vary from the very wealthy to those struggling to make ends meet. Part of the challenge for retirement providers will be ensuring they have the right mix in their portfolio to meet the needs of the population as it ages.

"Not everything has to be premium or luxury, like The Helier," says Dvorak, referring to Oceania's flagship premium retirement village in the Auckland beachfront suburb of St Heliers.

"There are different ways to retire. There are also mid-market price points that are more accessible to more people."

Getting that balance right will be integral to all retirement providers as they make longer-term plans to meet the steepening demand for their services in the coming decades.

Quote"It is time to look at how we change it to make it more accessible,
 says Dvorak.

"The steadily growing population means we could face a housing crisis as time goes on, so having people vacate larger properties to move into retirement is going to be beneficial for everyone. I believe there needs to be different avenues for making that possible."

Creating sustainable solutions will require a strategic, long-term approach, but Suzanne is committed to driving meaningful change from the outset.

"Living with dignity is always about choice," says Dvorak.

"And if Kiwis have greater ability to choose the life they want to lead when they want to, then we're doing our jobs properly."

It seems to me that Suzanne is very quickly "summed up" the aged care crisis situation in this country, and recognises that providers need to re-think their current mix of offerings, to include options for those who are not wealthy, but who may, at some point require some level of assisted living. We may well end up being pleasantly surprised by her leadership after all.


Shareguy

Quote from: Basil on Oct 28, 2024, 10:01 AMThose eps forecasts seem extremely optimistic to me given their long-established track record of zero earnings growth and well-known intense pressure on the business through appallingly low returns on care.  The only way I can see of them getting anywhere within a mile of there in FY26 is with a massive boom in the real estate market both in terms of price and volumes sold.  Even if that happened that sets them up for the next down leg of the cycle as property becomes even more heinously overpriced relative to average income than it already is. You got some shares and backing his research with your own capital mate ?
For what it's worth I think the shares are about fair value and with no dividends and the prospect of only a very minimal unimputed yield going forward, other assets in the property sector are preferred.  Worth remembering that international investors would have run the ruler over the entire sector in recent years and in the takeover of both MET and ARV, both those acquiring companies chose to leave Oceania on the shelf.

Yes I do agree that the eps forecast does seem optimistic,time will tell. Yes still holding and added with some of my Arvida proceeds some time ago.  Ryman my largest holding in this sector.

Basil

#1567
FWIW Matt Peek of Kingfish has chosen to allocate 3.1% to RYM and nearly three times as much, 8.4% to SUM and nothing to OCA.   
https://kingfish.co.nz/assets/Investor-Centre/Kingfish-Newsletter-September-2024.pdf

Poet

Quote from: Basil on Oct 28, 2024, 05:10 PMFWIW Matt Peek of Kingfish has chosen to allocate 3.1% to RYM and nearly three times as much, 8.4% to SUM and nothing to OCA.   
https://kingfish.co.nz/assets/Investor-Centre/Kingfish-Newsletter-September-2024.pdf

Yes, that's a nice return on the retirement sector. In his newsletter he boasts of returns of 28% for SUM and 21% for RYM over the relevant period. He doesn't talk about the 37% return for OCA over the same period for some reason

Buzz

Quote from: Poet on Oct 28, 2024, 05:36 PMHe doesn't talk about the 37% return for OCA over the same period for some reason

 ;D brilliant! At 45% discount to NTA, in a falling interest rate and bottoming property market environment, OCA is still cheap as. Doubled down in the 50's. Happy holder.
Age is not a good measure of ability

Basil

#1570
Quote from: Poet on Oct 28, 2024, 05:36 PMHe doesn't talk about the 37% return for OCA over the same period for some reason
LOL, you know that post is going to get a response. The reason he doesn't talk about it is, quite obviously they don't own OCA shares.  They're long-term investors not traders and are interested in shares that have key attributes that give them a competitive advantage in various sectors.  They've been shareholders of SUM since it listed in late 2011 for $1.35, last traded at $12.45 and have made more than 9 times their money in the last 13 years.  On the other hand, OCA, seven and a half years after listing are still languishing below their IPO price.
https://kingfish.co.nz/assets/Investor-Centre/Kingfish-Newsletter-December-2011.pdf,
Investment returns speak for themselves and show Kingfish have chosen very well.

I spoke with Matt after the recent Kingfish annual meeting some months back and asked if he thought OCA were worth looking at.  He was unequivocal in his response.  Far too much care in their business model which will give below sector returns and he went on to share he thought the Helier had a very limited addressable market.

He didn't think much of Greg Tomlinson's other major listed investment either, (HGH).  Wrong timing in the economic cycle to be owning that company he said.  Mind you, that was a few months ago so maybe its bottoming out now and at least there's a ~ 10% gross yield there which provides much needed help when it comes to having patience holding them.  He really likes Turners and shared he had a meeting scheduled with Todd and Aaron for September, but I see they have yet to action a disclosable stake there as at the end of Sept but given modest liquidity, they could be quietly accumulating.  I'd wager they will have a disclosable stake in Turners by their December quarter report.  Full disc: Turners is my #1 position on the NZX.

Matt impressed me.  He used to work alongside Julian Cook when they were both at UBS.  Don't think there's any doubt whatsoever how much value Julian added to SUM.

Greekwatchdog

Quote from: Basil on Oct 28, 2024, 06:14 PMLOL, you know that post is going to get a response. The reason he doesn't talk about it is, quite obviously they don't own OCA shares.  They're long-term investors not traders and are interested in shares that have key attributes that give them a competitive advantage in various sectors.  They've been shareholders of SUM since it listed in late 2011 for $1.35, last traded at $12.45 and have made more than 9 times their money in the last 13 years.  On the other hand, OCA, seven and a half years after listing are still languishing below their IPO price.
https://kingfish.co.nz/assets/Investor-Centre/Kingfish-Newsletter-December-2011.pdf,
Investment returns speak for themselves and show Kingfish have chosen very well.

I spoke with Matt after the recent Kingfish annual meeting some months back and asked if he thought OCA were worth looking at.  He was unequivocal in his response.  Far too much care in their business model which will give below sector returns and he went on to share he thought the Helier had a very limited addressable market.

He didn't think much of Greg Tomlinson's other major listed investment either, (HGH).  Wrong timing in the economic cycle to be owning that company he said.  Mind you, that was a few months ago so maybe its bottoming out now and at least there's a ~ 10% gross yield there which provides much needed help when it comes to having patience holding them.  He really likes Turners and shared he had a meeting scheduled with Todd and Aaron for September, but I see they have yet to action a disclosable stake there as at the end of Sept but given modest liquidity, they could be quietly accumulating.  I'd wager they will have a disclosable stake in Turners by their December quarter report.  Full disc: Turners is my #1 position on the NZX.

Matt impressed me.  He used to work alongside Julian Cook when they were both at UBS.  Don't think there's any doubt whatsoever how much value Julian added to SUM.

And yet you got pissed off at Julian for building to many units and not selling enough so you sold out after trying to blow his house down.

It was only a few weeks ago you were slamming other's for calling HGH a dog and were were backing up the truck buying and telling then about how cheap it was and eps was going to be this blah blah blah.

Honestly who really cares what you say about OCA anymore?


Basil

#1572
Not you obviously lol.  I was just sharing what Kingfish think about OCA.    The fact that Matt's opinion lines up with my own, obviously hits a raw nerve with you and possibly some others.

Greekwatchdog

Quote from: Basil on Oct 28, 2024, 06:26 PMNot you obviously lol.  I was just sharing what Kingfish think about OCA. 

Everyone is entitled to their opinion Basil incl Kingfish, but comparing OCA to SUM is a crock of pig crap.

Remember grumpy dog, the OCA worm will turn its just whether you are on the carriage and unless you are going to change 360 degrees again and buy back in. Sshh best you keep that a secret

Untamed

Quote from: Basil on Oct 28, 2024, 06:14 PM...Far too much care in their business model ...


You and Matt are wrong.