OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Basil

For anyone that doesn't know already. A full transcript of the analyst's call is available on the other channel and makes for a very interesting read.
DYOR and form your own opinion, mine is already well known lol.

Shareguy

#1606
Craigs latest note is not good reading. Apart from not selling enough and reports that the Hellier is a "ghost town" there costs are just to high

Craigs say

with its wage/revenue ratio of c.70% at the top end of the industry, which reflects its highly corporatised model of delivering care. Reducing wage/revenue to c.55%, in line with industry best practice, would improve OCA's aged care uEBITDA to c.$45-50m per year (up from c.$17m now). This would however require a radical restructure.

Cash flows were also surprisingly soft, with OCA's existing assets burning $14m of cash (excluding new sales and interest, but after maintenance). The net debt reduction that OCA had forecast for the period was also "delayed" due to "subdued" sales

I have been in since it listed but think this is going to take a long time to come right and there are better opportunity's in the meantime. Corporate activity the only real rationale to own OCA at present and I agree with Basil that high care is going to be the killer of that.

Disc/ Sold out last week.

Basil

Forsyth Barr analyst really called them out on the analysts call, see transcript on the other channel. Bet they're not happy either.

winner (n)

Quote from: Basil on Nov 25, 2024, 03:10 PMForsyth Barr analyst really called them out on the analysts call, see transcript on the other channel. Bet they're not happy either.

The Forbar man really grumpy

Apparently said Forbar only hope is 'selling the villages individually or merging OCA with one of the two large, privately held, aged care operators has the potential to unlock meaningful value."

Maybe Suzanne from Bupa there to sous out that possibility and become CEO of a really big company 

BlackPeter

Quote from: winner (n) on Nov 25, 2024, 03:17 PMThe Forbar man really grumpy

Apparently said Forbar only hope is 'selling the villages individually or merging OCA with one of the two large, privately held, aged care operators has the potential to unlock meaningful value."

Maybe Suzanne from Bupa there to sous out that possibility and become CEO of a really big company 

You mean combining OCA's hidden and unrealized value and Bupa's care problems (Actually Suzanne mentioned them in the recent report to make OCA look good - see below) could be a marriage made in heaven. They say that opposites are attracting each other, don't they?

From the transcript of the HY presentation (Suzanne):
QuoteYou probably know that I have worked in health care and aged care, in particular, for many years. I've seen care at its very worst. When I went to Bupa, it had 17 sanctions across its sites and at most places that I've worked, care is perfunctory at best. At Oceania, I can say with certainty that we provide the very best of care. I've been out to visit many of our sites and when I do visit our sites, there are 3 things that stand out to me: Our homes are full of loved ones and visitors.

Untamed

#1610
Quote from: BlackPeter on Nov 25, 2024, 03:57 PMYou mean combining OCA's hidden and unrealized value and Bupa's care problems (Actually Suzanne mentioned them in the recent report to make OCA look good - see below) could be a marriage made in heaven. They say that opposites are attracting each other, don't they?

From the transcript of the HY presentation (Suzanne):

QuoteYou probably know that I have worked in health care and aged care, in particular, for many years. I've seen care at its very worst. When I went to Bupa, it had 17 sanctions across its sites and at most places that I've worked, care is perfunctory at best. At Oceania, I can say with certainty that we provide the very best of care. I've been out to visit many of our sites and when I do visit our sites, there are 3 things that stand out to me: Our homes are full of loved ones and visitors.

Seems like you and I are the only ones who heard that. I found that very interesting. Last thing I would want is an investment in an RV providing "perfunctory" care. Suzanne seems like a hands on, feet on the ground floor, kind of CEO, and that is a very good thing in my opinion. She clearly understands care, while at the same time recognising and accepting the fact that she needs to find ways to make it more profitable.

Breath of fresh air.

Basil

#1611
Quote from: Shareguy on Nov 25, 2024, 12:53 PMwith its wage/revenue ratio of c.70% at the top end of the industry, which reflects its highly corporatised model of delivering care. Reducing wage/revenue to c.55%, in line with industry best practice, would improve OCA's aged care uEBITDA to c.$45-50m per year (up from c.$17m now). This would however require a radical restructure.

I think its great that someone has finally nailed down just how poorly their care operations are performing in terms of the pathetic return to shareholders. While nobody wants to see residents receive inadequate standards of care, the fact is the returns on care are so bad they might as well be running a charity, which frankly, is how I have seen it for quite some time.    OCA a great company to own for pure philanthropic purposes.  Basically, all other stakeholders, (residents, staff, management, directors, even bondholders who bought the bonds recently at a 7% yield to maturity), are doing extremely well from the company and shareholders are getting absolutely nothing, and frankly I think that situation is unlikely to change any year soon.




Habitz

Not specific to OCA, I found this interesting but the volume of paper and fine print is nutso

https://youtu.be/FjOVNkhQ8pk?si=53svWJqDb4rLXbXI

Mos

Quote from: Untamed on Nov 25, 2024, 05:23 PMSeems like you and I are the only ones who heard that. I found that very interesting. Last thing I would want is an investment in an RV providing "perfunctory" care. Suzanne seems like a hands on, feet on the ground floor, kind of CEO, and that is a very good thing in my opinion. She clearly understands care, while at the same time recognising and accepting the fact that she needs to find ways to make it more profitable.

Breath of fresh air.

Agree. A relief to have a straight talker in charge at last. Hopefully actions follow through.

Basil

Jenny Ruth posted an interesting piece on OCA today.  Better not share the detail as it's a breach of copyright.  In brief, it's one thing to acknowledge some of your problems but fixing them is quite another thing.

Untamed

Quote from: Basil on Nov 27, 2024, 06:02 PMJenny Ruth posted an interesting piece on OCA today.  Better not share the detail as it's a breach of copyright.  In brief, it's one thing to acknowledge some of your problems but fixing them is quite another thing.

Wasn't that long ago people were saying the same thing about Ryman.

There is enough to be pessimistic about in the world right now. I'm choosing to temper the negative (which I fully accept), with the positive. At least now there are some positive actions being taken.

Remind me, because it is hard to keep track, do you hold any OCA currently?

Basil

#1616
Ryman still have an absolute mountain of work to do.  I have some OCA corporate bonds, no shares.
Article in the Hearld today, paywalled, best not to read it if you want to try and stay positive.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/why-new-150m-auckland-retirement-village-the-helier-is-69-empty-new-ceo-explains/FLBODVXTPNFT3DJXCWXEMVERCU/?lid=cme23ou6o9wh

Untamed

#1617
Quote from: Basil on Nov 27, 2024, 07:01 PMRyman still have an absolute mountain of work to do.  I have some OCA corporate bonds, no shares.
Article in the Hearld today, paywalled, best not to read it if you want to try and stay positive.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/why-new-150m-auckland-retirement-village-the-helier-is-69-empty-new-ceo-explains/FLBODVXTPNFT3DJXCWXEMVERCU/?lid=cme23ou6o9wh

Unfortunately, I can't afford to pay for paywalled articles, given that I have wasted all my money investing in OCA  ;D

To be honest, I was always a little concerned about the Hellier, as it is obviously aimed at a very niche market, so I'm not surprised at the sales figures to date. I suspect it would never have been built had Suzanne been CEO at the time. We can't change the past, so OCA needs to find a way to "make the best of it" now. If that means dropping prices, so be it. Better to have full occupancy at reduced prices, than empty apartments, especially given the fact that they have to maintain full staffing levels to provide the current few residents with the services they are paying for.

I have no doubt that Suzanne will be looking very closely at it, and working hard on coming up with possible, maybe even temporary, options, alongside the already stated focus on marketing and increasing sales.

I am not wearing rose coloured glasses, no matter what you believe. I am a realist. I cannot sell without locking in a significant loss (peanuts for you, but significant for me). I don't want a takeover as I seriously doubt any offer would be enough for me to break even, let alone make a profit. I still believe in the sector, and I now believe we at least have a chance, with Suzanne at the helm. Even the naysayers have admitted that they believe it will "come right" over time. Probably more time than I would like, but hey ...it is what it is.

So what alternative is there? Might as well focus on the positives, now that there are a couple, rather than stress myself out with the negatives, don't you think? We both know what stress can do to one's health.

I'm giving Suzanne 12 months. We will see where things sit in a year, at which time I will re-visit my position. I am optimistic and hopeful, but not delusional  ;)

mike2023

I think if you look at the history of undervalued assets such as these, the take overs give you an insight into actual value. That is what keeps me holding OCA.
NZ is all about dividends, which undervalues stocks like this.

If they could unload The Hellier, maybe as a high-end hotel, that would be great. But surely dropping the entry price would create division amongst current residents?

We need a Tina or a Spot.

Untamed

Quote from: mike2023 on Nov 28, 2024, 07:04 AMI think if you look at the history of undervalued assets such as these, the take overs give you an insight into actual value. That is what keeps me holding OCA.
NZ is all about dividends, which undervalues stocks like this.

If they could unload The Hellier, maybe as a high-end hotel, that would be great. But surely dropping the entry price would create division amongst current residents?

We need a Tina or a Spot.

Yes, if they chose to reduce prices, they would have to do a deal of some kind with existing residents.

Maybe they need to look at offering a "bonus" for new sign ups? I don't know - maybe a reduced weekly fee or free chauffeur service/spa/ or whatever, for six months. I honestly have no idea.