OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

BlackPeter

Quote from: Basil on Nov 27, 2024, 07:01 PMRyman still have an absolute mountain of work to do.  I have some OCA corporate bonds, no shares.
Article in the Hearld today, paywalled, best not to read it if you want to try and stay positive.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/why-new-150m-auckland-retirement-village-the-helier-is-69-empty-new-ceo-explains/FLBODVXTPNFT3DJXCWXEMVERCU/?lid=cme23ou6o9wh

Actually - not sure what negative you read in the article which wasn't already clearly spelled out in the HY presentation? We discussed the occupancy of the Helier already to death ... but actually the article is describing the current look and feel in the Helier quite positive.

It does mention as well an in my view huge advantage of the Helier:

QuotePattison explained: "It's the first time we're aware of that we have a private resident-paying model. While we will still be certified under the Ministry of Health, we will not be entering into an authorised care contract with the Government."

That means the transfer to a higher level of care won't be controlled by the standard government model but is within the resident and Oceania's control, offering a big point of difference to most other retirement village hospitals.

Well, we obviously don't hope that we ever will get into the situation of needing high level care, however - if the need arises than I definitely would prefer if I can sort and arrange that between me and my care provider without the need to make knee falls all along a highly incompetent and inefficient public health bureaucracy. Not sure about you, but I would see this as a huge benefit.

So - sure, they might have overdone the luxury a bit (hard to read the market in advance), and they clearly have been very unlucky in picking the right time window to open the appartments in a perfectly modelled recession. Tough planning - how couldn't they not know that in 5 years later there will be a recession when they started? However - looking forward, I see them reasonably positioned and I am sure they will learn from that as well (which may or may not be the right lesson in a then different economic environment - I hear others are developing now super luxurious retirement places).

Look, it is absolutely ok if you don't hold, but it does not really add value to constantly repeat the same old warmed up bad vibes. OCA's SP is low, and this clearly reflects both the economic cycle as well as some previous misjudgments from board / management. However - going forward from here I am pretty sure that OCA is more likely to double its SP in the next say 5 years, than e.g. the much praised SUM.

Untamed

Quote from: BlackPeter on Nov 28, 2024, 09:21 AMPattison explained: "It's the first time we're aware of that we have a private resident-paying model. While we will still be certified under the Ministry of Health, we will not be entering into an authorised care contract with the Government."

That means the transfer to a higher level of care won't be controlled by the standard government model but is within the resident and Oceania's control, offering a big point of difference to most other retirement village hospitals.

Thanks for the reminder - I had forgotten about that.

Basil

#1622
Quote from: Untamed on Nov 27, 2024, 08:03 PMWe can't change the past, so OCA needs to find a way to "make the best of it" now. If that means dropping prices, so be it. Better to have full occupancy at reduced prices, than empty apartments, especially given the fact that they have to maintain full staffing levels to provide the current few residents with the services they are paying for.
Yes, I imagine the Helier from an operational perspective is costing them a fortune to run at present with just 31% occupancy and then there's the borrowing costs on funds invested which can no longer be capitalized.  Very concerning is they started marketing this more than 2 years ago and are at just 31% occupancy, despite all the creative B.S. from Brent it was selling well.. 

My contention is this is actually a lot worse than it looks as there's always some money from some MINO's (money is no object), sloshing around looking for a home and the very best north facing units would have already been taken by those people. Selling the rest could be more challenging. I think it's not just a question of the initial capital cost, weekly operating fees for a couple of $550 for the unit would put a lot of people off and I would think that's just the facility fees.  If you want to start using the butler service, in house chef and so on, I'd wager the costs are off the charts to what most would expect.  Maybe you need $1,000 a week extra disposable income to really enjoy living there?  How many people have that ?

It we just take a linear extrapolation of the sales rate, 31% has taken 2 years, that suggests about 15.5% per year which is ~ 6.5 years to fill the Helier, another 4.5 years hence from here.  With people moving out through the natural cycle of life and death, it may never be full.  Who knows what effect tweaking the prices a bit will have but I strongly suspect the $550 weekly fee has a lot to do with the very slow sales and that fee is not going to change with their revised marketing plan, or is it and OCA will have to wear operational losses from the Helier forever and a day ?

As to the question of how many people have somewhere near a million for a care suite and are then prepared to pay $3,500 per week for care unfunded by the Govt, I would think that's an even smaller market niche.

Its a very good site with great views and it looks extremely well built.  I'm just not sure that such an upper end niche product is ever going to sell very well.

Quote from: Untamed on Nov 27, 2024, 08:03 PMI'm giving Suzanne 12 months. We will see where things sit in a year, at which time I will re-visit my position. I am optimistic and hopeful, but not delusional
That makes sense to me but I'm not sure all that much will change in the next year.  Time will tell.  Good luck.


winner (n)

Quote from: Basil on Nov 27, 2024, 06:02 PMJenny Ruth posted an interesting piece on OCA today.  Better not share the detail as it's a breach of copyright.  In brief, it's one thing to acknowledge some of your problems but fixing them is quite another thing.

In that Jenny piece she said " Yes, the residential property market has been depressed for a couple of years now, but fellow retirement village operator Summerset Group continues to demonstrate that it's still possible to sell units."

Sales April/September for each in sector compared to last year

Oceania +1%
Arvida +2%
Ryman  +5%
Summerset +17%

REINZ reported sales volumes +7% (will be adjusted upwards when late returns included)

So in spite of most saying challenging times blah blah sales can be made and Jenny was right in do it properly and you'll sell.

At least Suzanne says we need to sell more

Can't help but notice how the sector pecking order is still relevant


winner (n)

#1624
Quote from: BlackPeter on Nov 28, 2024, 09:21 AM..........


 I am pretty sure that OCA is more likely to double its SP in the next say 5 years, than e.g. the much praised SUM.

This chart will look a bit different if OCA share prices and SUM doesn't won't it BP ...reversing  a 7+ year trend

I keep updating it regularly because I find such a trend intriguing

You cannot view this attachment.

winner (n)

At the rate things are going so fat this month I'll need to adjust the y-axis scale ....might go below 5% 🤩 😯

winner (n)

Well done Oceania ....doing good things that matter.

From their Facebook -

We had an incredible night at the Deloitte Top 200 Awards gala, celebrating the best of New Zealand business. We are thrilled to have been a finalist in the Snowflake Sustainability category alongside some of the most impactful and forward-thinking businesses in the country.

Congratulations to Spark on their well-deserved win in the Sustainability category, and to all the other winners and finalists. It's inspiring to see the innovation and leadership shaping New Zealand's future.

Basil

#1627
OCA came in for a single mention at last week's stock talk gathering.  In quite stark contrast to the gathering 6 years ago where almost everyone there was toasting their future success when OCA was $1.  Last Friday, not a single investor there thought they were a good investment going forward and one poster on here that will remain nameless, lamented how the very smooth talking of another very popular well-known former prolific poster on the other channel had drawn him into the OCA fold and what a dismal performance he'd subsequently endured. I'd wager there are dozens more that were smooth talked down the OCA capital destruction rat hole.

One argument I suppose ongoing holders could espouse, is at least they haven't lost all that much money from the IPO price of 79 cents in the last 7.5 years. 71 cents is not to bad and next year will be our year they keep repeating every single year.  This is way better since listing than for example MFB but that sets such an awfully low bar.  Sadly that school of thought has three holes in it so wide you could drive an oil tanker through them.  Firstly, on an inflation adjusted basis the shares should be now just north of $1 just to keep pace with inflation with no real return, (source RBNZ inflation calculator), secondly the shares have only ever paid a very modest unimputed dividend and it's now been suspended and who knows when a really tiny dividend might be paid again and lastly, what about the opportunity cost of investing in something that really is growing and paying decent dividends.  Its been an absolute disaster for long term holders and yet some skillful traders have managed to pull a 6-figure realized profit out of this dog.  All the proof you need that if worked right, you can trade and make money out of almost any old dog lol

Sadly, I think their focus on all things ESG, I am looking at the CFO Katherine Wargh here, has cost them plenty in terms of the fact that their focus should have been on running their business more efficiently and effectively.  OCA would definitely make it onto my finalist list for the worst managed companies in the NZX50 with a very good chance of winning.


ValueNZ

#1628
Quote from: Basil on Dec 10, 2024, 04:40 PMOCA came in for a single mention at last week's stock talk gathering.  In quite stark contrast to the gathering 6 years ago where almost everyone there was toasting their future success when OCA was $1.  Last Friday, not a single investor there thought they were a good investment going forward
The best investments are usually the ones that are unpopular.  ;D
Quote from: Basil on Dec 10, 2024, 04:40 PMOne poster on here that will remain nameless, lamented how the very smooth talking of another very popular well-known former prolific poster on the other channel had drawn him into the OCA fold and what a dismal performance he'd subsequently endured. I'd wager there are dozens more that were smooth talked down the OCA capital destruction rat hole.
Always easier to blame others eh... When things go well, you're an investing genius, when it doesn't, well it's the other fellas fault.

Also that prolific poster on the other channel - Would that happen to have been you circa 2021?   :-X
Quote from: Basil on Dec 10, 2024, 04:40 PMOne argument I suppose ongoing holders could espouse, is at least they haven't lost all that much money from the IPO price of 79 cents in the last 7.5 years. 71 cents is not to bad and next year will be our year they keep repeating every single year.  This is way better since listing than for example MFB but that sets such an awfully low bar.  Sadly that school of thought has three holes in it so wide you could drive an oil tanker through them.  Firstly, on an inflation adjusted basis the shares should be now just north of $1 just to keep pace with inflation with no real return, (source RBNZ inflation calculator), secondly the shares have only ever paid a very modest unimputed dividend and it's now been suspended and who knows when a really tiny dividend might be paid again and lastly, what about the opportunity cost of investing in something that really is growing and paying decent dividends.  Its been an absolute disaster for long term holders and yet some skillful traders have managed to pull a 6-figure realized profit out of this dog.  All the proof you need that if worked right, you can trade and make money out of almost anything including rubbish lol

This is all well and good but it is not the past return that matters but the forward return.

Also it's not been bad for all long-term holders. My average price is ~60c, with the majority of the shares purchased over the last year so sitting on an acceptable CAGR.

Basil

I've cautioned extensively about OCA since 2021 and been one of the most unpopular posters on the other channel for it, but the fact is my warnings were soundly basxed and turned out to be right.

 

BlackPeter

Quote from: Basil on Dec 10, 2024, 04:40 PMOCA came in for a single mention at last week's stock talk gathering.  In quite stark contrast to the gathering 6 years ago where almost everyone there was toasting their future success when OCA was $1.  Last Friday, not a single investor there thought they were a good investment going forward and one poster on here that will remain nameless, lamented how the very smooth talking of another very popular well-known former prolific poster on the other channel had drawn him into the OCA fold and what a dismal performance he'd subsequently endured. I'd wager there are dozens more that were smooth talked down the OCA capital destruction rat hole.


You provide an outstanding point for the argument that nobody is able to predict the future, not even a group of distinguished online posters sitting together for a beer. As you say, they couldn't get it right six years ago , and I would not know whey they would be more accurate this time around.

Why would you think that the punters got it "righter" this time than six years ago? It is a well understood mechanism that punters are euphoric when shares are on the way up and depressed when they are low. Nothing new.

Basil

#1631
Quote from: BlackPeter on Dec 11, 2024, 11:26 AMWhy would you think that the punters got it "righter" this time than six years ago?
Easy question to answer.  We've all seen the fruitlessness of all their endeavors, (in terms of trying to grow eps) over the last 6 years and can see all the issues they now have to overcome.

6 years ago the care suite model was unproven, and all took Earl Gasparich at his word that returns from care would substantially improve from the care suite model they were pioneering.  The exact opposite has happened, and returns have more than halved from $19.5K EBITDA per bed to under $9K. 
All at the gathering can see their business transformation program has been an epic failure and they face ever strengthening headwinds from Govt underfunding of care as well as a range of other issues I have previously discussed.

Basil

#1632
Quote from: winner (n) on Dec 01, 2024, 04:06 PMThis chart will look a bit different if OCA share prices and SUM doesn't won't it BP ...reversing  a 7+ year trend

I keep updating it regularly because I find such a trend intriguing

You cannot view this attachment.
I believe the trend will continue because OCA's business model has so many severe headwinds they can't escape from, whereas SUM's business model is the only one in the R.V. market that's fighting fit for purpose against the severe headwinds of Govt underfunding of care, a major factor that I predict will continue indefinitely.  You're going to need a 3% on that left hand axis of the chart at some stage in the years ahead mate.

ValueNZ

Hey guys. Question for the accountants

Can someone please explain the tax implications regarding the development of units, initial sales and subsequent resales.

So in my scenario OCA develops at cost unit for 600k, it's then valued to 800k. Initially sold for 800k, then resold 7 years later for 960k.

I know as the DMF is amortized as revenue over the 7 years, that's obviously revenue and taxable. My question is whether there are any other taxable events in this process.

1. Development gain (200k), 2. Initial Sale, 3. Resale gain (160k).

Dolcile

I believe that there is no "sale" it is just a lease.   The operator retains ownership of the unit. 

disc. not a tax accountant