OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Azz

#1230
Quote from: ValueNZ on May 04, 2024, 02:52 PMNot at all. The debt will never decrease due to this replacement policy (one resident out, another in before refund is made).

Don't believe me? Look at Ryman's 2008 financial statements.

What happens if there are no buyers (no new customers)?

My view is that a "no buyers" scenario would be catastrophic for OCA, for the reason I - and you - have described: OCA is reliant on new customers to pay off the debt owed to customers who have exited. There is one word that sums up what this is, and it's not "Beware" (which it could be I guess).
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Basil

The market is telling us that people who are healthy and in their 70's prefer fully featured villages with all the bells and whistles like SUM build and just like Toyota has a dominant market share, they also make products people want and can afford. 

People can stamp their feet and have a tantrum if they like, it will make no difference. The market is speaking loud and clear.



Breezy

Quote from: Basil on May 04, 2024, 01:41 PMRYM a rudderless ship. Probably headed to 50% of NTA. 
Can you guarantee that like your $15 oh wait wasn't it $10 call on FPH, your crystal ball is obviously malfunctioning.

Breezy

Quote from: Basil on May 04, 2024, 01:36 PMParagraph 2 of post 1195.  I'm just reporting what Earl Gasparich said.

Earl still has a whole stack of OCA shares he's not selling, just thought I'd report on that.

Basil

Quote from: Breezy on May 04, 2024, 06:00 PMCan you guarantee that like your $15 oh wait wasn't it $10 call on FPH, your crystal ball is obviously malfunctioning.
How are we getting on with your claim RYM will always be twice the share price of SUM...can't be right that SUM are nearly three times the price of RYM.  Must be a mistake eh :P

Breezy

Quote from: Basil on May 04, 2024, 07:29 PMHow are we getting on with your claim RYM will always be twice the share price of SUM...can't be right that SUM are nearly three times the price of RYM.  Must be a mistake eh :P
Well it was right for many years and thats a whole lot of right in market time so I was pretty happy with that call and it was the gold standard at the time. ;D

mike2023

#1238
Quote from: Buzz on May 04, 2024, 04:42 PMYeah, looks like the 70+ year olds are really SlUMming it in their OCA apartments, villas and care suites. I bet they wish they'd chosen SUM eh?  ::)

https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/eden
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/meadowbank
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/remuera-rise
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/waterford
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/lady-allum
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/the-sands
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/awatere
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/st-johns-wood
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/the-bayview
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/whitianga
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/eldon
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/green-gables
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/marina-cove
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/the-bellevue
https://oceaniahealthcare.co.nz/location/the-oaks



Thanks for that, quite inspirational really. The stated prices I read are pretty attractive and I would say affordable for most.  I do feel the property market locally is well stacked with homes for sale, more than I have seen in a decade. I can see large numbers of rental quality stock unsold and higher end homes at rock bottom prices, things must move sooner or later. My guess is later. More than triple the number of open homes compared to when we were looking last July August. That is a statement.

Teitei

Quote from: mike2023 on May 05, 2024, 10:10 AMThanks for that, quite inspirational really. The stated prices I read are pretty attractive and I would say affordable for most.

So why are stock levels building up?

Don't judge a book by its cover - advice which comes to mind.

Waltzing

#1240
Looks very reasonable ... nice stock on hand  to have... probably sell at some point...

does that mean the stock (share) is a https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Juci-kAqjes

 but the actual residents get a bargain...


BlackPeter

Quote from: winner (n) on May 03, 2024, 07:10 PMHere's a summary of new units delivered and new unit sales since listing ..taken from their announcements

In 2 years they sold a few more than delivered ...other years delivered more than sold ...and in the period shown they have delivered 395 more than sold

No further comment

You cannot view this attachment.





Interesting - but isn't this just showing that a growing company has as well more stock?

I am wondering whether the occupation rate would be a more meaningful indicator ...  ?


BlackPeter

#1242
Quote from: Basil on May 03, 2024, 06:10 PMhttp://nzx-prod-s7fsd7f98s.s3-website-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/attachments/OCA/411935/395028.pdf

Its actually pretty simple BP, I thought you could work this out for yourself.
In last years repot, link above, they sold a total of 128 new units, (74 care suites and 54 apartments).

New sales are up ~ 20% per April 15 2024 announcement so that suggests they sold 154 new units in FY24.
They sold 84 new units in 1H FY24 so their total new sales for the year are 154, (a 20% increase on last year), they only sold 70 new units in 2H (154-84)

What's not in dispute is they had 409 new unsold units as at 30/09/2023.
If you have another look at the half year presentation you'll see they had the following new blocks to be completed in 2H FY24, (after building 63 apartments in 1H.
The Helier 32 care suites
Bayview 28 apartments
Blenheim 55 care suites
Total units scheduled for 2H completion 115.

In the April 15 announcement they said they'd completed 182 new units for the year so after completing 63 apartments in 1H that means they actually delivered 119 new units in 2H FY24 (182-63).

Therefore unsold stock when up by 49 units in the second half (total 458 new unsold)  because they delivered 119 new units in 2H and only sold 70.

I make total unsold new units as at 31 March 2024 459.

At their most recent annual sales rate for new units of 154 units per annum that's 2.97 years worth of unsold new stock.  That compares by exactly the same measure to be just over 8 months of unsold new stock for SUM.  Given a lot of these care suites churn, or are supposed to churn every 2-5 - 3 years of unsold stock is a serious problem. I think it's fair to say the professional analysts are quite right, they have an ocean of unsold stock that keeps getting bigger every year.  I repeat, no analyst is saying that about any other company in this sector.    Are all the professional analysts stupid or maybe you are looking at this on a one-eyed basis, which of these is more likely ?
They've been building far in excess of demand for years.  That's why their unsold stock keeps growing every year.  Go back and look at the numbers over the years.  As a bondholder I am starting to get a little concerned whether some of this stock is actually sellable or not ?
...


Might be a bit of "perception is reality". It appears we do agree on some data, and others you seem to interpret differently than I do.

We do seem to agree on the number of vacant units at 30/9/23 - this is good.

I do accept that I misread the sales forecast for 2024 (mea culpa). You are right - the mid April announcement points to only something like 154 new sales but as well 319 re-sales (which is a new high for the company). In total they are likely to report 473 sales in FY 2024! Not bad. They never sold that many units before in any year!

I don't see how you add up all these units for completion in 2HY2024 - I see only a reference to 60 more units (on slide 25). Sure, they have more unfinished stock, but where do they say that they complete that all in 2HY2024?

Anyway, in two or three weeks we will anyway have the updated numbers - so probably no point to analyse this part to death based on old data.

What I see is a retirement company with only marginally lower occupation rates than SUM (and there are good reasons for that, like different types of housing as well as shorter occupancy times (and with that more frequent vacancy times) for the care suites.

What I see as well is that they rent out some of their units (e.g. in the Helier), which  improves the vacancy rates (and I suppose the financials), but makes them obviously on a pure sales based comparison less attractive.

Did they hope for a better sell of their top end units released since 2021/22? You guess. Are they responsible for the housing downturn, which started to bite around the opening of the Helier - of course not, which makes the consistent down ramping and management bashing sort of tiresome.

Do they have any problems which can't be fixed with a moderate adaptation of the build rate? I can't see that ...

And hey - there always is this old Palestinian proverb: "At times when Apricots are cheap, plant Apricot trees". Think about it - useful input for anybody who looks further than just the short term trend.

Not sure, what to make out of your reference to "professional analysts". I can give you literally hundreds of examples where analyst consensus was wrong in the past ... and significantly less examples where analyst consensus has been right. We all know that, given that analysts are not better in predicting the future than any of us.

But if you are just in a phase where you happen to think that analyst predictions are any good: professional analyst consensus for OCA (according to market screener) is currently  93 cents for the SP and the professional analyst recommendation is 8.7 out of 10 (which is a pretty streight forward BUY). But I assume you are telling us that analysts exhausted their wit by correctly agreeing with you on OCA's housing stock, which unfortunately lead to all other professional analyst statements of them related to OCA have been non-sense?

Clearly professional analysts are only good if they agree with the beagle, but if they do (and only then) they are infallible :P ; 

Breezy

SUM dogs clearly like to run with the hares and hunt with the hounds, whatever floats their boat on any given day.

Azz

Sales are not going to help. Every sale adds a horrific amount of debt (70% of the license contract). And the way OCA "pays off" this debt is with a future customer's debt, and that new debt then has to be paid off with another future customer's debt, ... This thing ain't gonna end well. I'm surprised it's lasted this long.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~