OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Basil

Quote from: Teitei on May 04, 2024, 12:11 PMSobering how Ryman's sp is now 58% of NTA! Was once the premium RV stock with its huge premium to NTA.

Looking like same issue with OCA that they have unsold stock building up and costing irrecoverable huge holding costs?

Answer when there's unsold stock building up in any company is to discount and get rid of the stock.  Is that happening or are the RVs just waiting and hoping that the property market will pick up and solve that problem for them?

Heck, even Sky TV is now giving away its Sky Box free (after initially charging $200) because it is clear that subscribers are happy to keep the old boxes.
RYM a rudderless ship. Probably headed to 50% of NTA. 

Buzz

Quote from: Basil on May 04, 2024, 01:36 PMParagraph 2 of post 1195.  I'm just reporting what Earl Gasparich said.


1195 was my post? In any event, Gasparich is long gone, and it's pretty clear that they are targeting the 70+ age group, which debunks your thesis.
Age is not a good measure of ability

Teitei

Quote from: Azz on May 04, 2024, 01:33 PMThere isn't a comparison for what OCA does in any other industry: takes in 100% of a house price, rents that house (the 30% fee), then gives back the 70%. This is big-time debt being created with every new license contract signed.

Not an accurate reflection of how it works - the 70% is only given back when the unit is resold (fully refurbished at the previous tenant's cost) and any capital gains go to the RV.

Basil

Quote from: Buzz on May 04, 2024, 01:44 PM1195 was my post? In any event, Gasparich is long gone, and it's pretty clear that they are targeting the 70+ age group, which debunks your thesis.
1195 is my post.  The type of villages is not long gone.

Azz

Quote from: Teitei on May 04, 2024, 01:49 PMNot an accurate reflection of how it works - the 70% is only given back when the unit is resold (fully refurbished at the previous tenant's cost) and any capital gains go to the RV.

I know that, and reading my posts shows that.

OCA has borrowed the 70%, that's what I'm saying. It is not being paid by the customer for any service. It is an interest-free loan to OCA. And must be paid back at some point. The thing with debt is: it's the paying back that is the hard part.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Buzz

Quote from: Teitei on May 04, 2024, 01:49 PMNot an accurate reflection of how it works - the 70% is only given back when the unit is resold (fully refurbished at the previous tenant's cost) and any capital gains go to the RV.

Not to mention the weekly fees paid by the resident, or government if they qualify. It appears that someone who has a lot to say doesn't actually  understand of the actual business model.
Age is not a good measure of ability

Azz

Quote from: Buzz on May 04, 2024, 01:54 PMNot to mention the weekly fees paid by the resident, or government if they qualify. It appears that someone who has a lot to say doesn't actually  understand of the actual business model.

I understand it completely.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Buzz

Quote from: Basil on May 04, 2024, 01:52 PM1195 is my post.  The type of villages is not long gone.

You made a big deal of the 85+ to support your argument. When shown to be incorrect, you don't acknowledge, but double down on another angle.

#1195
Age is not a good measure of ability

ValueNZ

Quote from: Azz on May 04, 2024, 01:53 PMAnd must be paid back at some point. The thing with debt is: it's the paying back that is the hard part.
Are you sure that's the position you want to take?

That the refundable ORA account must be paid back?

Azz

#1224
Quote from: ValueNZ on May 04, 2024, 02:04 PMAre you sure that's the position you want to take?

That the refundable ORA account must be paid back?


Yes, quite sure.

And to correct your misquote: I wrote "must be paid back at some point."
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Basil

Quote from: Buzz on May 04, 2024, 01:59 PMYou made a big deal of the 85+ to support your argument. When shown to be incorrect, you don't acknowledge, but double down on another angle.

#1195
I'm just reporting what I heard. Their villages are designed to target the 85+ age group.  Sure their minimum entry age is lower but that is the demographic they are targeting. Thanks for posting age stat's, that explains a lot about their slow sales. Have a fabulous weekend 

ValueNZ

Quote from: Azz on May 04, 2024, 02:05 PMYes, quite sure.

And to correct your misquote: I wrote "must be paid back at some point."
At what point is that?

For a vacated villa/apartment to be refunded, a new resident must enter. Meaning that on a net basis, the account doesn't decrease.

You show me a single cashflow statement where receipts from ORA's are less than payments for ORA's (meaning the "loan" value has decreased), in the entire history of these RV providers. I doubt there is a single period where that has happened.

Azz

Quote from: ValueNZ on May 04, 2024, 02:44 PMAt what point is that?

For a vacated villa/apartment to be refunded, a new resident must enter. Meaning that on a net basis, the account doesn't decrease.

You show me a single cashflow statement where receipts from ORA's are less than payments for ORA's (meaning the "loan" value has decreased), in the entire history of these RV providers. I doubt there is a single period where that has happened.

In other words, this massive debt is protected only by a buoyant property market.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Buzz

Quote from: Basil on May 04, 2024, 02:13 PMI'm just reporting what I heard. Their villages are designed to target the 85+ age group.  Sure their minimum entry age is lower but that is the demographic they are targeting. Thanks for posting age stat's, that explains a lot about their slow sales. Have a fabulous weekend 

So Earl said something prior to March 2021 when he resigned, and you're holding onto it as a core to your thesis [that OCA care is stuffed]. I think targeting is a poor choice of words, as they are targeting the 70+ age demgraphic. Their villages are not "designed" for 85+, that's ridiculous, they are designed for all ages from 70+ to their death.

Why does 70+ explain the poor sales, all the RV's target the same/similar minimum entry age?
Age is not a good measure of ability

ValueNZ

Quote from: Azz on May 04, 2024, 02:48 PMIn other words, this massive debt is protected only by a buoyant property market.
Not at all. The debt will never decrease due to this replacement policy (one resident out, another in before refund is made).

Don't believe me? Look at Ryman's 2008 financial statements.