OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Teitei

Quote from: Basil on May 03, 2024, 09:40 PMYou're certainly not boring me, I totally get that.  He's my theory why the sales are not going that well.  I suspect that OCA is delivering the market product that's simply not in strong demand.  Let me unpack that a bit.

Years ago Earl Gasparich at the Auckland branch of the NZSA gave a presentation unpacking their business case.  Therein he clearly stated we are not trying to replicate the RYM or SUM full land-based cruise ship experiences, we're smaller, boutique with more limited facilities.  He went on to say we're targeting the 85+ age group.

Now let's have a look at that and consider that the demand is now starting to flow from the baby boomers, a vast population demographic with high spending power widely considered to have been a post-world war 2 phenomenon that kicked off in 1946, 78 years ago.

Late 70's is widely considered in the industry to be the average age of entry for ILU R.V. living.
It seems to me that the large full feature facilities provided by the likes of SUM are what people in their mid to late 70's really want and OCA are currently targeting a much smaller pool of 85+ year old's. My contention is that in time, over the next 7 -10 years there will be a much larger demand for the care suites and smaller boutique villages OCA provides.

I acknowledge they are trying to turn things around and if they can sell all the basic care villages they're endeavoring too and realise close to $100m, that will quite possibly enable them to continue their transformation program and move the needle in a meaningful way towards a greater percentage of their units being ILU.
This target however, against a current run rate of annual sales of circa 150 suggest their overstock problem is only going to get worse.  Why they are not throttling back their development rate in the face of slow sales and a vast ocean of unsold stock...Go figure ?.

All that said RYM seem to have their problems as well with the shares closing down 8 cents to an eleven year low of only $3.94.  Surely, they're not going to do an ARV or OCA and head down to around 50% of NTA or slightly worse...or maybe they are ?

Sobering how Ryman's sp is now 58% of NTA! Was once the premium RV stock with its huge premium to NTA.

Looking like same issue with OCA that they have unsold stock building up and costing irrecoverable huge holding costs?

Answer when there's unsold stock building up in any company is to discount and get rid of the stock.  Is that happening or are the RVs just waiting and hoping that the property market will pick up and solve that problem for them?

Heck, even Sky TV is now giving away its Sky Box free (after initially charging $200) because it is clear that subscribers are happy to keep the old boxes.

Buzz

Quote from: Buzz on May 04, 2024, 11:03 AMWell perhaps you're right but they are literally advertising to their 'target market' with minimum age limits stated, most of them I've found are 70 years young.

The other things that makes no sense if their 'market' was 85+ years old, is that would reduce their addressable market from 11.4% of the total population aged 70+, to only 1.8%.

70-74 years        221,430    4.2%
75-79 years        172,040    3.3%
80-84 years        111,510    2.1%
85-89 years        59,940    1.1%
90 years and over    34,880    0.7%
https://rep.infometrics.co.nz/new-zealand/population/age-composition

Age is not a good measure of ability

Azz

Quote from: Teitei on May 04, 2024, 12:11 PMSobering how Ryman's sp is now 58% of NTA! Was once the premium RV stock with its huge premium to NTA.

Looking like same issue with OCA that they have unsold stock building up and costing irrecoverable huge holding costs?

Answer when there's unsold stock building up in any company is to discount and get rid of the stock.  Is that happening or are the RVs just waiting and hoping that the property market will pick up and solve that problem for them?

Heck, even Sky TV is now giving away its Sky Box free (after initially charging $200) because it is clear that subscribers are happy to keep the old boxes.

What's discounting going to achieve when the business model itself is broken? This is why we're seeing the behavior we're seeing.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Teitei

Quote from: Azz on May 04, 2024, 12:19 PMWhat's discounting going to achieve when the business model itself is broken? This is why we're seeing the behavior we're seeing.

Discounting to meet the market, achieve sales to free up funds and reduce carrying costs.

That's what sensible businesses do.

Azz

Quote from: Teitei on May 04, 2024, 12:22 PMDiscounting to meet the market, achieve sales to free up funds and reduce carrying costs.

That's what sensible businesses do.

I get what you're saying, and agree.

But what I'm saying is that sensible has gone out the window because the problems here go beyond "unsold stock".
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Azz

Here's an example of the weird that can be created by this business model:

A potential customer has a choice between a "new build" and a "resale". When things are good (sales of all sorts humming along), OCA would prefer that the customer buy the new build. When things are bad, OCA would prefer that the customer buy the resale license (otherwise too many exited customers will be waiting to be paid out).
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

winner (n)

Quote from: Teitei on May 04, 2024, 12:22 PMDiscounting to meet the market, achieve sales to free up funds and reduce carrying costs.

That's what sensible businesses do.

Just as well they have that huge FLOAT that's getting bigger by the day

Azz

Quote from: winner (n) on May 04, 2024, 12:40 PMJust as well they have that huge FLOAT that's getting bigger by the day

I'm guessing that's tongue in cheek. :-)

But that "float" is nothing but debt. A very big and dangerous debt.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Teitei

#1208
Quote from: Azz on May 04, 2024, 12:45 PMI'm guessing that's tongue in cheek. :-)

But that "float" is nothing but debt. A very big and dangerous debt.

The 'float' is great if the funds are invested properly and profitably.

Not when it is used however (along with ever higher debt) to buy & develop ever more expensive land & villages which do not sell as they do not meet the needs of the market.

Supermarket operators have enormous float as they get free credit from their suppliers while selling their products for cash. And their high turnovers mean they are never caught with unsold stock.

Plata

Quote from: Azz on May 04, 2024, 12:38 PMHere's an example of the weird that can be created by this business model:

A potential customer has a choice between a "new build" and a "resale". When things are good (sales of all sorts humming along), OCA would prefer that the customer buy the new build. When things are bad, OCA would prefer that the customer buy the resale license (otherwise too many exited customers will be waiting to be paid out).

Assuming the new build and the resale were the same price why is there any difference? With the resale you pay the old customer out with the money from the new customer, with the new build you can use the sale proceeds to pay out the old customer from the resale unit. They have to pay them out anyway.

Azz

Quote from: Plata on May 04, 2024, 01:24 PMAssuming the new build and the resale were the same price why is there any difference? With the resale you pay the old customer out with the money from the new customer, with the new build you can use the sale proceeds to pay out the old customer from the resale unit. They have to pay them out anyway.

I think the OCA contract only pays out the exited customer when a new license is purchased for that unit?
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Plata

Quote from: Azz on May 04, 2024, 01:27 PMI think the OCA contract only pays out the exited customer when a new license is purchased for that unit?

Ah yes you may right, they don't specify they will definitely pay you back after a time period waiting. They do say they pay interest on the refund amount after 6 months though. Apologies

Azz

Quote from: Teitei on May 04, 2024, 01:24 PMThe 'float' is great if the funds are invested properly and profitably.

Not even it is used along with increased debt to buy & develop ever more expensive land & villages which do not meet the needs of the market.

Supermarket operators have enormous float as they get free credit from their suppliers while selling their products for cash. And their high turnovers mean they are never caught with unsold stock.

There isn't a comparison for what OCA does in any other industry: takes in 100% of a house price, rents that house (the 30% fee), then gives back the 70%. This is big-time debt being created with every new license contract signed.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Azz

Quote from: Plata on May 04, 2024, 01:31 PMAh yes you may right, they don't specify they will definitely pay you back after a time period waiting. They do say they pay interest on the refund amount after 6 months though. Apologies

No probs. And I think there might even be competitors that will pay it back fully even if the unit hasn't sold.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Basil

Paragraph 2 of post 1195.  I'm just reporting what Earl Gasparich said.