OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Breezy

Quote from: Azz on May 05, 2024, 02:57 PMIf I'm right about this stock - will you apologize to me (for your hyper-aggressive personal attacks)?
We will know in another half a dozen years so until then that would be a no, hyper aggressive personal attacks you must be kidding, only the extremely woke would think that, I've said nothing about you personally or attacked you in any way.

Breezy

Quote from: Azz on May 05, 2024, 02:56 PMYou don't know what a ponzi actually is. Bitcoin is mined, it is decentralized, it has no debt to be paid off by future debt. It is in no way, shape, or form - a ponzi.
Bitcoin is an imaginary electronic signature floating around in cyberspace unlike the retirement sector which has physical land and buildings which can be seen and actually exist.

Waltzing

#1262
Well  what ever the model thats is being used thanks for posting the links to the Villages and apartments ... had not seen the full range of what was on offer.

Even if the balance sheet isnt perfect there is at least some land and buildings behind it and some of them look very reasonably priced..

There is a RYM village going in down the road and it looks very expensive for what you get.. sobering reminder..

well back to gardening and what a lovely late summer its been.. im sure those in RV's with small gardens have had a great time..

Do you get afternoon tea and scones in the gardens brought out? or is one expecting a bit much?

cream with the scones?

BlackPeter

#1263
Quote from: winner (n) on May 05, 2024, 01:32 PMBlackPeter ...I understand that when Oceania refers to Occupancy Rates they are only referring to care units (ILU units excluded)

If so are you calcs meaningful?

Good question. I don't know (depending on the occupancy rate of the rest).

However - if this would be the case, I'd call their reporting misleading - clearly a case for the NZX (not that anybody would fear that paper tiger, but anyway).

Have a look e.g. at slide 8 of the HY presentation ... they present the occupancy rate at the top next to other group numbers and they present it without any qualification (like "only for this segment").

You cannot view this attachment.

Why would you think that the occupancy rates they report are not applicable for the whole group?

Untamed

Quote from: BlackPeter on May 05, 2024, 05:16 PMHave a look e.g. at slide 8 of the HY presentation ... they present the occupancy rate at the top next to other group numbers and they present it without any qualification (like "only for this segment").

You cannot view this attachment.

Why would you think that the occupancy rates they report are not applicable for the whole group?


I agree with you. I interpret that slide to mean total occupancy (of the total assets). But who knows? I have emailed them to ask for clarification. Not holding my breath for an answer though.

winner (n)

Group probably does mean everything as the slide posted

But go the Slide 18 where report on Care Segment they quote the same 90.3% which to me in the this context implies car beds only.

Again one of the confusing matrices Oceania (and others) use

Hope you get a reply to your email untamed

Azz

Quote from: Breezy on May 05, 2024, 03:46 PMBitcoin is an imaginary electronic signature floating around in cyberspace unlike the retirement sector which has physical land and buildings which can be seen and actually exist.

You can fight against reality as much as you like; not my problem! I find it quaint, actually.

Are you aware that Bitcoin's market cap is five times bigger than New Zealand's GDP? ...just to provide some context.

But Bitcoin's not a ponzi. And that's what the subject was: ponzi.

It's interesting that the [non-deliberate] ponzi financial structure of OCA which I have described is not addressed in any way. Instead it's insult and more misdirection than within the obfuscation contained in an OCA half-yearly report.

I don't know of many businesses that take in huge six- or seven-figure interest-free loans from their customers. That's really nice of those customers I reckon. But where's the money? Those loans cannot be paid back unless future currently-non-existent customers take over the risk and pay out the old debt and at that point provide OCA with new debt. This defined-in-contract financial shenanigans is the very definition of ponzi; ie, the paying out of debt (or sharing of "profit") with new debt from brand new customers. That's what a ponzi is. And OCA even borrowed to pay dividends - so they've essentially covered all the ponzi bases.

What happens to OCA when enough people stop buying licenses and at the same time many licenses are exited? There's only one outcome. And it's not good. People will want their money. And accusations will fly all over the show. For example, accusations of the alleged misuse of the "you don't get your money until your unit is resold" clause (a clause which is dependent on company behavior such as good-faith attempts to resell exited units) will probably be made. (I should add that I do not view OCA as acting in this manner; I don't think they're operating in bad faith.)
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Breezy

#1267
Quote from: Azz on May 05, 2024, 07:07 PMYou can fight against reality as much as you like; not my problem! I find it quaint, actually.

Are you aware that Bitcoin's market cap is five times bigger than New Zealand's GDP? ...just to provide some context.

But Bitcoin's not a ponzi. And that's what the subject was: ponzi.

It's interesting that the [non-deliberate] ponzi financial structure of OCA which I have described is not addressed in any way. Instead it's insult and more misdirection than within the obfuscation contained in an OCA half-yearly report.

I don't know of many businesses that take in huge six- or seven-figure interest-free loans from their customers. That's really nice of those customers I reckon. But where's the money? Those loans cannot be paid back unless future currently-non-existent customers take over the risk and pay out the old debt and at that point provide OCA with new debt. This defined-in-contract financial shenanigans is the very definition of ponzi; ie, the paying out of debt (or sharing of "profit") with new debt from brand new customers. That's what a ponzi is. And OCA even borrowed to pay dividends - so they've essentially covered all the ponzi bases.

What happens to OCA when enough people stop buying licenses and at the same time many licenses are exited? There's only one outcome. And it's not good. People will want their money. And accusations will fly all over the show. For example, accusations of the alleged misuse of the "you don't get your money until your unit is resold" clause (a clause which is dependent on company behavior such as good-faith attempts to resell exited units) will probably be made. (I should add that I do not view OCA as acting in this manner; I don't think they're operating in bad faith.)
Its not the Bitcoin thread and the only reason I bought it up is because you call OCA a ponzi scheme and yet you are a hard-core Bitcoin junky, im sure many reading this will find that extremely ironic. OCA aside from their buildings they also own land, both of which are physical/real and have both value and price in real world terms.

Azz

Quote from: Breezy on May 05, 2024, 07:27 PMIts not the Bitcoin thread and the only reason I bought it up is because you call OCA a ponzi scheme and yet you are a hard-core Bitcoin junky, im sure many reading this will find that extremely ironic. OCA aside from their buildings they also own land, both of which are physical/real and have both value and price in real world terms.

I walk the talk: I own Bitcoin; I do not own OCA shares. So far I'm ahead.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Buzz

Quote from: Azz on May 05, 2024, 07:32 PMI do not own OCA shares.

If you don't own OCA shares, and have no intention of owing OCA shares ever, because in your opinion the business model is a fraud, broken, and OCA are destined to oblivion, why then would you bother posting extensively on the OCA investment thread? What precisely do you hope to achieve spending your time posting here?
Age is not a good measure of ability

jfb51

Hey there, first time poster - I'm trying to understand the ORA receipts number in the 2024 HY report and wondered if anyone could help? Cashflow statement says $105m below:

You cannot view this attachment.

but when you add up the sales numbers and multiply by the average sales prices, you get ~ $129m*, which I think Forbar quoted in their report after the HY earnings. Does anyone know how where this difference comes from? Thanks

* = 847k*62 (apartments) + 634k*40 (villas) + 336k*153 (care suites)

Ferg

#1271
Hello and welcome to ST.

In the presentation on page 28 is a reconciliation of "resales cash flow".  Most importantly we can see a number there of $46m for "New Sales".

If you break out the "new" sales x the average prices then you get expected ORA 'new' receipts of $52m versus $46m per that page (being 5x$634k + 43x$847k + 36x$336k).  A difference of $6m.

$105m - $46m = $59m is theoretical ORA 'resale' receipts.

Multiplying resale volumes x the average prices gives an expected receipt of $77m for 'resales' but we calculated this as $59m above.  Difference is $18m.

Back to page 28 we can see a number of adjustments to resales cash flow which possibly explains the difference.  Also, don't forget there has been growth in the Accounts Receivable value since year end of $15m.  So some of the 'missing' cash may not have been collected by period end and could be sitting in AR - although I admit I don't know the actual invoicing & collection process for OCA with regard to ORAs.  Someone else may have experience with a relative having entered into such an agreement.

Azz

Quote from: Buzz on May 05, 2024, 08:03 PMIf you don't own OCA shares, and have no intention of owing OCA shares ever, because in your opinion the business model is a fraud, broken, and OCA are destined to oblivion, why then would you bother posting extensively on the OCA investment thread? What precisely do you hope to achieve spending your time posting here?

I'm posting here because this is a CHAT board, and I happen to have a different opinion from you. What sort of chat board would this be if only people of one mind were allowed to post? And I follow probably the number one rule for stock investment: never fall in love with a stock... and alongside that, don't whatever you do construct an echo chamber, there's no benefit to an echo chamber, in fact it's of extreme negative benefit.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

ValueNZ

Quote from: jfb51 on May 05, 2024, 08:21 PMHey there, first time poster - I'm trying to understand the ORA receipts number in the 2024 HY report and wondered if anyone could help? Cashflow statement says $105m below:

You cannot view this attachment.

but when you add up the sales numbers and multiply by the average sales prices, you get ~ $129m*, which I think Forbar quoted in their report after the HY earnings. Does anyone know how where this difference comes from? Thanks

* = 847k*62 (apartments) + 634k*40 (villas) + 336k*153 (care suites)

I am no accountant, but is it possible that the receipts from customers of 107m includes an estimate of the DMF from the sales?

So the 105m inflow from new ORAs only includes an estimate of the refundable portion?

Hmm.

Ferg

Not quite.  Note the reconciliation on page 28 of the presentation shows the 'DMF Realised' - this is where the RV gets to deduct the DMF invoiced to the client from the repayment of the ORA to the outgoing resident's estate.  They wouldn't deduct it from the $105m in the cash flow at the time the ORA is received given the actual value will not be known at that point and it would contravene accounting policies.

It could also be that OCA was pre-counting sales that did not yet have a financial impact.

Quote from: ValueNZ on May 06, 2024, 11:46 AMI am no accountant, but is it possible that the receipts from customers of 107m includes an estimate of the DMF from the sales?

So the 105m inflow from new ORAs only includes an estimate of the refundable portion?

Hmm.