OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

BlackPeter

#1185
Quote from: Basil on May 03, 2024, 10:35 AMI am time poor today so you'll need to do some legwork yourself. I suggest you read the most recent half year presentation, its all in there.  I posted a link to it a while back.

You are getting totally confused between the care unit's occupancy and the overall stock situation.  Try harder, it's all in there, 409 unsold units as at half year and then extrapolate by adding new builds in the 2H, less sales.  Page 12 and 13 will get you started.  Then look at their overall annual new build sales annual run rate and compare that to the number of estimated unsold new build stock units as at 31 March 2024.  Its worrying me as a bondholder.  I get approx 3 years of stock.

8 months uncontracted stock for SUM at their most recent sales run-rate.
 


Beagle, beagle - you confuse me.

You made a lot of dooming allegations re the OCA sales pipeline, and when I ask some questions for clarification you tell me that I need to do the legwork myself, because you haven't got the time.

Does this mean that all your damning allegations are based on - well - guts feelings mixed with fairy dust?

So, lets look at OCA's units (i.e. care beds, care suits and village units) at 30-9-23 (i.e. HY report). At this stage I just took totals, feel free to do the analysis as well on an individual basis.

They say (e.g. on slide 24) they have (at 30/9/23) a total of 4267 units (so I guess this is 100%).

They say that they have 409 new units for sale - which would be 9.6% of their stock (lets call this close enough to the claimed occupancy rate of 90.3%, shall we? And yes, I know, there are some resale units for sale and as well some units occupied by renters, which pretty much seem to even out)?

They say that they have 382 units under construction (ok, this will over time (whenever this is) increase the number of stock to sell), but they say as well (if you throw your eyes on slide 25) that only 60 of them are due to completion in FY2024 (check the comments on slide 25).

So, yes - they will need to sell these 60 on top of the 409 vacant units.

On the other hand - they sold in the first HY 84 new and 171 resale units. This means, if we add in HY2 60 more new and nothing changes with the sales numbers (I hear, they are increasing), than they will end up at FY with less than 409 vacant units. Isn't this great - they are reducing their stock!

.... and this is not even taking their April 15 announcement into account where they said that their sales volumes increased by 20% vs last year). Isn't this marvellous? ... Things are even better than a plain extrapolation of their HY data would suggest.

Sure, they don't say when they intend to complete these remaining 382-60=322 units, but it won't be in FY2024. They talk as well about plans to increase the total number of units to 5801 (without timeline, and they have already some of them consented).

But - nobody forces them to start their development unless there is demand.

So - what exactly is the fuss about? Is this what beagles do? Bark first and let think later?


Basil

#1186
http://nzx-prod-s7fsd7f98s.s3-website-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/attachments/OCA/411935/395028.pdf

Its actually pretty simple BP, I thought you could work this out for yourself.
In last years repot, link above, they sold a total of 128 new units, (74 care suites and 54 apartments).

New sales are up ~ 20% per April 15 2024 announcement so that suggests they sold 154 new units in FY24.
They sold 84 new units in 1H FY24 so their total new sales for the year are 154, (a 20% increase on last year), they only sold 70 new units in 2H (154-84)

What's not in dispute is they had 409 new unsold units as at 30/09/2023.
If you have another look at the half year presentation you'll see they had the following new blocks to be completed in 2H FY24, (after building 63 apartments in 1H.
The Helier 32 care suites
Bayview 28 apartments
Blenheim 55 care suites
Total units scheduled for 2H completion 115.

In the April 15 announcement they said they'd completed 182 new units for the year so after completing 63 apartments in 1H that means they actually delivered 119 new units in 2H FY24 (182-63).

Therefore unsold stock when up by 49 units in the second half (total 458 new unsold)  because they delivered 119 new units in 2H and only sold 70.

I make total unsold new units as at 31 March 2024 459.

At their most recent annual sales rate for new units of 154 units per annum that's 2.97 years worth of unsold new stock.  That compares by exactly the same measure to be just over 8 months of unsold new stock for SUM.  Given a lot of these care suites churn, or are supposed to churn every 2-5 - 3 years of unsold stock is a serious problem. I think it's fair to say the professional analysts are quite right, they have an ocean of unsold stock that keeps getting bigger every year.  I repeat, no analyst is saying that about any other company in this sector.    Are all the professional analysts stupid or maybe you are looking at this on a one-eyed basis, which of these is more likely ?
They've been building far in excess of demand for years.  That's why their unsold stock keeps growing every year.  Go back and look at the numbers over the years.  As a bondholder I am starting to get a little concerned whether some of this stock is actually sellable or not ?

Quote from: Breezy on May 03, 2024, 05:40 PMHe hasn't got the time yet plenty of time for endless long posts on a stock he can't stand
I made it clear I have a substantial investment in the bonds and i was time poor for most of today, (not every day).
Why not post something useful for a change.  I asked you quite a while back how do you explain the poor second half sales and you have given no answer or explanation.  So let's hear your wonderful insights please.

winner (n)

Ah so Oceania have about 459 new units for sale

Full year sales F24 were 154

Therefore 3 years worth of new stock for sale ....at current rates

Interesting in F24 they sold 154 new units but delivered 182 new units

Azz

They have two options to keep afloat: borrow or raise capital.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

winner (n)

Here's a summary of new units delivered and new unit sales since listing ..taken from their announcements

In 2 years they sold a few more than delivered ...other years delivered more than sold ...and in the period shown they have delivered 395 more than sold

No further comment

You cannot view this attachment.




Buzz

Quote from: Azz on May 03, 2024, 06:53 PMThey have two options to keep afloat: borrow or raise capital.

You know this company is profitable don't you? On ignore, goodbye.
Age is not a good measure of ability

Azz

Quote from: Buzz on May 03, 2024, 07:15 PMYou know this company is profitable don't you? On ignore, goodbye.

Is it profitable on an operational basis? Because if it isn't, and I don't think it is, it means the business is entirely dependent on money coming in from a never-ending supply of "new sales" - and there's a name for that.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Basil

#1192
To be fair they have made fairly good money on unit resales Azz.

Basil

Quote from: winner (n) on May 03, 2024, 07:10 PMHere's a summary of new units delivered and new unit sales since listing ..taken from their announcements

In 2 years they sold a few more than delivered ...other years delivered more than sold ...and in the period shown they have delivered 395 more than sold

No further comment

You cannot view this attachment.

The unsold stock problem seems to have gained really strong momentum in FY22 and FY23. Need to have a good look at what was built those years and ask why it isn't selling now.  Research for another day.



Buzz

#1194
Quote from: Basil on May 03, 2024, 08:00 PMTo be fair they have made fairly good money on resales Azz.

The Azz reckons it's all just a big Ponzi, not just OCA, all the RV's, and he detests the RV business model that don't do what Fletcher's do with their Care-(less) offering and basic services for able bodied residents and their selfish benefactors who would prefer them dead and cash out the inheritance. Bugger the infirmed that our RV's so capably care for, and at marginal profitability.

We can move beyond that, our listed RV's occupy a specific and well proven commercial property development niche domiciled in the RV sector, the relative performance of them is all we're talking about. OCA's performance is justifiably in question, relative to its industry peers.

But all of them are profitable, they're all making money, there's no question about that.

The market is a dire beast, it punishes any uncertainty. OCA really does need to prove that it can sell its backlog of property, and until then it will be punished. I've said repeatedly, and sorry for boring you, it's about sales, sales and sales. So far, OCA continues to disappoint.

The viability of the property development business model per se is not in question, imo, it is well proven and sustainable. Those who choose to question this have other motivations that I don't relate to.
Age is not a good measure of ability

Basil

#1195
Quote from: Buzz on May 03, 2024, 08:27 PMhe market is a dire beast, it punishes any uncertainty. OCA really does need to prove that it can sell its backlog of property, and until then it will be punished. I've said repeatedly, and sorry for boring you, it's about sales, sales and sales. So far, OCA continues to disappoint.
You're certainly not boring me, I totally get that.  He's my theory why the sales are not going that well.  I suspect that OCA is delivering the market product that's simply not in strong demand.  Let me unpack that a bit.

Years ago Earl Gasparich at the Auckland branch of the NZSA gave a presentation unpacking their business case.  Therein he clearly stated we are not trying to replicate the RYM or SUM full land-based cruise ship experiences, we're smaller, boutique with more limited facilities.  He went on to say we're targeting the 85+ age group.

Now let's have a look at that and consider that the demand is now starting to flow from the baby boomers, a vast population demographic with high spending power widely considered to have been a post-world war 2 phenomenon that kicked off in 1946, 78 years ago.

Late 70's is widely considered in the industry to be the average age of entry for ILU R.V. living.
It seems to me that the large full feature facilities provided by the likes of SUM are what people in their mid to late 70's really want and OCA are currently targeting a much smaller pool of 85+ year old's. My contention is that in time, over the next 7 -10 years there will be a much larger demand for the care suites and smaller boutique villages OCA provides.

I acknowledge they are trying to turn things around and if they can sell all the basic care villages they're endeavoring too and realise close to $100m, that will quite possibly enable them to continue their transformation program and move the needle in a meaningful way towards a greater percentage of their units being ILU.

QuoteIn FY2025 Oceania intends to complete deliveries of a further 224 units at Elmwood in Manurewa, Awatere in Hamilton and Waterford in Hobsonville Point.
This target however, against a current run rate of annual sales of circa 150 suggest their overstock problem is only going to get worse.  Why they are not throttling back their development rate in the face of slow sales and a vast ocean of unsold stock...Go figure ?.

All that said RYM seem to have their problems as well with the shares closing down 8 cents to an eleven year low of only $3.94.  Surely, they're not going to do an ARV or OCA and head down to around 50% of NTA or slightly worse...or maybe they are ?

Azz

#1196
Quote from: Buzz on May 03, 2024, 08:27 PMThe Azz reckons it's all just a big Ponzi, not just OCA, all the RV's, and he detests the RV business model that don't do what Fletcher's do with their Care-(less) offering and basic services for able bodied residents and their selfish benefactors who would prefer them dead and cash out the inheritance. Bugger the infirmed that our RV's so capably care for, and at marginal profitability.

We can move beyond that, our listed RV's occupy a specific and well proven commercial property development niche domiciled in the RV sector, the relative performance of them is all we're talking about. OCA's performance is justifiably in question, relative to its industry peers.

But all of them are profitable, they're all making money, there's no question about that.

The market is a dire beast, it punishes any uncertainty. OCA really does need to prove that it can sell its backlog of property, and until then it will be punished. I've said repeatedly, and sorry for boring you, it's about sales, sales and sales. So far, OCA continues to disappoint.

The viability of the property development business model per se is not in question, imo, it is well proven and sustainable. Those who choose to question this have other motivations that I don't relate to.

I'm genuinely concerned for shareholders of OCA. There are other stocks not doing great and I am not commenting on those stocks because they have issues that the shareholders seem to have in hand.

There are a number of issues with the RV business model. But let me focus on what it means for OCA (ie, not the customer end). And why I do not see it as being beneficial for OCA.

* The premium time [for OCA finances] for a resident to leave the RV is after exactly three years, and then at that point, and after any cosmetic and structural fixes to the property, the premium outcome is that the newly available license is then picked up (a "resale") immediately by a new resident.

* But, there is negative incentive for a resident to leave after exactly three years; it is actually the opposite: the longer the resident stays the better for the resident because that means the rent (ie, the 30%) is spread out over a longer term.

* Because an extra 70% has been taken in by OCA, this debt is then owed to any resident that leaves. This is a real problem, and nothing can be more dangerous than "free" money that at some point needs to be paid back. Remember the US subprime meltdown? That was all, at its heart, caused by "free" money.

* If there is no new buyer (a resale not occurring), OCA does not pay the previous licensee (the resident, the tenant) until there is a new buyer. But the debt is still owed.

What I'm trying to get across is that this whole setup - if you pardon the pun - is a house of cards. If there are any problems with finance - eg, lack of sales, lack of resales, a loss on the day-to-day operation of the RVs, a genuine overbuild, a major house price correction (be it short and sharp, or just as bad but over a longer time period), internal "robbing Peter to pay Paul", etc - then each step of the sales and resales process could mean problems for the next step. It could mean not being able to pay out exited tenants due to non-executed - or even with executed - resales (and the terrible PR this would produce); it could mean not enough new sales to keep the operations running; it could mean a number of these sequential mini disasters that, all taken together, add up to something much worse.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Buzz

#1197
Quote from: Basil on May 03, 2024, 09:40 PMLate 70's is widely considered in the industry to be the average age of entry for ILU R.V. living.
It seems to me that the large full feature facilities provided by the likes of SUM are what people in their mid to late 70's really want and OCA are currently targeting a much smaller pool of 85+ year old's. My contention is that in time, over the next 7 -10 years there will be a much larger demand for the care suites and smaller boutique villages OCA provides.

Are you sure about that? I haven't done a thorough search but The Sands minimum age is 65, Meadowbank minimum age is 70, Eden is 70, Remuera Rise is 70, St Johns is 70, Hutt Gables is 70, The Oaks is 70.

I can't find anything mentioning 85.

I also think that your implication that OCA doesn't provide "large full feature facilities" to residents under the age of 85 is incorrect. Numerous OCA villages are very well appointed, and it appears they are mostly accessible from 70 years young.

Age is not a good measure of ability

Hectorplains

Quote from: Buzz on May 04, 2024, 10:52 AMAre you sure about that? I haven't done a thorough search but The Sands minimum age is 65, Meadowbank minimum age is 70, Eden is 70, Remuera Rise is 70, St Johns is 70.

I can't find anything mentioning 85.

I also think that your implication that OCA doesn't provide "large full feature facilities" to residents under the age of 85 is incorrect. Numerous OCA villages are very well appointed, and it appears they are mostly accessible from 70 years young.



Minimum age is different to target market. 

Buzz

Quote from: Hectorplains on May 04, 2024, 11:00 AMMinimum age is different to target market. 

Well perhaps you're right but they are literally advertising to their 'target market' with minimum age limits stated, most of them I've found are 70 years young.
Age is not a good measure of ability