Main Menu

Geopolitical Risk

Started by Davexl, Jun 28, 2022, 05:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Davexl

Thanks for the headsup on the book BP, always plenty to learn.

Re:
Well, that's my view anyway. Look I grew up in a country very supportive of the US and always prepared to walk together with them - but I must admit, after the last Trump term and potentially prior to the next alt right term in the US am I not so sure anymore whether these are the people we can or should rely on. Feels just a bit risky to me - I guess Trump would drop us like a hot potato if Xi or Putin offer him some nice compliments and a good deal.

I grew up in Little ol' Gisborne, with the US, Aust and NZ Navy assets tying up at our local port for RIMPAC etc. It was a somewhat different US then. Solid, reliable, sound leadership sole super-power etc.
Sure they made some terrible mistakes, were a little too human in that regard, but they had our backs & we were contributors back around 40 to 50 years ago.

I'm not sure that NZ has the will anymore to defend democratic values as a nation when it won't pull its weight with our sole ally Australia, Hell, we are a liability to Australia as it stands AFA our defence spend.

As for the US, I would like to think they were cohesive enough to still have our backs, but why should they when we don't even do our bit ?

It would be nice to have the option of being neutral, but for me that doesn't align sufficiently with our values
and with the divisive state of the US in recent times eg Trump - Australia has decided it must rely on itself more and has gone on with AUKUS-I and whatever AUKUS-II turns out to be.

In my view, it would be unconscionable to abandon our ally-status with Australia, they need all the help they can get and are way more vulnerable. We are not far behind them and have only BEGUN to wake-up to the threat to Australia and help them out. I personally cannot imagine neutrality for NZ and leave Aussi behind. We could never look ourselves in the eye again IMO.
All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...

Waltzing

Chump equals Chumpville....

Everyone will have to pay for their defence...  invest in US defence stocks ...

BlackPeter

Quote from: Davexl on Jul 17, 2024, 05:37 PMThanks for the headsup on the book BP, always plenty to learn.

Re:
Well, that's my view anyway. Look I grew up in a country very supportive of the US and always prepared to walk together with them - but I must admit, after the last Trump term and potentially prior to the next alt right term in the US am I not so sure anymore whether these are the people we can or should rely on. Feels just a bit risky to me - I guess Trump would drop us like a hot potato if Xi or Putin offer him some nice compliments and a good deal.

I grew up in Little ol' Gisborne, with the US, Aust and NZ Navy assets tying up at our local port for RIMPAC etc. It was a somewhat different US then. Solid, reliable, sound leadership sole super-power etc.
Sure they made some terrible mistakes, were a little too human in that regard, but they had our backs & we were contributors back around 40 to 50 years ago.

I'm not sure that NZ has the will anymore to defend democratic values as a nation when it won't pull its weight with our sole ally Australia, Hell, we are a liability to Australia as it stands AFA our defence spend.

As for the US, I would like to think they were cohesive enough to still have our backs, but why should they when we don't even do our bit ?

It would be nice to have the option of being neutral, but for me that doesn't align sufficiently with our values
and with the divisive state of the US in recent times eg Trump - Australia has decided it must rely on itself more and has gone on with AUKUS-I and whatever AUKUS-II turns out to be.

In my view, it would be unconscionable to abandon our ally-status with Australia, they need all the help they can get and are way more vulnerable. We are not far behind them and have only BEGUN to wake-up to the threat to Australia and help them out. I personally cannot imagine neutrality for NZ and leave Aussi behind. We could never look ourselves in the eye again IMO.

Fair enough ... though we started with talking about the distance to China vs the US.

I do see Australia in a different bucket. Yes, I do see the historic connections, and clearly the geography as well a similar language ( ;) ) play all an important role. And they like to use us to put out their garbage, don't they? So - clearly, they like us for something, that's a good start.

And lets face it - it does make sense to militarily work together with them. Still not sure, though whether this means we need to give up our independent political views and follow the US wherever they point. I can still help a neighbour if his house is on fire if I don't agree with his political views, can't I?

A Trumpesk US might not care about us, no matter whether we talk economic relations or military support - unless we pay them enough. Trump is a quite transactional type - loyalty is for him only important if its loyalty to him.

For that reason I think it would be better for us to keep some other options open.

Anyway - I think, no matter which way we go we must invest into our defence, and keep our options open. The latest news from our glorious government (redundancies for the forces to close a budget gap) is clearly a big step in the wrong direction. Without a decent force we won't have any options at all, no matter where we position us in the geopolitical field.

Davexl

#918
Quote from: BlackPeter on Jul 18, 2024, 01:50 PMFair enough ... though we started with talking about the distance to China vs the US.

I do see Australia in a different bucket. Yes, I do see the historic connections, and clearly the geography as well a similar language ( ;) ) play all an important role. And they like to use us to put out their garbage, don't they? So - clearly, they like us for something, that's a good start.

And lets face it - it does make sense to militarily work together with them. Still not sure, though whether this means we need to give up our independent political views and follow the US wherever they point. I can still help a neighbour if his house is on fire if I don't agree with his political views, can't I?

A Trumpesk US might not care about us, no matter whether we talk economic relations or military support - unless we pay them enough. Trump is a quite transactional type - loyalty is for him only important if its loyalty to him.

For that reason I think it would be better for us to keep some other options open.

Anyway - I think, no matter which way we go we must invest into our defence, and keep our options open. The latest news from our glorious government (redundancies for the forces to close a budget gap) is clearly a big step in the wrong direction. Without a decent force we won't have any options at all, no matter where we position us in the geopolitical field.


The wild card in all this is Trump himself. He could be so entirely unhinged, together with using his majority in the politicised Supreme Court, that even Australia could have another think about decoupling and considering armed neutrality, thereby opening up the possibility of NZ doing the same?

However my money would tend to be on Australia swallowing the dead-rat (Trump), and gritting their teeth, seeing out his final 4-year term. Of course Trump could simply extend his term by some kind of decree, whereby we are now dealing with an authoritarian US regime gone rogue ? Surely too extreme a possibility ? One would hope the US military itself would rise-up against Trump in defence of the constitution before this could eventuate...

I can't believe I am even entertaining this idea, but this will be Trump's America we could be dealing with. And with no Angela Merkel in sight to represent the West's institutions vs its most powerful member.
I hope like hell that Biden the decent, wise man that he is, does in-fact step down in his infirmity, and perhaps someone like Gavin Newsom steps into the breach. I don't think Kamala Harris would cut it against Trumps electioneering. Far too sensible, without the mongrel to take on Trump. Sadly every way you turn there are huge risks.

On the defence expenditure issue, it is extremely concerning with the coalition doing the exact opposite against it's partners' stated objectives of increasing expenditure to 2% over time. Although a friend who was in the military noted that there were in fact too many civilians in the Wellington MoD vs uniformed members.

I note that even a country like Greece, with its dozens of F-16 C/D fighters, can afford to give away a bunch to Ukraine. https://www.twz.com/air/greek-f-16c-ds-lined-up-for-ukraine-report If Greece can afford to have them NZ certainly can. It truly is a matter of priorities in a strategic time-frame of great danger.
Similarly, with our frigates, Aussi is starting to decommission it's oldest ANZACs shortly and NZ needs to step up with a minimum of 3 General Purpose frigates in the joint purchasing / build agreement, just to have a single frigate with the readiness to patrol https://defsec.net.nz/2024/07/11/australian-surface-combatant-review/
Even Peeni Henare is stepping into the fray, demanding that NZ spends more on defence. https://defsec.net.nz/2024/07/12/peeni-henare-time-for-real-defence-investment/
All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...

Davexl

Sound commentary on future foreign policy / trade considerations from Matthew Hooton

Economic outlook improves but Trump looms - Matthew Hooton

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/...J2VN4CFBAZ2JU/
All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...

Davexl

All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...

Davexl

All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...

Davexl

Winston Peters on New Zealand's AUKUS stance | Full video on TVNZ+

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pqZnvGmfVrM&ab_channel=1News
All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...

Davexl

All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...

BlackPeter

Quote from: Davexl on Aug 02, 2024, 03:30 PMWarnings of 'catastrophic conflict' by Australian Aukus sceptic Hugh White

    https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/warnings-of-catastrophic-conflict-by-australian-aukus-sceptic-hugh-white/IDCDWMRMJVFGDGGXARUUAOVQLQ/


Quite a lot of warnings of "catastrophic conflict" by somebody who bases all his warnings on unconfirmed working assumptions - or should I say unconfirmed guts feelings?. He clearly is not privy to the AUKUS agreement (otherwise he would not talk about it in public) and he does not know anything more about the intentions of any of the players than anybody else.

Long article based on minimal substance ... but sure, anybody can be concerned about what's happening in world politics, and anybody with concerns might well be right. We just don't know which of the many powder kegs will start the chain reaction.

But back to China and the US: If you look at the money flow ... then I am not sure why any of US or China could have any interest in an armed (or even nuclear) conflict, but sure - sh*t happens.

Davexl

#925
Australian professor (Hugh White) on why NZ shouldn't join AUKUS | Q+A 2024

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OacZj6WFhFs&ab_channel=Q%2BAwithJackTame

Unipolar vs Multipolar, US supremacy vs Peer relationship with China

US Aggression and effectively Lower Deterrence, supposedly what we have now = Dangerous.

Does Hugh White seriously think China will respect us (NZ & Australia) more - if the US treats China as a peer?
Seriously, after what Hong Kong has experienced ?
All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...


Waltzing

15 Ks to go to the big nuclear power station....



Davexl

ICYMI RNZ Audio

David Sanger is the White House and National Security Correspondent for the New York Times, where he's worked for more than four decades and covered five American presidents.

His latest book 'New Cold Wars'  examines the relationship between the U.S., Russia and China and looks at how technology, military intelligence and economic sanctions play into the conflict.

https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/ninetonoon/audio/2018951275/new-york-times-national-security-correspondent-david-sanger
All science is either Physics or stamp collecting...

Waltzing

Thanks for that  will read some ...