Main Menu

Geopolitical Risk

Started by Davexl, Jun 28, 2022, 05:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Waltzing

Europe has to understand soon someone or lots of people are going to get injured and killed...

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2025/11/17/russia-suspected-of-blowing-up-polish-railway-line-ukraine/

They are going to go after stuff all over the place...

Oil next ?

After all Russia is basically on fire now...

BlackPeter

Quote from: Waltzing on Nov 18, 2025, 09:36 PMEurope has to understand soon someone or lots of people are going to get injured and killed...

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2025/11/17/russia-suspected-of-blowing-up-polish-railway-line-ukraine/

They are going to go after stuff all over the place...

Oil next ?

After all Russia is basically on fire now...

Possible.

I guess it depends as well on how long the Russian economy keeps running (remember end of the 1980íes?). If they start to really annoy the West, then they might find out that it is still difficult for a country with less than the Italian GDP to fight against the West with something like 50% of the world GDP behind them, even if half of that is run by an idiot.

But yes, mentally unwell bears can be dangerous.

LoungeLizard

Quote from: Waltzing on Nov 18, 2025, 09:36 PMEurope has to understand soon someone or lots of people are going to get injured and killed...

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2025/11/17/russia-suspected-of-blowing-up-polish-railway-line-ukraine/

They are going to go after stuff all over the place...

Oil next ?

After all Russia is basically on fire now...

Ukraine was always a proxy war between US/Europe and Russia. Hardly surprising then it should eventually spill outside the borders of Ukraine.

BlackPeter

Quote from: LoungeLizard on Nov 19, 2025, 06:29 PMUkraine was always a proxy war between US/Europe and Russia. Hardly surprising then it should eventually spill outside the borders of Ukraine.

Funny way to look at it.

The Russian attack against Ukraine has been run by an old KGB servant who wants to recover the old Russian empire - and he killed aready more than one million of his own soldiers so far.

Has nothing to do with proxy war. Neither Ukraine nor the West did attack, and the Russions (the  attackers) are killing nextg to some Ukrainina civilians mainly their own people.

That's not a proxy war, its just the normal slaughterhouse killing you would expect from some of the Russian czars.

LoungeLizard

Thats a bit simplistic - a bit like the ill fated "war on terrorism" or it's current iteration, "the war on nanrco-terrorism"  that is usually a prelude to an invasion (ie Venezuela).
 There is always geopolitical considerations at play. The Ukraine has been the jewell in the crown for both Russia and NATO for a long time. Non alignment ie neutrality, kept things in a precarious balance, but now it's open warfare, with the poor Ukrainian people paying the price.

BlackPeter

Quote from: LoungeLizard on Nov 20, 2025, 09:20 AMThats a bit simplistic - a bit like the ill fated "war on terrorism" or it's current iteration, "the war on nanrco-terrorism"  that is usually a prelude to an invasion (ie Venezuela).
 There is always geopolitical considerations at play. The Ukraine has been the jewell in the crown for both Russia and NATO for a long time. Non alignment ie neutrality, kept things in a precarious balance, but now it's open warfare, with the poor Ukrainian people paying the price.

Nobody said that Americans are perfect ... even before they picked a quite idiotic and criminal poulist as their president.

And sure - Russia considers the Ukraine as part of their territory - I guess the last hundred of years it was roughly half of the time that Ukrainians did run the Soviet Union (like Leonid Brezhnev, Nikita Khrushchev, Konstantin Chernenko).

Having said that - Ukraine was even during the Soviet union a sovereign country (having an own space in the UN), and Russia even "guaranteed" their security when the Ukraine gave their nuclear weapons to Russia.

Yes, the poor people of Ukraine are paying a high price for Russias lies and Western indifference. But this still has nothing to do with proxy war. Russia is the only reason this war has been started and keeps going - and I don't see who they use as proxy (well, maybe the poor North Korean soldiers dying for Putins money).

LoungeLizard

Quote from: BlackPeter on Nov 20, 2025, 10:06 AMNobody said that Americans are perfect ... even before they picked a quite idiotic and criminal poulist as their president.

And sure - Russia considers the Ukraine as part of their territory - I guess the last hundred of years it was roughly half of the time that Ukrainians did run the Soviet Union (like Leonid Brezhnev, Nikita Khrushchev, Konstantin Chernenko).

Having said that - Ukraine was even during the Soviet union a sovereign country (having an own space in the UN), and Russia even "guaranteed" their security when the Ukraine gave their nuclear weapons to Russia.

Yes, the poor people of Ukraine are paying a high price for Russias lies and Western indifference. But this still has nothing to do with proxy war. Russia is the only reason this war has been started and keeps going - and I don't see who they use as proxy (well, maybe the poor North Korean soldiers dying for Putins money).

The Ukraine was at peace when it was non-aligned. On good terms with Russia and the West. No need for either side to interfere. Thats how it should have remained, if it hadn't been for both the West and Russia to pull it in one direction or another. There was no need to make the Ukraine choose one over the other. If it's at all possible now, the Ukraine should assert its own independence and return to its neutral, sovereign status. This may be enough to satisfy Russia but also tell Us/Europe that it is not going to be used as a proxy for Russian/Western rivalry. There's no military solution to this conflict. Any one who says otherwise has an axe to grind.

BlackPeter

Quote from: LoungeLizard on Nov 20, 2025, 10:21 AMThe Ukraine was at peace when it was non-aligned. On good terms with Russia and the West. No need for either side to interfere. Thats how it should have remained, if it hadn't been for both the West and Russia to pull it in one direction or another. There was no need to make the Ukraine choose one over the other. If it's at all possible now, the Ukraine should assert its own independence and return to its neutral, sovereign status. This may be enough to satisfy Russia but also tell Us/Europe that it is not going to be used as a proxy for Russian/Western rivalry. There's no military solution to this conflict. Any one who says otherwise has an axe to grind.
Funny - what time are you talking about when you say Ukraine was in peace?

Maybe you forgot already Russias attack against the Krimn?

Clearly - you forgot the many years whenr green clothed and Russian speakling people invaded Eastern parts of the Ukraine and killed plenty of civilians?

Ah, you mean the time when Russia lover and strongman Yanokovich was running down the Ukraine? ... and before the people of Ukraine decided that they would prefer to go with a democratic system? That's like observing the peace of the burried on a cemetry.   

LoungeLizard

#1478
Quote from: BlackPeter on Nov 20, 2025, 11:02 AMFunny - what time are you talking about when you say Ukraine was in peace?

Maybe you forgot already Russias attack against the Krimn?

Clearly - you forgot the many years whenr green clothed and Russian speakling people invaded Eastern parts of the Ukraine and killed plenty of civilians?

Ah, you mean the time when Russia lover and strongman Yanokovich was running down the Ukraine? ... and before the people of Ukraine decided that they would prefer to go with a democratic system? That's like observing the peace of the burried on a cemetry.   

Clearly I am talking about the period before the current widespread, nation destroying hostilities broke out - isn't that obvious?

That period was Yanukovych as the fourth Ukraine President and those before him. Yanukovych was as corrupt as those that have come before him and since, but he was an elected official. In the light of what came after, maybe the decision to remove him from office wasn't such a good idea? There is another way of removing corrupt leaders from office - they're called elections. Elections that would have taken place 6 months after his removal by force. He probably would have been voted out - not a certainty - but then a more moderate government may have been appointed and kept the Ukraine as a neutral, non-alighned country. And none of this would have happened.

Waltzing

we dont know if none of this would have happened perhaps just have prolonged the process until it all merged but time was running out...

LoungeLizard

Quote from: Waltzing on Nov 20, 2025, 11:45 AMwe dont know if none of this would have happened perhaps just have prolonged the process until it all merged but time was running out...

True, we'll never know if a better course could have been plotted for the Ukraine. And there-in lies the tragedy.

LoungeLizard

Bit of a Wall Street Wobble (as opposed to shuffle) going on as tech stocks get hit on fears of an AI bubble. Our exchange looks fragile as well, particularly if overseas investors start to move out of equities. As I see it, the best place to be for the next few months is on the sidelines.

Waltzing

#1482
if this goes through its actually the end of NATO and any assurances that anyone has protection from the US as Europe is now left with two choices, agree or step up and confront the inevitable now and not wait for the greater war in europe that would come from this peace....

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/us/comment/2025/11/20/putin-was-losing-badly-in-ukraine-now-he-cant-believe-his/

Is this a back room deal that shuts out ukraine and europe?  Trump appears desperate to do anything to get a deal with the criminal in russia...he want the money no matte the costs for everyone else...

at last we see what was there all along...

remember this day....

only will there be a peace ? or just a few days, weeks, months of restocking... then  off we go Europe will be next...

LoungeLizard

Sorry, but that's a nonsense headline and article. Russia wasn't "losing" the war let alone "losing it badly." Articles like that - typically from a right-wing newspaper like the Telegraph - are nothing short of misinformation designed to convince people - maybe the people who are losing their lives - that the war in Ukraine is winnable. It isn't, not for Putin or the Ukraine. Surely that should be painfully obvious by now?

Waltzing

AUS is also entering this market and with China now a blue ocean fleet AI controlled seas drones are probably the way to go....

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2025/11/21/britain-drone-underwater-russia-helsing-yantar/