OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Basil

#1485
Quote from: Buzz on Jul 19, 2024, 05:49 PMbut my analysis eventually focused on whether these companies should 1. spin off 'development' from 'operations' so that we can see the true financial performance of each side of the business, and 2. somehow treat what some have called the 'float' differently, as currently stated as a pure liability is denying the inherent value due to it's unusual characteristics.

1. Most companies in this sector already disclose profit from new developments in their investor presentations).  Some are heavily manipulated, especially RYM.
2. Look, to be completely frank about it, "the float" is the biggest load of crap ever invented on the other site.  It's simply interest free loans from residents to the business, nothing less and nothing more.  Some try and make the spurious unfounded argument that because these loans are never repaid by the company itself, the exiting resident is never repaid until the unit is resold) the liability doesn't exist so this contingent liability should in effect not be recognized as a liability at all.  Again, this is absolute garbage.  We all know this interest free liability exists and the benefits of it but it only takes one line in an amendment to the Retirement villages Act to force companies to repay this money within a certain timeframe, e.g. 12 months and the liability becomes crystal clear and very real.  In the meantime, accounting conventions that date back 500 years or more require this liability to be recognized as such.   Of course, every now and again some people dream up idea's that think that gives them the right to change accounting conventions that have stood the test of time for centuries.  These people are amateur idiots in my opinion and get far too much useless bandwidth on the other forum.  I am sorry but my professional opinion of your report is its a complete load of rubbish.

Buzz

Quote from: Basil on Jul 19, 2024, 06:30 PM1. Most companies in this sector already disclose profit from new developments.
2. The float is the biggest load of crap ever invented on the other site.  It's simply interest free loans from residents to the business, nothing less and nothing more.  Some try and make the spurious unfounded argument that because these loans are never repaid by the company itself, the exiting resident is never repaid until the unit is resold) the liability doesn't exist so this contingent liability should in effect not be recognized as a liability at all.  Again, this is absolute garbage.  We all know this interest free liability exists and the benefits of it but it only takes one line in an amendment to the Retirement villages Act to force companies to repay this money within a certain timeframe, e.g. 12 months and the liability becomes crystal clear and very real.  In the meantime, accounting conventions that date back 500 years or more require this liability to be recognized as such.  Of course, every now and again some people dream up idea's that think that gives them the right to change accounting conventions that have stood the test of time for centuries.  These people are amateur idiots in my opinion and get far too much useless bandwidth on the other forum.  I am sorry but my professional opinion of your report is its a complete load of rubbish.


Whoa, someone tweaked your Beagle tail! Lol.

I'm ill equipped to argue with a lifetime professional accountant, but it does seem odd that a 'whatever you call it' ORA, that will never be repaid by the company (it's paid by the incoming resident), -ergo uncallable, and no interest payable, and is leveraged by the company as an asset (literally cash in the bank), sits on the Balance sheet as a pure liability - IRFS accounting standards notwithstanding.

Perhaps you could entertain us by putting yourself in the invidious position of CFO of an RV, and having to account for this pseudo ever growing asset that is leveraged into development, versus not ever having to repay it - except with incoming residents money, and never paying interest on it.

I know, it's a mind f*ck from an accounting perspective and that's what these RV's have to get their head around imo, as in OCA's case, it's appearing to hide almost a $1 billion of shareholder embedded value, and worse, it's subtracting that value as a liability.

Age is not a good measure of ability

Basil

#1487
Quote from: Buzz on Jul 19, 2024, 06:42 PM'm ill equipped to argue with a lifetime professional accountant, but it does seem odd that a 'whatever you call it' ORA, that will never be repaid by the company (it's paid by the incoming resident), -ergo uncallable, and no interest payable, and is leveraged by the company as an asset (literally cash in the bank), sits on the Balance sheet as a pure liability - IRFS accounting standards notwithstanding.

It has the legal character of a liability as I've described it above, and indeed is callable if the legislative environment ever changes.

It's certainly not an asset.  There's plenty of evidence out there that companies are not fully recovering the total cost of a new village constructed in the initial sell down so cash from new unit sales is more than fully expended on the creating of new units.  I concur that the original liability when the company floated, which others euphemistically call "the float" is unlikely to be callable unless there's a legislative change forcing some time frame for repayment upon the company's, but that change could come at any time with the review of the Retirement Villages Act, if not in this review, perhaps some future one.

This so-called secret float and reserve of secret asset should by all accounts have therefore generated outsized earnings for ARV who floated a decade ago or OCA, 7 years ago but no evidence of earnings growth has been forthcoming to suggest this float has any value.
Quote from: Buzz on Jul 19, 2024, 06:42 PMPerhaps you could entertain us by putting yourself in the invidious position of CFO of an RV, and having to account for this pseudo ever growing asset that is leveraged into development, versus not ever having to repay it - except with incoming residents money, and never paying interest on it.
Why not, its Friday night after all.  Look, the very definition of an asset in accounting convention is something that confers an enduring future benefit to the owner whether that be a tangible asset like land and buildings or some intangible asset like goodwill, or some derivation of that term, call it the float just for our amusement.  This so-called intellectual property, or structural benefit the existing industry norms confers if you prefer, could only be argued to be of worth if indeed it did confer an enduring future benefit but where is the earnings evidence from this so-called hidden ever-growing asset to validate its existence and worth?  AWOL is where it is, nowhere to be seen.

Look, we've known the legal structure of the industry and interest free loan status forever and a day since RYM listed in the late 1990's.  Now, people want to completely rescope how this is allegedly benefitting new companies that float in this sector.  Spare me, it's a desperate act of pitiful fools who don't want to confront the reality of the total lack of realized eps growth for those new participants in the sector.

When desperate and forced into a corner, people will try and come up with all sorts of reasons why existing accounting standards and principles don't encapsulate the real performance or financial position of a company.   RYM and desperate holders of underwater positions in that and other companies are doing exactly that, trying to deceive themselves and others.  The liability exists, how the company repays it, is what's immaterial and that could, as suggested in my previous post, easily change with the single stroke of a legislative pen.

Existing accounting standards and principles, (when they're applied correctly and not egregiously falsified) work perfectly fine and accurately represent the true state of the company's financial performance, (underlying profit), IFRS16 (total comprehensive profit both realized and unrealized) and their financial position. We all know the exact legal character of the resident's financial arrangement they have with RV companies being an interest free loan and we always have.  There's nothing new here and certainly no asset hidden that's generating outsized returns.  Far from it, the financial and share price performance of recently listed companies ARV and OCA in this sector has been very, very poor over the last 10 and 7 years respectively.

No doubt that's all going to change radially in the future because this hidden float will magically come to light, and believe it or not I just saw a huge herd of pink pigs just fly past my office window  ;)    I hope you have been suitably entertained by a dry old bean counter that is silly enough to think professional standards and existing accounting conventions do work and there is nothing new here that hasn't already existed in this sector for decades. Have a good weekend.




Buzz

Quote from: Basil on Jul 19, 2024, 07:32 PMIt has the legal character of a liability as I've described it above, and indeed is callable if the legislative environment ever changes.

It's certainly not an asset.  There's plenty of evidence out there that companies are not fully recovering the total cost of a new village constructed in the initial sell down so cash from new unit sales is more than fully expended on the creating of new units.  I concur that the original liability when the company floated, which others euphemistically call "the float" is unlikely to be callable unless there's a legislative change forcing some time frame for repayment upon the company's, but that change could come at any time with the review of the Retirement Villages Act, if not in this review, perhaps some future one.

This so-called secret float and reserve of secret asset should by all accounts have therefore generated outsized earnings for ARV who floated a decade ago or OCA, 7 years ago but no evidence of earnings growth has been forthcoming to suggest this float has any value. Why not, its Friday night after all.  Look, the very definition of an asset in accounting convention is something that confers an enduring future benefit to the owner whether that be a tangible asset like land and buildings or some intangible asset like goodwill, or some derivation of that term, call it the float just for our amusement.  This so-called intellectual property, or structural benefit the existing industry norms confers if you prefer, could only be argued to be of worth if indeed it did confer an enduring future benefit but where is the earnings evidence from this so-called hidden ever-growing asset to validate its existence and worth?  AWOL is where it is, nowhere to be seen.

Look, we've known the legal structure of the industry and interest free loan status forever and a day since RYM listed in the late 1990's.  Now, people want to completely rescope how this is allegedly benefitting new companies that float in this sector.  Spare me, it's a desperate act of pitiful fools who don't want to confront the reality of the total lack of realized eps growth for those new participants in the sector.

When desperate and forced into a corner, people will try and come up with all sorts of reasons why existing accounting standards and principles don't encapsulate the real performance or financial position of a company.   RYM and desperate holders of underwater positions in that and other companies are doing exactly that, trying to deceive themselves and others.  The liability exists, how the company repays it, is what's immaterial and that could, as suggested in my previous post, easily change with the single stroke of a legislative pen.

Existing accounting standards and principles, (when they're applied correctly and not egregiously falsified) work perfectly fine and accurately represent the true state of the company's financial performance, (underlying profit), IFRS16 (total comprehensive profit both realized and unrealized) and their financial position. We all know the exact legal character of the resident's financial arrangement they have with RV companies being an interest free loan and we always have.  There's nothing new here and certainly no asset hidden that's generating outsized returns.  Far from it, the financial and share price performance of recently listed companies ARV and OCA in this sector has been very, very poor over the last 10 and 7 years respectively.

No doubt that's all going to change radially in the future because this hidden float will magically come to light, and believe it or not I just saw a huge herd of pink pigs just fly past my office window  ;)    I hope you have been suitably entertained by a dry old bean counter that is silly enough to think professional standards and existing accounting conventions do work and there is nothing new here that hasn't already existed in this sector for decades. Have a good weekend.





Thank you, I will have a good weekend, but I've also had a couple of nice Pinot's so I'll refrain from responding until that wears off. ;)
Age is not a good measure of ability

Basil

Darn it I was just starting to have fun gnawing on this bone lol

winner (n)

Buzz says they should 1. spin off 'development' from 'operations' so that we can see the true financial performance of each side of the business,...

Oceania essentially do that now in there segment reporting. All development impacts shown under 'Village' and 'Care' just showing operations per se. Probably because Care makes no money they do include a note as to how much realised gains/revaluations from care units there are.

The big issue is how do you allocate the $30m odd of Other expenses ....assuming HQ costs

winner (n)

#1491
Talking of 'floats' Air New Zealand has pretty big one. ....$1.7 billion last count ..when used the amounts get replaced by more cash

Don't always pay it back either

Could call that an asset as well

Red Baron

#1492
Quote from: Basil on Jul 19, 2024, 06:30 PM2. Look, to be completely frank about it, "the float" is the biggest load of crap ever invented on the other site.  It's simply interest free loans from residents to the business, nothing less and nothing more.  Some try and make the spurious unfounded argument that because these loans are never repaid by the company itself, the exiting resident is never repaid until the unit is resold) the liability doesn't exist so this contingent liability should in effect not be recognized as a liability at all.  Again, this is absolute garbage.  We all know this interest free liability exists and the benefits of it but it only takes one line in an amendment to the Retirement villages Act to force companies to repay this money within a certain timeframe, e.g. 12 months and the liability becomes crystal clear and very real.  In the meantime, accounting conventions that date back 500 years or more require this liability to be recognized as such.   Of course, every now and again some people dream up idea's that think that gives them the right to change accounting conventions that have stood the test of time for centuries.  These people are amateur idiots in my opinion and get far too much useless bandwidth on the other forum.  I am sorry but my professional opinion of your report is its a complete load of rubbish.

Basil finds ze 'oat' een ze throat of ze 'float'!


Ze question zhat remains: Who eez ze 'goat'?

RB


Left Field

OCA having a good day.... rising on the Arvida tide.
"The difficulty lies not in new ideas... but in escaping from old ideas." (J M Keynes.)

lorraina


Basil

#1495
Quote from: Untamed on Jul 18, 2024, 05:28 PMWould you even tell us if you had? Serious question.
Yes and yes I now have.  Bought some of the ones I sold years ago at $1.40 back at half price.  Not too shabby reallocations of my portfolio seeing as they've paid very little in dividends in the last 3 years.

Not as big a position as I once had by any means but there's been a clear change in direction form RBNZ and sentiment towards the sector is improving on the back of the takeover of ARV.  On top of that, the chart shows a clear break above the 200 day MA and there is early indicative talk of more interest in the housing market.  We could see mortgage rates 1.5-2.0% lower by the end of 2025.

From a FA perspective OCA made 8.5 cps last year underlying.  Even if they don't manage to grow that in the years ahead, with lower interest rates my valuation model will be changing to a no growth company is worth a PE of 8.5 and 8.5 x 8.5 = 72 cents so they seem underpinned here from a fundamental perspective as well.     I'd welcome a takeover with open arms at $1.00 but think that's very unlikely.

I'm aware that some shareholders may disapprove of my return, but that concern should be directed to someone who is interested.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Basil on Jul 23, 2024, 10:44 AMYes and yes I now have.  Bought some of the ones I sold years ago at $1.40 back at half price.  Not too shabby reallocations of my portfolio seeing as they've paid very little in dividends in the last 3 years.

Not as big a position as I once had by any means but there's been a clear change in direction form RBNZ and sentiment towards the sector is improving on the back of the takeover of ARV.  On top of that, the chart shows a clear break above the 200 day MA and there is early indicative talk of more interest in the housing market.  We could see mortgage rates 1.5-2.0% lower by the end of 2025.

From a FA perspective OCA made 8.5 cps last year underlying.  Even if they don't manage to grow that in the years ahead, with lower interest rates my valuation model will be changing to a no growth company is worth a PE of 8.5 and 8.5 x 8.5 = 72 cents so they seem underpinned here from a fundamental perspective as well.     I'd welcome a takeover with open arms at $1.00 but think that's very unlikely.

I'm aware that some shareholders may disapprove of my return, but that concern should be directed to someone who is interested.

Ah too funny! Willing at 70c after a 40% rise but not at 50c.

There's nowt so queer as folk.

Basil

#1497
Quote from: ValueNZ on Jul 23, 2024, 10:52 AMAh too funny! Willing at 70c after a 40% rise but not at 50c.

There's nowt so queer as folk.

LOL, maybe you missed the bit where I sold years ago at $1.40 and FYI have got excellent returns on that money elsewhere in the intervening years.
There's no shame in waiting for a clear change of direction and confirmation of 200 day MA break, especially when you've been out of the stock for so long in the multi year prevailing downtrend, beforehand.  Onwards and upwards from here.  Forsyth Barr reckon its worth at least $1.  What could possibly go wrong lol

Breezy

Quote from: Basil on Jul 23, 2024, 10:44 AMYes and yes I now have.  Bought some of the ones I sold years ago at $1.40 back at half price.  Not too shabby reallocations of my portfolio seeing as they've paid very little in dividends in the last 3 years.

Not as big a position as I once had by any means but there's been a clear change in direction form RBNZ and sentiment towards the sector is improving on the back of the takeover of ARV.  On top of that, the chart shows a clear break above the 200 day MA and there is early indicative talk of more interest in the housing market.  We could see mortgage rates 1.5-2.0% lower by the end of 2025.

From a FA perspective OCA made 8.5 cps last year underlying.  Even if they don't manage to grow that in the years ahead, with lower interest rates my valuation model will be changing to a no growth company is worth a PE of 8.5 and 8.5 x 8.5 = 72 cents so they seem underpinned here from a fundamental perspective as well.     I'd welcome a takeover with open arms at $1.00 but think that's very unlikely.

I'm aware that some shareholders may disapprove of my return, but that concern should be directed to someone who is interested.
Lol your return was predicted and certain.

Basil

#1499
Quote from: Breezy on Jul 23, 2024, 10:59 AMLol your return was predicted and certain.
You and as many others care too, can laugh all you want. I'm very content with my approach and track record with this one and am only reinvesting past profits so this is a free ride.  If you are honest about it, buy and hold forever has not worked, (ask Liz Coutts), but other strategies have.
The new CEO has truck loads of housework to do.  Let's see how she goes.