OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Perky

Ohh No....That's the kiss of death winner ..winning industry awards is normally a reason to sell.

Remember...

Comvita won best growth story Deloitte top 200 about 6 months ago...
They have managed to half their share price in the last 6 months
That's some mighty growth story right there..lol

The funniest thing is Oceania was the naming sponsor of the award they won

Oceania Retirement Living & Aged Care Property Award
Best in Category: The Helier


Proudly holding this award winning share in my award winning nz portfolio.



allfromacell

Winner, it's difficult to give forward guidance when so much depends on uncertain sales numbers.

You used to be very critical of OCA management not selling a story.

Untamed

#1457
Quote from: allfromacell on Jul 01, 2024, 01:53 PMWinner, it's difficult to give forward guidance when so much depends on uncertain sales numbers.

You used to be very critical of OCA management not selling a story.

Winner is "very critical" of everything OCA. He doesn't hold as far as I am aware.

allfromacell

#1458
Quote from: Untamed on Jul 01, 2024, 01:58 PMWinner is "very critical" of everything OCA. He doesn't hold as far as I am aware.

Honestly, Winner is one of my favorite posters if not favorite. He's got a deep understanding of the sector and business management generally.

I understand he still holds some 'free carry'.

His posts are often a bit sarcastic and he likes to stir a bit but I don't believe his intention is to upset anyone. I understand how some might find that irritating.


Untamed

Winner, I apologise for my previous post. I was out of line, and I am sorry.

winner (n)

#1460
Quote from: Untamed on Jul 01, 2024, 09:51 PMWinner, I apologise for my previous post. I was out of line, and I am sorry.

Ok Untamed but no real need to do that as you're the first to call me a clown but I'll accept your apology.

In a subsequent post you said I was 'very critical' of everything Oceania. At the moment thats true.

I have found that being 'critical' has been a great investment attribute. Over the years it has worked well for me. A critical view and an assessment of market sentiment can take one a long way. It gives one a sense of reality.

It has kept me out or made me very cautious about the likes of Synlait, Comvita, Fletchers, Steel and Tube, Warehouse, kathmandu and many others. These are still good 'trading' per se stocks but I've never seen them as long term holds ...trading in this context can be traded lasting years.

Funny just this morning Jenny Ruth did a piece on Vista. Untamed, this extract seems to sum up our exchange -

I emailed Ridgewell about his note: "My impression of reading your work over the years is that you're more likely to be a sceptic than not. Would you think that's fair?"

He responded: "All good analysts need to have a healthy level of scepticism, but a good eye for risk and reward is needed (not just risk), to get it right more often than not," he said.

"I've tended to be more supportive of growth companies than my peers, backed by rigorous research (including asking a lot of sceptical/cynical questions to verify the story, ie what management are saying is true, more or less) and, on balance, this part of the market has out-performed."

Teitei

Quote from: winner (n) on Jul 02, 2024, 10:13 AMOk Untamed but no real need to do that as you're the first to call me a clown but I'll accept your apology.

In a subsequent post you said I was 'very critical' of everything Oceania. At the moment thats true.

I have found that being 'critical' has been a great investment attribute. Over the years it has worked well for me. A critical view and an assessment of market sentiment can take one a long way.

It has kept me out or made me very cautious about the likes of Synlait, Comvita, Fletchers, Steel and Tube, Warehouse, kathmandu and many others. These are still good 'trading' per se stocks but I've never seen them as long term holds ...trading in this context can be traded lasting years.

Funny just this morning Jenny Ruth did a piece on Vista. Untamed, this extract seems to sum up our exchange -

I emailed Ridgewell about his note: "My impression of reading your work over the years is that you're more likely to be a sceptic than not. Would you think that's fair?"

He responded: "All good analysts need to have a healthy level of scepticism, but a good eye for risk and reward is needed (not just risk), to get it right more often than not," he said.

"I've tended to be more supportive of growth companies than my peers, backed by rigorous research (including asking a lot of sceptical/cynical questions to verify the story, ie what management are saying is true, more or less) and, on balance, this part of the market has out-performed."


I would just make the observation, W69, that almost all holders of OCA are sitting on losses (some rather horrendous) so they are feeling rather sensitive and rather touchy.


Breezy

Quote from: Teitei on Jul 02, 2024, 10:21 AMI would just make the observation, W69, that almost all holders of OCA are sitting on losses (some rather horrendous) so they are feeling rather sensitive and rather touchy.


Forums like these are made up of members with varying intentions, you've got long term holders/day traders/momentum traders etc. You've got those that run with the hares and hunt with the hounds and downright trolls, you've got good-hearted people and nasty people and of course you've got hard core narcissists. Not really any wonder that you get tensions running high from time to time with all these people clashing, is it.

Untamed

#1463
Quote from: winner (n) on Jul 02, 2024, 10:13 AMOk Untamed but no real need to do that as you're the first to call me a clown but I'll accept your apology.

In a subsequent post you said I was 'very critical' of everything Oceania. At the moment thats true.

I have found that being 'critical' has been a great investment attribute. Over the years it has worked well for me. A critical view and an assessment of market sentiment can take one a long way.

It has kept me out or made me very cautious about the likes of Synlait, Comvita, Fletchers, Steel and Tube, Warehouse, kathmandu and many others. These are still good 'trading' per se stocks but I've never seen them as long term holds ...trading in this context can be traded lasting years.

Funny just this morning Jenny Ruth did a piece on Vista. Untamed, this extract seems to sum up our exchange -

I emailed Ridgewell about his note: "My impression of reading your work over the years is that you're more likely to be a sceptic than not. Would you think that's fair?"

He responded: "All good analysts need to have a healthy level of scepticism, but a good eye for risk and reward is needed (not just risk), to get it right more often than not," he said.

"I've tended to be more supportive of growth companies than my peers, backed by rigorous research (including asking a lot of sceptical/cynical questions to verify the story, ie what management are saying is true, more or less) and, on balance, this part of the market has out-performed."


Winner, as I said, I crossed the line with my post so that is on me. To be honest, it isn't your criticism of OCA that bothers me. Well not your constructive criticism at least. It is the constant sarcasm and what feels to me, to often be "winding up" that gets my hackles up. If I logged in and saw you posting something negative about OCA (or any company actually) but without the sarcasm/stirring component, I would have no problem. I would probably actually take the time to read past the first sentence. You make it very difficult for some of us (not just me) to know whether you are being serious about something, or joking, and that can make it hard to sort the wheat from the chaff. I have nothing against joking, and I contribute my fair share of sarcasm, but not all the time. I know that you do contribute valuable stuff, and I appreciate and respect that. But the constant sarcasm, just gets tiring. To be honest, with regard to OCA, it also sometimes feels like you are having a good laugh at the expense of those who are invested and currently underwater. When you (and others) make people feel like dicks for still holding, that has the potential to make us second guess ourselves and possibly make a bad investing decision. It isn't your critical analysis that makes me feel that way. It is the constant sarcasm/winding up.

Or maybe I'm just tired, getting old, and a bitch.

Either way, thank you for accepting my apology.

Breezy

Quote from: Untamed on Jul 02, 2024, 10:34 AMWinner, as I said, I crossed the line with my post so that is on me. To be honest, it isn't your criticism of OCA that bothers me. Well not your constructive criticism at least. It is the constant sarcasm and what feels to me, to often be "winding up" that gets my hackles up. If I logged in and saw you posting something negative about OCA (or any company actually) but without the sarcasm/stirring component, I would have no problem. I would probably actually take the time to read past the first sentence. You make it very difficult for some of us (not just me) to know whether you are being serious about something, or joking, and that can make it hard to sort the wheat from the chaff. I have nothing against joking, and I contribute my fair share of sarcasm, but not all the time. I know that you do contribute valuable stuff, and I appreciate and respect that. But the constant sarcasm, just gets tiring. To be honest, with regard to OCA, it also sometimes feels like you are having a good laugh at the expense of those who are invested and currently underwater. When you (and others) make people feel like dicks for still holding, that has the potential to make us second guess ourselves and possibly make a bad investing decision. It isn't your critical analysis that makes me feel that way. It is the constant sarcasm/winding up.

Or maybe I'm just tired, getting old, and a bitch.

Either way, thank you for accepting my apology.
Well unpacked.

Breezy

Sally Evans adds 61k shares to her collection.

winner (n)

Coffee with a mate today

We chatted about the performance of Summerset and Oceania ......he said Summerset is the Briscoes of the RV sector while Oceania is the Warehouse of the sector

I tried not to laugh

Breezy


winner (n)

Does The Helier allow dogs?

If so they probably have got dog walkers on the payroll.

Greekwatchdog

Just out of interest, how many of you traders bought in at the lows of $0.50???