OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Basil

Quote from: Breezy on Jun 04, 2024, 02:15 PMThe fickleness of the human state up for display here and why not to trust anything written on a random internet forum.
Not at all.  We were all sold a pup. It's just that some people have stopped drinking the OCA cool aid and others still lap up as much as they can

Breezy

#1381
Quote from: Basil on Jun 04, 2024, 02:30 PMNot at all.  We were all sold a pup. It's just that some people have stopped drinking the OCA cool aid and others still lap up as much as they can
Punters also thought they were sold a pup when XRO went from $45 down to $12 before it headed to the ASX, (I was one of them and how wrong i was) the rest as they say is history, there are plenty of other examples as well.

Basil

Nobody gets it right every time. The trick is to get it right most of the time.

winner (n)

Oceania's Underlying NPAT per share over the years

No comment needed

You cannot view this attachment.

Basil

Basically, no growth on average underlying eps of 8 cps.
The problem is inflation has been quite gnarly in recent years and inflation adjust the earnings at listing and compared to current eps, inflation adjusted eps in FY24 is down ~ 30% compared to 7 years ago.  So much for the transformation process that Earl Gasparich told us was going to deliver huge gains after the 6 year program was complete.  Maybe in another 6 years...

I know it's a lot of work Winner, but when you get a chance, no hurry, would you mind doing the same graph for ARV please?

Untamed

Surely, we have done this to death now? Maybe it is time to just chill and wait and see how things go once the new CEO takes over in July. There is literally zero point going over and over history, and what CEO's to date, did or didn't do. CEOs are not unlike politicians. Sometimes they get it right, sometimes they don't, but what is done is done. Investors will either decide to take their money and run, or they will decide to give the new CEO the benefit of the doubt, for X period of time, before making any major decisions.

Perhaps it would be more interesting now, to chat about where we might see her taking the company, what her focus might be etc? I watched a couple of interviews with her, from back when she was with BUPA - couldn't find anything more recent. To be honest, I wasn't overly impressed, but hey, they were just short interviews based on pretty stupid questions from the interviewer, so not exactly a fair depiction of who she is or what she has to offer.

One would hope we have a better idea, by the end of the year.

Whacc

#1386
Quote from: Untamed on Jun 05, 2024, 10:37 AMSurely, we have done this to death now? Maybe it is time to just chill and wait and see how things go once the new CEO takes over in July. There is literally zero point going over and over history, and what CEO's to date, did or didn't do. CEOs are not unlike politicians. Sometimes they get it right, sometimes they don't, but what is done is done. Investors will either decide to take their money and run, or they will decide to give the new CEO the benefit of the doubt, for X period of time, before making any major decisions.


What gets me is we have had the same Chair (and largely the same Board) throughout this period, ultimately they are the ones critiquing this strategy and approving (or as it may be withholding) all spend and/or critical strategic moves. 

Why is it only the CEO coming in for criticism while the Board seems to either get off scot-free or be lauded for their brilliance?

They appear to be very adept at being present when there is a ribbon to be cut then fading into the hedge-work or, worse, pointing the the finger whenever accountability is required.
The Chair showed she is particularly skilled at this competency when she exited the Port.

Untamed

Quote from: Whacc on Jun 05, 2024, 01:05 PMWhat gets me is we have had the same Chair (and largely the same Board) throughout this period, ultimately they are the ones critiquing this strategy and approving (or as it may be withholding) all spend and/or critical strategic moves. 

Why is it only the CEO coming in for criticism while the Board seems to either get off scot-free or be lauded for their brilliance?

They appear to be very adept at being present when there is a ribbon to be cut then fading into the hedge-work or, worse, pointing the the finger whenever accountability is required.
The Chair showed she is particularly skilled at this competency when she exited the Port.

I agree. Personally though, I am not experienced enough to feel at all confident in my ability to judge/rate the various board members. I do know that some trusted posters here, are very supportive of Liz and Greg in particular. Having said that, I hear what you are saying. Brent hasn't been running the show in isolation.

Basil

#1388
Quote from: Untamed on Jun 05, 2024, 01:44 PMI agree. Personally though, I am not experienced enough to feel at all confident in my ability to judge/rate the various board members. I do know that some trusted posters here, are very supportive of Liz and Greg in particular. Having said that, I hear what you are saying. Brent hasn't been running the show in isolation.
Your mate on the other channel gone bush again ?  Unusually quiet after the last result?
QuoteThey appear to be very adept at being present when there is a ribbon to be cut then fading into the hedge-work or, worse, pointing the the finger whenever accountability is required.  The Chair showed she is particularly skilled at this competency when she exited the Port.

If I recall correctly Liz Coutts quit as chairperson of Auckland ports after a death or was it two?, at Auckland Ports.  True story, a friend phoned me and asked if she should face a manslaughter charge for culpable liability?  I told him I wasn't a lawyer and had no idea if liability for alleged breaches of serious safety protocols extended to the board as to whether proper oversight of safety matters was a board responsibility, my best guess is its pretty unlikely. 

Regarding Greg, Heartland Bank also pluming decade lows...seems a lot of respect for him from others so maybe that's just a coincidence.

My 2 cents is that Oceania's board should have woken up and smelled the coffee a LONG time ago that care suite sales uptake was very poor and steered the ship in a different direction.  Remarkable after all these years and an ocean of unsold care suite stock, there's heaps more still being built in FY25.  Serious failure of governance there in my opinion.

Untamed

#1389
Quote from: Basil on Jun 05, 2024, 04:13 PMYour mate on the other channel gone bush again ?  Unusually quiet after the last result?

You are going to wish you hadn't asked me this.

The fact that you even asked it, speaks volumes. Maverick has graciously and generously, shared his work on OCA, for years. He has never once asked for, or expected any gratitude or recognition for it. You, and others, ridiculed and disrespected him at every opportunity. Yet he kept sharing. He is one of the most humble, kind, and respectful posters at ST, and you have treated him like shit. But here you are, looking for another opportunity to make a judgement about his absence, so you can have yet another "go" at him.

You are right about one thing. He is my mate. He has earned my respect and friendship.

You do not deserve access to his contributions.

Basil

#1390
Just a "slight" overreaction lol  Just wondered why he hadn't commented on the last result.


Untamed

#1391
Quote from: Basil on Jun 05, 2024, 04:40 PMLOL what a comical overreaction.  You certainly chose your user name well lol

I did (choose my name well), and it was intentional.

Don't try to make yourself look better by making it about me. You asked me where my mate was, for one reason, and one reason only. It's what you do, and everyone knows it.

You knew exactly what my reaction would be.


Breezy

Lots of ongoing agro on the other channel with this stock and some drunken sailor dredging up old posts, his ramblings are next level and psychotic. Some pretty weird stuff on here as well.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Basil on Jun 05, 2024, 04:13 PMYour mate on the other channel gone bush again ?  Unusually quiet after the last result?
I was wondering the same thing.

Untamed

Quote from: ValueNZ on Jun 06, 2024, 09:31 AMI was wondering the same thing.

ValueNZ, I actually like you, and I think you have a bright future, but please, please, please, don't buy into Basil's BS. You are fairly new here, so you are not fully aware of historical "behaviours." I do not feel at all comfortable speaking for Maverick, but I am not going to sit by and let anyone diss him, in any way whatsoever. Go read my reply to Basil. Maverick has been treated incredibly disrespectfully, for a very long time - by certain people. He has finally realised that he is better to share his work with those of us who appreciate it, than to share it publicly as he was before. Which, is the best possible decision he could make as far as I am concerned.

So no, as it stands right now, "my mate" will not be back at ST, or anywhere else. No doubt you and Basil will choose to read something into that, but that is nothing more than fantasy. I have explained his reasons for no longer posting. Up to you whether you choose to accept and respect that or not.

Be careful. I can tell you from personal experience, that there are people here, and at ST, who are not completely trustworthy. Their number one reason for hanging out at these forums is not the reason you or I hang out. Yes, they do have valuable investing experience to share, but at the end of the day, they hang out in these forums, to feed their egos. That's a truth that you will no doubt have to learn for yourself. But you would do well to heed my warning.