OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Whacc

Quote from: Basil on May 26, 2024, 10:51 AMWhether this is deliberate obfuscation or just generally a really slack and inconsistent approach used by the CFO from one period to another, judge for yourself but my opinion is the accounts are actually extremely messy and complicated even for professionals and analysts to understand and the senior management team do a very, very poor job maintaining consistency with reporting around certain key details of key metrics from one period to another.  That does them absolutely no favours with institutional investors.


For me this is the biggest difference between Earl & Brent.

Earl seemed to have a consistent pack and reported with a consistent format each time, good or bad.

Now the reports just cherry pick the best metrics they can find at each print and as a result it confuses everyone.
Analysts and brokers spend more time searching in vain for figures presented in the last reports to look at trends, then are forced to pivot to whatever framing & smokescreen has been disclosed.

Basil

#1366
Very high quality research released by Ridgewell at Craigs today.
Included the following.
QuoteFor OCA shares to begin to close the c.60% discount to adj NTA ($1.46), and
indeed to remain a going concern, cash generation from existing assets must
improve. With OCA consistently failing to deliver the improvement guided to
by management, it has become a "show me" story.
We see the appointment
of new CEO Suzanne Dvorak (ex Bupa MD) as potentially a positive catalyst
for change, but she will need to deliver quick results to regain investor trust.
Retain Neutral, target price -10% to $0.67[/quote]

For mine, his research is better than anything you will read on either channel.
His rating is neutral.  Reckons it will take 4 years to sell down the Helier.

Forbar doing their best to talk it up seeing as Forsyth Barr Investment management are one of the biggest shareholders with 5%.

Shareguy

Arie at Jardens still negative

Market conditions, high inventory levels and the debt situation are all
reasons to pause while providing more con- fidence on the operating outcomes being generated from OCA's strategy is also key." Jarden target price $0.69. Rated N

winner (n)

Arvida said ' With the assistance of advisors, Arvida is also considering a range of alternative options to accelerate value recognition that includes engaging with other market participants on various capital partnerships, restructuring options and strategic alternatives for the Company.

Is this code for Oceania to merge with Arvida ...that'll be fun

Basil

#1369
Craigs forecasting the following dividends for FY25, FY26 and FY27 0, 0, 0.
RYM and even ARV joined in the zero-dividend policy while stay paying their senior staff huge salaries and bonus's. Hmmm

Mos

Quote from: Basil on May 28, 2024, 04:33 PMCraigs forecasting the following dividends for FY25, FY26 and FY27 0, 0, 0.
RYM and even ARV joined in the zero-dividend policy while stay paying their senior staff huge salaries and bonus's. Hmmm
Dividends don't really make sense in this sector as never imputed. Share buy back at deep discount when cash flow allows would be better for shareholders

Basil

#1371
Agree but OCA too busy extending their balance sheet right out buying more land in front of the Helier, (which itself will take many years to sell down) at top market rates.

Mos

Quote from: Basil on May 28, 2024, 05:42 PMAgree but OCA too busy extending their balance sheet right out buying more land in front of the Helier, (which itself will take many years to sell down) at top market rates.
Sell down has certainly been very slow to date. Good to see some of the lesser assets being sold off which has also taken ages. If they can streamline the portfolio to less than 20 premium villages it would be a more consistent and valuable proposition in my view. Hopefully the new CEO is a sales orientated straight talker.

Whacc

Quote from: Mos on May 28, 2024, 04:52 PMDividends don't really make sense in this sector as never imputed. Share buy back at deep discount when cash flow allows would be better for shareholders

They don't make sense because these are stocks that should be reinvesting for growth given the demographic tailwinds they are building for (the point regarding bonuses is still relevant even though not that material).

This whole confused situation where they are confusing their target investor demographic with their target resident demographic.

Just because you sell residences to old people who prefer yield doesn't mean you should necessarily be selling your stock to those same people.

If these businesses hadn't paid out millions in dividends when the market was buoyant then they wouldn't be contending with the debt burden they have now and could keep developing through the cycle.
Instead they pander & apologise to a greedy superannuitant retail investor cohort who would rather strip their yield out at the expense of longer term profitability.

Basil

#1374
Quote from: Whacc on May 28, 2024, 08:04 PMInstead they pander & apologise to a greedy superannuitant retail investor cohort who would rather strip their yield out at the expense of longer term profitability.
Just commenting on your obvious bias here.  Firstly, at the IPO a big meal was made with OCA and to some extent ARV, that due to the much higher level of care in their business model a feature of bringing these companies to market was that they could afford to pay a very modest dividend.

Its not investors who are greedy it is management trying for ever higher pay rates and bonus's and trying to achieve that by building ever increasing new monuments to their ego that so saturate the market with supply and so lever up the balance sheet to the extreme limit that the companies cannot afford to even feed a single crumb from the table to shareholders while despite this, management gorge themselves on ever increasing salaries and bonuses.

Left Field

#1375
Crikey...............Over on the other channel Value NZ today posted the following bullish OCA 2021 posts from 'guru' posters...... interesting......and a bit scary.... mind you, 2021 was sssooo long ago!

 Originally Posted by winner69

With a booming property market (even the RBNZ wants it to keep going up) and low interest rates and with Oceania's plans coming to fruition the future is bright

For believers in relativity theory OCA share price at least $2.40 next year

YOU CAN'T HAVE TOO MANY OCA


 Originally Posted by winner69
And then we will able say 'we'll never see $1.50 again'

 Originally Posted by winner69
OCA - the share you can't have too many of (unless one has self imposed portfolio weighting limits)

Originally Posted by Beagle
I am comfortable one year hence from here at 18 times forward earnings = 18 x 10.3 cps = $1.85 updated target price early 2022. Over time as they prove their growth rate I expect that multiple will expand to about 20 times as they prove over a number of years they can grow eps at a CAGR of something like 15%. We could see eps of 20 cps in FY26 and the market pricing the company on a forward basis in late 2025 at 20 times that number = ~ $4.
As I said earlier, the real money will be made by those with the patience to hold this for at least 5 years which is what I intend to do.

 Originally Posted by Beagle
If we see strong and reliable growth in OCA's eps in the years ahead, (one broker has FY26 estimated at 19 cps) we could see a PE in the mid 20's applied to that multiple and given the market is always forward looking that opens up the prospect of 25 times 19 cents ($4.75) being recognized as early as 2025.


 Originally Posted by Snow Leopard
Still trades at a discount to what I consider fair value but not cheap enough for me to buy more. It is currently my #3 holding on the NZX

 Originally Posted by Snow Leopard
Fundamentally I value it at $1.68 right here, right now, with a modest $1.71 for a year hence.



 

"The difficulty lies not in new ideas... but in escaping from old ideas." (J M Keynes.)

Basil

#1376
Just shows what an extremely disappointing company this has been.
Sold most of mine more than 2 years ago at $1.40 and made heaps of posts since then explaining why and warning what a dog this is. 
Bit disingenuous to post comments from several years ago without posting more recent posts from the same people.


winner (n)

Leftie .....that guy and his mates over on the other place are only trying to comfort/convince themselves that OCA is the greatest thing since sliced bread ...and can't understand why the share price is where it is ......although the cheaper the better lol

Breezy

Quote from: Left Field on Jun 04, 2024, 01:37 PMCrikey...............Over on the other channel Value NZ today posted the following bullish OCA 2021 posts from 'guru' posters...... interesting......and a bit scary.... mind you, 2021 was sssooo long ago!

 Originally Posted by winner69

With a booming property market (even the RBNZ wants it to keep going up) and low interest rates and with Oceania's plans coming to fruition the future is bright

For believers in relativity theory OCA share price at least $2.40 next year

YOU CAN'T HAVE TOO MANY OCA


 Originally Posted by winner69
And then we will able say 'we'll never see $1.50 again'

 Originally Posted by winner69
OCA - the share you can't have too many of (unless one has self imposed portfolio weighting limits)

Originally Posted by Beagle
I am comfortable one year hence from here at 18 times forward earnings = 18 x 10.3 cps = $1.85 updated target price early 2022. Over time as they prove their growth rate I expect that multiple will expand to about 20 times as they prove over a number of years they can grow eps at a CAGR of something like 15%. We could see eps of 20 cps in FY26 and the market pricing the company on a forward basis in late 2025 at 20 times that number = ~ $4.
As I said earlier, the real money will be made by those with the patience to hold this for at least 5 years which is what I intend to do.

 Originally Posted by Beagle
If we see strong and reliable growth in OCA's eps in the years ahead, (one broker has FY26 estimated at 19 cps) we could see a PE in the mid 20's applied to that multiple and given the market is always forward looking that opens up the prospect of 25 times 19 cents ($4.75) being recognized as early as 2025.


 Originally Posted by Snow Leopard
Still trades at a discount to what I consider fair value but not cheap enough for me to buy more. It is currently my #3 holding on the NZX

 Originally Posted by Snow Leopard
Fundamentally I value it at $1.68 right here, right now, with a modest $1.71 for a year hence.



 


The fickleness of the human state up for display here and why not to trust anything written on a random internet forum.

Left Field

Quote from: winner (n) on Jun 04, 2024, 02:02 PMLeftie .....that guy and his mates over on the other place are only trying to comfort/convince themselves that OCA is the greatest thing since sliced bread ...and can't understand why the share price is where it is ......although the cheaper the better lol

Of course it's all about the motives of the poster...... begs the Q.... what was your motive back in 2021?
"The difficulty lies not in new ideas... but in escaping from old ideas." (J M Keynes.)