OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Breezy

Quote from: Gerald on May 24, 2024, 01:33 PMThat's like saying your neighbour shouldn't point out your house is in fire.


I see no fire here just a gentle flame.

Shareguy

Further from Craig's today

Ridgewell notes net bank debt is now $633m and worse than management guidance for debt to be flat or down at the interim result. - OCA is paying a very low effective interest rate on its borrowings, less than 3% in FY24, which is providing is supporting its compliance with bank covenants. This is a credit to OCA's finance team who locked in low rates long term during Covid, however these facilities reset FY28. If these facilities were to be reset to market rates of 6-7% today, we estimate OCA would be in breach...........

Untamed

#1352
Quote from: Shareguy on May 24, 2024, 05:20 PMFurther from Craig's today

Ridgewell notes net bank debt is now $633m and worse than management guidance for debt to be flat or down at the interim result. - OCA is paying a very low effective interest rate on its borrowings, less than 3% in FY24, which is providing is supporting its compliance with bank covenants. This is a credit to OCA's finance team who locked in low rates long term during Covid, however these facilities reset FY28. If these facilities were to be reset to market rates of 6-7% today, we estimate OCA would be in breach...........

So? FY28 is a long way out, and there is plenty of water to flow under the bridge between now and then. This kind of hypothetical musing, is meaningless. Craig's giving praise with one hand and taking it away with the other.

Breezy

Quote from: Untamed on May 24, 2024, 05:24 PMSo? FY28 is a long way out, and there is plenty of water to flow under the bridge between now and then. This kind of hypothetical musing, is meaningless. Craig's giving praise with one hand and taking it away with the other.
I'd take Craigs with a grain of salt, they are no better than your average punter at predicting anything.

Left Field

The big question is whether OCA's result means the Warriors will win this weekend?
"The difficulty lies not in new ideas... but in escaping from old ideas." (J M Keynes.)

Whacc

lol, Brent getting his largest STI so far - $390k (pg 86 of annual report)

For doing what???

Buzz

Quote from: Whacc on May 24, 2024, 07:01 PMlol, Brent getting his largest STI so far - $390k (pg 86 of annual report)

For doing what???

How about answering that yourself? Tell us what business metrics have improved since Pattison took over from Gasparich, and for balance which have declined.
Age is not a good measure of ability

Whacc

#1357
Quote from: Buzz on May 24, 2024, 07:20 PMHow about answering that yourself? Tell us what business metrics have improved since Pattison took over from Gasparich, and for balance which have declined.

Are you serious?

If my understanding is correct, his incentives are (& payments should be) based on TSR and Underlying EBITDA growth.

Both those metrics have been dire under him.  The stock is trading well below IPO if you need reminding.

All the earnings 'growth' metrics presented yesterday were off a small base and paper off the fact they had been torpedoed over the past couple of years.

Aside from that his accomplishments were a couple of small acquisitions and hasn't provided any proof they have been accretive.

He has managed to turn over pretty much an entire executive team and some.

Other than that he hasn't sold down completed stock and as a result racked up far higher gearing than Earl, beyond the Board's long stated target range.


Did I miss a great redeeming factor?

Basil

#1358
Yes, you missed that he very successfully lead the company into a position where it can't afford to pay a single cent in dividends to shareholders. That's surely worth double the pay Earl was on plus a huge bonus lol

Mos

Quote from: Whacc on May 24, 2024, 07:01 PMlol, Brent getting his largest STI so far - $390k (pg 86 of annual report)

For doing what???

Negotiated exit package?

Basil

#1360
For those that don't know, there's a full transcript of the analysts call on the other channel and it appears there's lots of confusion with the financial accounts...there's a big surprise lol.  It would seem they are selling some care suites on credit terms.  There seems to be a lot of confusion about the debt level and how come its grown.  Also a lot of confusion about unsold stock level's, reported number has gone down from first half number but the number built in the second half exceeded the number sold in that half.  Winner suggested obfuscation.  Its either that or a real dog's breakfast, or more likely some combination of that.

The only value I can add to that debate is to me it seems quite clear that at the first half result in late November they showed a graphic of unsold stock and separately identified numbers which were temporarily occupied as premium room accommodation.  At the full year result the unsold numbers were down because they no longer included unsold stock temporarily occupied under premium daily rate.

Whether this is deliberate obfuscation or just generally a really slack and inconsistent approach used by the CFO from one period to another, judge for yourself but my opinion is the accounts are actually extremely messy and complicated even for professionals and analysts to understand and the senior management team do a very, very poor job maintaining consistency with reporting around certain key details of key metrics from one period to another.  That does them absolutely no favours with institutional investors.

The increase in debt level is again concerning but it appears they are clearly in "tapering off development mode" and will be reducing their build rate in the future in line with how RYM and ARV are doing this to try and stop their debt going up.  I think new unit deliveries in FY26 and FY27 will be quite modest.  The impact of that on profit in future years remains to be seen.

Management seems confident that returns on care beds are improving and I acknowledge they have made decent progress with the reduction is basic care services, in terms of the number of beds with basic care villages sold or closed which is encouraging but there is a long way to go.
My view is that in certain respects the company has been very poorly lead and governed in the last few years.  Even in FY25, despite hundreds of new unsold care suites they are still building heaps more of them.  With proper leadership that simply wouldn't be happening.  From the call, thankfully it would seem FY25 is the last year for quite some time that vast amounts of new care suites will be built.

Interesting comment from Brent that the new CEO has a lot of "cleaning" to do.  Can't help wondering what "cleaning" really means ?  Like others on the other channel, I think he has "checked out" already.

Conclusion:  I think this looks okay to me as a bondholder and the level of debt will gradually start to come down in the years ahead.    Shareholders can make their own minds up but for me, this seems anchored in the sub 50% of NTA zone until such time as they can clearly execute on a greatly enhanced volume of new unit sales.  Forbar have been picking 275 for FY25, up nearly 50%.  That looks like fantasy land stuff to me with the housing market in the sombre state it's in.   

One thing that really caught my eye on the call was only 13 confirmed apartment sales at the Helier out of (from memory 72 apartments) and that's with all the pre-construction sales hype, opening a sales office in St Heliers and Brent previously assuring shareholders they had really good levels of enquiry.
Given the very best north facing units with sea views always sell quickly to cashed up MINO's (money is no object) I think its going to be a very long hard slog to sell the other 59 units.

Maybe the new CEO brings a new approach that generates better results or maybe just even more ESG focus...time will tell.   
Disc: Bondholder,, no shares held.. 

Just some of my thoughts.  If others see it very differently that's absolutely fine and good luck.   



snapiti

thanks for your well thought out "thoughts" Mr Beagle.
Not unusual for a company struggling to use a lot of smoke n mirrors.
Some, like yourself, see why they use this sort of reporting style.
Plenty hung up on the fact that care suites are a necessity rather than a choice, they are right of course, but many have had tunnel vision based on this and failed to see the other strong macro factors that are at play.
Long term this be be a winner but entry timing is gonna be key.......suspect now is not the time to enter
 
never buy or sell shares driven by emotion, show conviction to your purchases

Untamed

Does anyone know where I can download the full transcript? I can't see it on the OCA website anywhere.

Greekwatchdog

For Bars Review by Andrew Ibbotson

OUTPERFORM


Oceania Healthcare (OCA) reported an in-line result at our annuity EBITDA line and a decent beat at the volatile new sales gain line. We see the results as a side show to the broader issues of: (1) too much debt; (2) capital raise concerns; and (3) long-term cash generation and profitability. On the first two issues we believe OCA got the message and appears to be targeting a dramatic reduction in capex. Capex declined by ~-NZ$50m sequentially in 2H24, and we estimate investing cash flow for the next three years to be ~NZ$100m annually, half the previous three years. This will result in a substantial decline in new unit deliveries in FY26 and FY27, but the associated ~NZ$300m lower net debt is far more important for the investment case. With assets ~7x its market value of equity, lowering debt rather than growing assets should be the focus — profitability should follow. We reiterate our OUTPERFORM rating with an increased target price of NZ$1.00.

What's changed?
Earnings: Increased annuity EBITDA +2%/+5%/+3% and underlying earnings +12%/+18%/+1% over FY25/FY26/FY27
Target price: Increased to NZ$1.00, due to lower net debt and increased earnings offsetting lower dividends.
The Helier appears to be performing well — a young portfolio should command a higher earnings multiple
The most significant surprise versus our estimates was OCA's expectation to have recovered all capex for its flagship development, The Helier, by the end of FY25. OCA has fallen short on its expectations before, but this suggests a reduced tail risk. More broadly, 85% of OCA's book value of assets now come from sites developed or acquired since 2017. A young and not fully sold down portfolio under earns today but should deliver stronger growth going forward. We estimate that OCA has the lowest level of resales relative to independent living units (ILUs) and the largest gap between ILU new and resale prices in the sector. Both point to growth ahead.


Signs are accumulating that we are through the worst in care
OCA reported care EBITDA from ongoing operations ~+8% ahead of our estimates, up ~+15% year-on-year in 2H24. This was driven by a combination of daily care fees growing ahead of staff expenses for the first time since listing, and continued growth in DMF and resale gains. One swallow does not a summer make, but we forecast care margins to expand meaningfully from here.


The aged care companies have a credibility issue with regards to non-GAAP disclosure; OCA did not help itself
Non-GAAP measures make up ~80% to 90% of through the cycle 'underlying earnings' for the major listed aged care operators. Consequently, the quality, consistency and accuracy of these many non-GAAP disclosures is crucial. At 1H24 OCA stated that it had 409 new units 'currently available for sale' and 382 'additional units currently under construction'. As it turns out, rectified but not highlighted at this result, OCA counted ~100 units that were delivered in 2H24 in both categories.

Basil

Quote from: Greekwatchdog on May 27, 2024, 07:41 AMTarget price: Increased to NZ$1.00, due to lower net debt and increased earnings offsetting lower dividends.
Are they still assuming a "miraculous" 50% increase in property sales to about 275 units this year as a key assumption supporting their thesis ?