OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Azz

Quote from: Ferg on May 09, 2024, 09:43 PMThe amounting owing to the client's estate being ORA #1 less fees is repaid with the cash proceeds from the sale of ORA #2.  ORA #2 is repaid (less fees) at some future unknown date using the cash proceeds from the sale of ORA #3 and so on.  Yes there is a future obligation - no one is denying that.  If there was no certainty of future customers lining up to live in a safe, caring and sociable environment then the business would fail the 'going concern' test - then the directors, staff, bankers, customers/residents and investors would all run for the hills.  Are you seeing this happening?  I'm not.

Overlay macro factors such as growth in the number of elderly people, longer expected lives and the Western trend whereby most dwellings have 1 or 2 generations living in them (as opposed to 3 or maybe even 4), and we have an increasing demand for the services offered by RVs.  This will continue until the local population goes into decline and/or there are some fundamental shifts to the macro factors mentioned.

BTW the 30% doesn't just pay for the refurbishment of the unit, it also pays ongoing wages, maintenance and other bills that make the village a community.  This is what the resident is buying - a community and not being alone.  Your suggestion for a business to invest capital to build facilities but only be paid the 30% upfront for an unknown duration is not a business that will make money.....that is a charity.

Yes I get it is not *fair* to surviving family members, but the resident knows exactly what they are doing and what they are getting for their money.  And it is no-one else's business.  Commentary around 'spending kids inheritance' is outright wrong, and unbelievably entitled.

The expectation the business continues on the basis of attracting new business is not unique to RVs.  That IS pretty much ALL business.  You haven't explained why this issue is unique to RVs.

Also, everyone knows each ORA has to be repaid at some point in the future - no one cannot see this. The macro factors suggest there will be many people lining up for many years (or many decades?) to come.  Will it fail at some point where ORAs cannot be repaid?  Sure - that will be the day we no longer have a sizable elderly population and/or the elderly are living with extended family.  So you have a point there but you are missing the other macro factor being the current low levels of penetration - the percentage of elderly population that currently occupy a unit in a RV is very low.

The problem with every single ponzi in history is that at a certain point the new debt - to pay off the old debt - cannot be found. Maybe this one will be different...........

I'm very suspicious of OCA's unsold stock level, which in a normal environment would be described as "high, and they need to pull out the stops and get selling".

But I think it's becoming difficult for OCA to juggle two conflicting things:

* They need to sell the built stock of new units to receive in "cashflow"; but:
* ...Each new ORA adds a massive new debt.

It's catch-22.

The stress must be horrific at the top levels of leadership.
~~ I thought I was a genius but couldn't follow simple instructions. I find it hard to work with others and accept the idea someone can have a different opinion to mine, now all I am is a distant meeeemooorrrryyyyyy (ghost sounds) ~~

Waltzing

well the next FA result and the next, next one after that.... and add Infinitum will either confirm your theory or there wont be a run on the banks...

Administrator

After numerous warnings went unheeded, Azz has been permanently banned for trolling in this thread. Please continue any further discussion about retirement villages in the context of inheritance, in the lifestyle category. I have deleted certain posts where appropriate to reduce the mess.

Breezy

Quote from: Administrator on May 09, 2024, 10:05 PMAfter numerous warnings went unheeded, Azz has been permanently banned for trolling in this thread. Please continue any further discussion about retirement villages in the context of inheritance, in the lifestyle category. I have deleted certain posts where appropriate to reduce the mess.
Many Thanks.

winner (n)

Maybe Oceania need to convert some unsold villas into community houses -

He's "lucky" to now flat with 11 other seniors in a community house provided by registered charity Abbeyfield, which has 14 homes across Aotearoa.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/nz-news

Basil

#1295
I think a very good solution to the hundreds of unsold care suites is to convert them into low cost independent living units.  Not everyone has the ability to purchase a $700K+ ILU 2-bedroom apartment and I think there's a big market for ILU suites in the $400K area.  A lot of older single people, all they want is a 35 sq meter or thereabouts, quality smaller apartment. 
Hopefully a new CEO can zoom out and take a high level helicopter view of the ocean of unsold care suite stock and make some changes.

Untamed

If you do that, you immediately remove the ability to provide any continuity of care, barring the minimal number of government subsidised, standard care beds.

But of course, you don't care about that.

Quote from: Basil on May 10, 2024, 10:13 AMI think a very good solution to the hundreds of unsold care suites is to convert them into low cost independent living units.  Not everyone has the ability to purchase a $700K+ ILU 2-bedroom apartment and I think there's a big market for ILU suites in the $400K area.  A lot of older single people, all they want is a 35 sq meter or thereabouts, quality smaller apartment. 
Hopefully a new CEO can zoom out and take a high level helicopter view of the ocean of unsold care suite stock and make some changes.

Basil

#1297
Quote from: Untamed on May 10, 2024, 10:22 AMIf you do that, you immediately remove the ability to provide any continuity of care, barring the minimal number of government subsidised, standard care beds.

But of course, you don't care about that.

You've got the wrong end of the stick...as is not unusual in respect to my posts.  To be clear, what i am suggesting is there is probably quite a bit of mileage in right sizing their care offer.  For example, at Lady Allum village in Milford they have built over 100 care suites and that's likely to take an exceptionally long time to fill, probably several years.  Maybe they should try selling half of them as small ILU apartments.  There's very few facilities at that village for ILU living but maybe the location does it for people at a certain price point.  Not far to Takapuna beach or Lake Pupuke.

You will see later this month the effect of having hundreds of unfilled units when they report their annual result and I predict it won't be pretty.  I know you fancy yourself as an altruistic investor investing for the care and that makes you feel good and all that and you're not alone but most people expect the company to try and optimize returns for shareholders.  Efficient use of capital and providing good care are not mutually exclusive activities...just need a CEO that better understands the balance.

I do wonder if it's time for some board changes as well as the CEO.  Maybe Liz Coutts should also go ?

BlackPeter

Quote from: Basil on May 10, 2024, 10:28 AM...
  To be clear, what i am suggesting is there is probably quite a bit of mileage in right sizing their care offer.  For example, at Lady Allum village in Milford they have built over 100 care suites and that's likely to take an exceptionally long time to fill, probably several years.  Maybe they should try selling half of them as small ILU apartments.  There's very few facilities at that village for ILU living but maybe the location does it for people at a certain price point.  Not far to Takapuna beach or Lake Pupuke.

I'd agree with that. If care units are empty, than they clearly are in no way helping to reduce the care crisis.

So - absolutely, why not turn empty care units into needed ILU's? Sounds like a win-win to me.

Buzz

Quote from: BlackPeter on May 10, 2024, 10:36 AMI'd agree with that. If care units are empty, than they clearly are in no way helping to reduce the care crisis.

So - absolutely, why not turn empty care units into needed ILU's? Sounds like a win-win to me.

As a shareholder I'd be against it, as it is in effect selling care suites at a massive discount.
Age is not a good measure of ability

Basil

#1300
Quote from: Buzz on May 10, 2024, 10:55 AMAs a shareholder I'd be against it, as it is in effect selling care suites at a massive discount.
I get you think that, but the DMF is similar but with less churn...then again if you can't sell them in the first place there is no care suite DMF or churn. 

Buzz

Quote from: Basil on May 10, 2024, 11:01 AMI get you think that, but the DMF is similar but with less churn...then again if you can't sell them in the first place there is no care suite DMF or churn. 

You lost me there, how can 30% DMF of a much smaller ORA be similar to the DMF if sold at marketed prices? I presume also that the entry age would be a lot younger as it's not a care suite anymore and the churn could move out by many years?

Anyway, it's an interesting thought to ponder, as you say, selling them for something is better than not selling them at all.
Age is not a good measure of ability

BlackPeter

Quote from: Buzz on May 10, 2024, 10:55 AMAs a shareholder I'd be against it, as it is in effect selling care suites at a massive discount.

Quote from: Basil on May 10, 2024, 11:01 AMI get you think that, but the DMF is similar but with less churn...then again if you can't sell them in the first place there is no care suite DMF or churn. 

Exactly.

Clearly - if they can sell it as care unit, than they should. Makes a lot of (not just) economic sense.

However - if it is just unsold stock, collecting dust (and eating unproductive capital) than I as a shareholder would want them to turn these units into ILU's (or whatever brings some return). Obviously - when the care tsunami happens to arrive, then there is nothing stopping them to turn them back into care units as soon as the ILU residents depart. Some of them might even benefit from a conversion back to care while they live there. Could be an additional sales argument for the ILU's ...

BlackPeter

Quote from: Buzz on May 10, 2024, 11:29 AMYou lost me there, how can 30% DMF of a much smaller ORA be similar to the DMF if sold at marketed prices? I presume also that the entry age would be a lot younger as it's not a care suite anymore and the churn could move out by many years?


ORA for ILU's is typically higher than ORA for care suites. On the other hand do care suites have an average churn of 3 years and ILU's 8 years - which tends to balance the issue out.

Basil

#1304
Quote from: Buzz on May 10, 2024, 11:29 AMYou lost me there, how can 30% DMF of a much smaller ORA be similar to the DMF if sold at marketed prices? I presume also that the entry age would be a lot younger as it's not a care suite anymore and the churn could move out by many years?

If it takes about 3 years to sell a care suite, then it's occupied for 3 years and takes another 3 years to resell and given both care suite and ILU are 30% DMF I'm not sure there's much in it either way, ILU or care suite from a DMF perspective.  More important at this stage to simply get them sold and get the debt down.
Have seen Lady Allum care suites advertised for circa $375K on Trade Me before, maybe a slightly higher price could be asked for ILU living?

What about letting the customer choose what support they want with the unit using the time honored successful selling strategy that the customer is always right and allowing people to chose what level of support they start with and then being flexible to meet their needs as they get older.
Just noticed this is what Arvida are doing https://www.trademe.co.nz/a/property/retirement-villages/auckland/auckland-city/epsom/listing/4652308801
Excerpt: This studio apartment has been designed with comfort and convenience in mind. Better still, we offer varying levels of support – from fully independent, to assisted living, to full rest home care – all from your apartment. So you can relax knowing support is on hand.  Surely tweaking their business model a bit to allow some of this sort of flexibility makes sense with hundreds of unsold care suites...