OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Untamed

#1305
Quote from: Basil on May 10, 2024, 10:28 AMI know you fancy yourself as an altruistic investor investing for the care and that makes you feel good and all that ...

Wrong. Nothing altruistic, or "feel good" about it at all. I invest in a company that provides care, because care is what I know and understand. Sometimes that, is actually more important as an investor, than simply being a financial whizz.

You might understand property/real estate, but you do not understand care. Which is why you have tunnel vision and cannot understand that an RV without a care component, and continuity of care, won't cut the mustard in the future. Down the track however, when you quite possibly may require some level of care yourself, you will finally understand what I've been trying to explain - when the RVs have all ditched care (because of lack of government support), and the only option you have is a standard rest home bed in a NFP rest home. Assuming of course, any of those still exist.

Basil

#1306
I've lost count of the number of times I've said it's about right sizing the care side of operations so all stakeholders do well. 
Even OCA themselves are trying to do this.   

Untamed

#1307
Yes, you have, and your suggestion has some merit but if OCA decides to convert some care suites into IL apartments (which is what they would be, as the care suites are arranged in the building as apartments are), they are committing those care suites to that designation, for an indefinite period of time. If the demand for care suites then increases, those suites are no longer available for that purpose. So "right sizing" the care offerings is not as simple as it may seem.

In addition to that, care suites, as we know, are designed specifically for continuity of care, with room design, and equipment oriented towards the resident needing an increasing level of care assistance for the rest of their life, in most cases. Independent living units, by definition, are for people who require no assistance. So are you going to tie up a purpose built "care" suite, with someone who may be in their early seventies who quite possibly won't need any assistance for another ten years? If demand for care suites increases over the next year or two, is OCA going to have to turn people away, because they panicked and turned some into ILU as you are suggesting?

As far as "stakeholders doing well" goes, anyone who buys any RV, looking to make a quick buck, is investing in the wrong sector. Those who are willing to hang in there for the long term, will do OK. None of these RVs are going bust. They are all ticking along, doing what they do, and at some point things will turn around. But if they lose sight of the importance of care/continuity of care, it will be a different story.

Anyway, enough for today.


Quote from: Basil on May 10, 2024, 01:54 PMI've lost count of the number of times I've said it's about right sizing the care side of operations so all stakeholders do well. 
Even OCA themselves are trying to do this.   

Untamed

For anyone who is interested, I actually received a response from OCA re my email asking for clarification re occupancy rates.

" Thanks for your enquiry, happy to clarify this for you.

Occupancy rates are a metric used by Oceania in relation to care only – that includes both care suites (occupied by residents under an ORA) and standard care beds combined. We provide the occupancy rates in our care portfolio in our biannual results presentations and reports, for example see Appendix 3 of our 1HY2024 results released in November 2023


Which backs up Black Peter's recent comments that OCAs last reported occupancy rate, is only marginally lower than SUM's.

Interestingly, the email I received came from an "investor" email address which I have never seen before, so maybe they have decided it is time to "do better."

winner (n)

Quote from: Untamed on May 11, 2024, 09:06 AMFor anyone who is interested, I actually received a response from OCA re my email asking for clarification re occupancy rates.

" Thanks for your enquiry, happy to clarify this for you.

Occupancy rates are a metric used by Oceania in relation to care only – that includes both care suites (occupied by residents under an ORA) and standard care beds combined. We provide the occupancy rates in our care portfolio in our biannual results presentations and reports, for example see Appendix 3 of our 1HY2024 results released in November 2023


Which backs up Black Peter's recent comments that OCAs last reported occupancy rate, is only marginally lower than SUM's.

Interestingly, the email I received came from an "investor" email address which I have never seen before, so maybe they have decided it is time to "do better."

Thanks untamed

Glad I was correct lol

Untamed


Basil

I am happy with the way I have calculated the seriousness of their unsold stock situation and the methodology used including ILU units. Analysts are right to be concerned about their "ocean of unsold stock", their words not mine. 


Untamed

Ok, so can you please explain to me, how a 91% occupancy rate (which is what I think it was at last report) of care suites and standard care beds, equates to an "ocean of unsold stock?"

Unless I am mistaken, your focus has always been on poor sales of care suites, not ILUs. Hence our previous conversation about the possibility of converting unsold suites to apartments. But this clarification from OCA shows that care suites are obviously selling. If we hear in a couple of weeks, that the occupancy rate has increased from that figure, then clearly care suites are a success story, not the bane of all evil, that you would like us to believe they are.

I note however, that you have amended your usual narrative to include ILU units, in the "unsold stock" situation. If it is ILU's that are not selling, maybe they should convert a few to care suites  ;)

Quote from: Basil on May 11, 2024, 09:48 AMI am happy with the way I have calculated the seriousness of their unsold stock situation and the methodology used including ILU units. Analysts are right to be concerned about their "ocean of unsold stock", their words not mine. 



Basil

#1313
Quote from: Untamed on May 11, 2024, 10:06 AMOk, so can you please explain to me, how a 91% occupancy rate (which is what I think it was at last report) of care suites and standard care beds, equates to an "ocean of unsold stock?"
I have already fully explained it.  If you haven't got it by now, you're not going to.  If you're serious about trying to understand it go back to the debate I had with BP about it, read the half year presentation available on the NZX which stated the number of unsold units and re-read my posts.  It's all in there but it would probably help if you opened both eyes 😉...or you could choose to not do the work and pretend there isn't a stock problem and it's going to recover to $1 by Christmas and good luck with that.

Untamed

Quote from: Basil on May 11, 2024, 10:20 AMI have already fully explained it.  If you haven't got it by now, you're not going to.

Ditto!

Basil

I've actually done a lot of work to understand why the company is struggling.  I trust my own work.

Untamed

#1316
Quote from: Basil on May 11, 2024, 10:28 AMI've actually done a lot of work to understand why the company is struggling.  I trust my own work.

I am sure you have, and I respect that. I am well aware that I have literally nothing to offer with respect to discussions about financials, so I actually do value what you contribute as far as financials go. All I have to offer, is my knowledge of the process of ageing, and aged care in general. Along with my personal experience, and anecdotal evidence, as someone working in the sector. Caregivers are the people on the ground, caring for and supporting our elderly. We are the ones who genuinely know our residents - much more so than nurses or managers. We see what is broken. We see what works well. I share some of that here, in the hope that people will perhaps see the RV sector from a different perspective to simply that of "investor."

I do have an emotional stake in my RV investment but not because I am a woke, touchy feely do-gooder. It is because the business is about caring for people. Human beings. Someone's Mum or Dad, or Nana or Grandad, and I believe OCA provides that care well. It is very easy to just have a chuckle at my posts, roll your eyes and mutter about me being in it for altruistic reasons, but I can tell you this. When you are in a rest home or care suite, the caregiver that I am, is the caregiver you will hope for.

By the way, just as an aside. Last week, we sent two residents on to facilities with higher levels of care (hospital and dementia). We have a third transfer pending. Three of our "family" who consider our rest home, their "home." Three people whose lives, relationships, friendships and security, are being uprooted - because we are not resourced to provide continuity of care. Two of them left without me even having a chance to say goodbye. They will be well cared for where they are going, just as they were with us. But sometimes that move, can be the catalyst to a downward spiral in health and/or emotional well-being. It is not uncommon for us to hear that someone who recently moved, has died. Often within weeks of leaving us. Sure, sometimes it is due to their health condition, but sometimes it is not .... :(

I stand by my prediction that continuity of care will become the number one selling point for RVs.

Time to get outside and enjoy the day.


Basil

#1317
I am sure you find your job incredibly rewarding from a people perspective and its great there are people like you prepared to put their heart and soul into their work for modest pay.  I'm happy to take you at your word that you do your best for the people you care for.  When my time comes, I hope I receive the care I need from dedicated hard working caregivers who genuinely care about their residents. 

Like many, I started off investing in OCA in the belief the business transformation program Earl Gasparich so eloquently outlined would be a program that not only provided great levels of care and excellent LIU living but also would be a company that would be very rewarding to own as a shareholder.  I remember early on, the time I organised a share trader meeting down at the Viaduct and many of us enjoyed a fabulous day out getting drunk in the sun and toasting our future success with OCA when it was ~ $1 and the saying of the day was "Oceania, you can't have too many" I think every time we said that it was compulsory to toast and have another drink lol.  Disappointingly, that is just a distant fond memory from many years ago.

Over the seven years I have watched, studied and intensely analyzed OCA to the point it would give me bad headaches, I have yet to see any evidence whatsoever that the transformation program is working in terms of improving returns.  Quite the opposite in fact and I think the market is quite correctly pricing the stock where it is, also for ARV and RYM for different reasons. 

I think the whole sector faces serious headwinds, (posted more thoughts on that in the general retirement thread earlier today).  Unfortunately, those in the sector who provide the highest level's of care face the most serious headwinds.  As a bondholder, (and I have quite a few), I do have concerns about the level of their gearing, (highest in the sector), and am mystified as to why they would announce a targeted build rate for FY25 some 50% higher than the run rate they have previously been selling at given they have record level's of unsold stock already on hand.  As an accountant that's been advising clients for over 40 years this makes no sense to me.  Perhaps more information and / or explanations will be forthcoming when they report later this month.

 

Untamed

As per my previous post, if anyone ever wants to contact OCA with queries, this is the email address to use:

investor@oceaniahealthcare.co.nz

TGB

That address has been around for yonks fyi. If you search it with double quotes around it "investor@oceaniahealthcare.co.nz"

It comes up on releases going back a few years