Main Menu

MFB - My Food Bag

Started by nztx, Jun 25, 2022, 02:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Basil

#105
QuoteThis article resonated with me back in 2007 and still stands today. What do you think? Should this be a topic of study in business? Winner

Yes, absolutely as this cuts right to the core of the culture of any new start up.  Every business has to some extent a process of trail and error, finding what works and what doesn't and learnings from being stupid is vitally important.  If we can't learn from our mistakes how are we going to learn ?

Would make a great high level investment analysis paper.  The science of train wrecks 301.
There are always so many learnings every time a listed company hits the rocks I think that's why I find them so fascinating.
It has been said the definition of insanity is to keep doing the same thing over and over and to expect to get a different result.

I think its easier to learn from examples of companies that made mistakes than any other way.
The problem with highly successful companies is they're often not that keen to share the recipe of the secret sauce that made them so successful.
I reckon if you study train wrecks long enough you get to learn how to keep your own train on the tracks chugging along just fine.

Left Field

Quote from: Basil on Sep 10, 2022, 07:16 PMEvery business has to some extent a process of trail and error, finding what works and what doesn't and learnings from being stupid is vitally important.  If we can't learn from our mistakes how are we going to learn ?

I recall in the mid 1980's when almost any NZX IPO was a guaranteed instant success for early investors (or stags as they were known.) Then came the 'crash' of Oct 10th 1987 and many of the then successful IPO's slowly disappeared.

Since that time the success of NZX IPO's has by my estimation been at best 50/50 (I would like to see more recent stats on the success ratio of NZX IPO's??? )

My current investment rule is to avoid the 'hype' of IPO's and this has worked fine for me. Best to wait for a company to prove itself IMO.

"The difficulty lies not in new ideas... but in escaping from old ideas." (J M Keynes.)

KW

The train wrecks usually get made into tv/movies, so pretty easy to study them.  If anyone wants some good summer TV viewing I highly recommend The Dropout (Theranos), We Crashed (WeWork) and Super Pumped (Uber).  If you watch them simultaneously you will see many cross overs and similarities between the three companies. 

But the study of stupidity is really the field of Behavioural Finance.  There you can study all the irrational things that humans do that are self defeating and self sabotaging.  I highly recommend everyone does a Behaviour Finance course like this one https://www.coursera.org/learn/duke-behavioral-finance  (its free)
Don't drink and buy shares in a downtrend, you bloody idiot.

Ferg

Quote from: KW on Sep 11, 2022, 10:28 AMI highly recommend everyone does a Behaviour Finance course like this one https://www.coursera.org/learn/duke-behavioral-finance  (its free)

Have you done that course?  I was about to sign up and then decided to read some reviews:
https://www.coursera.org/learn/duke-behavioral-finance/reviews?page=1&sort=recent&star=1

KW

#109
Quote from: Ferg on Sep 11, 2022, 10:45 AMHave you done that course?  I was about to sign up and then decided to read some reviews:
https://www.coursera.org/learn/duke-behavioral-finance/reviews?page=1&sort=recent&star=1

Yes, I've done it.  I passed with between 72-93% scores on the tests.  Going from the reviews, one has to be mindful that (a) its a University level course, and (b) its Duke University so complaining its not easy, or the reading materials are complex, or that it should be dumbed down for beginners, is not particularly useful.  Just take your time, and if in doubt, use Google to do further reading on the subject before (or while) attempting the quizzes.  It does power through the course in 3 weeks and probably could do with more detail in each section, but its enough to give you a good overview of the things that matter.

(If you are only going to read the 1 star reviews you will get a negative impression, but the course has far more 4 and 5 star reviews than 1 star ones.)
Don't drink and buy shares in a downtrend, you bloody idiot.

Ferg

Thanks for the feedback.  And you obviously recommend it otherwise you would not have posted it!

Quote from: KW on Sep 11, 2022, 02:46 PMIf you are only going to read the 1 star reviews you will get a negative impression, but the course has far more 4 and 5 star reviews than 1 star ones.

A fair comment. Typically I find out more from negative reviews than a slew of 5 star "great" reviews (Which could be bots for all I know) but one has to keep in mind the author and maybe not everyone is cut out for tertiary learning.

Mousehold

Quote from: Ferg on Sep 12, 2022, 03:34 PMTypically I find out more from negative reviews than a slew of 5 star "great" reviews (Which could be bots for all I know) ....

I'm just the same with shows on IMDB...

Hectorplains

I dunno much about MFB.  However; all three "meal kit stocks' on the ASX are stuck in epic down trends.  MFB is at an all time low today, MMM and MBX are also loitering around their lows.  The whole sector is a dog's dinner and there are no signs of the sentiment changing any time soon. 

Basil

Quote from: Hectorplains on Sep 12, 2022, 08:30 PMI dunno much about MFB.  However; all three "meal kit stocks' on the ASX are stuck in epic down trends.  MFB is at an all time low today, MMM and MBX are also loitering around their lows.  The whole sector is a dog's dinner and there are no signs of the sentiment changing any time soon. 

Definitely not time to "tuck in" anytime soon. 

KW

Quote from: Ferg on Sep 12, 2022, 03:34 PMThanks for the feedback.  And you obviously recommend it otherwise you would not have posted it!

A fair comment. Typically I find out more from negative reviews than a slew of 5 star "great" reviews (Which could be bots for all I know) but one has to keep in mind the author and maybe not everyone is cut out for tertiary learning.

The one negative comment I do agree with is that one of the quizzes asks questions that are not covered in the course material, so you are guessing the answers (that would be my 72% score lol).  So just watch out for that. 
Don't drink and buy shares in a downtrend, you bloody idiot.

Shareguy


Left Field

CEO has had enough of MFB......more exciting challenges elsewhere it seems.

https://www.nzx.com/announcements/398911

My Food Bag Group Limited (NZX: MFB) announces that overnight it has received notice of resignation from the company's Chief Executive Officer, Kevin Bowler.

Mr Bowler joined My Food Bag in June 2018 as its first independent CEO and has overseen a period of significant change.
Tony Carter, My Food Bag's Chair, says "Kevin successfully led the business through the COVID-19 pandemic, which delivered a number of significant challenges, including heightened health & safety risks, supply chain disruptions, rapid periods of growth and high inflation.

"It has been a challenging time for My Food Bag and despite this, with Kevin's leadership, the business has performed well, transitioned to a publicly listed company and is investing for the future.

"During Mr Bowler's tenure, the business virtually tripled its earnings, took control of national operations from third parties, opened two new assembly facilities in Auckland and Christchurch, and broadened its offering to customers by adding recipe choice, Made meals and its grocery options via the Kitchen.

"We wish Kevin all the very best as he seeks out new challenges in his personal and professional life," says Carter.
"The difficulty lies not in new ideas... but in escaping from old ideas." (J M Keynes.)

KW

I wonder if this is related to the return of Cecilia Robinson?
Don't drink and buy shares in a downtrend, you bloody idiot.

Fiordland Moose

Possibly.  Would be hard and could have a different view on marketing / customer retention.

Under his newly established LTI scheme all his non base rem is based on 50% relative TSR vs NZ50 and 50% absolute EPS growth. That not getting paid this year I wouldnt have thought.

There was no LTI payment last year as didnt over perform and hurdle not yet.

Could be sees whats coming and doesnt want to be the one to have to resize the business - people like to grow things - not shrink them.

Does this count as the second downgrade or have we still got 2 more to go

Basil

We still have two more downgrades to go.  Doggy won't be standing in front of this fast moving train wreck anytime soon.