Main Menu

MFB - My Food Bag

Started by nztx, Jun 25, 2022, 02:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

kiwi2007

#135
https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/130513373/my-food-bag-firsthalf-profit-slumps-38-as-consumers-tighten-their-wallets?fbclid=IwAR3ypSzbHv53o5MszwHWcqgHedACa5qa8av4vD3gQG9hBdDfcgLK2YFTTMk

My Food Bag first-half profit slumped 38% as consumers tighten their wallets and hunt for bargains in a high inflation environment.

The meal kit company said net profit fell to $5.9 million in the six months to September 30, from $9.4m last year. Revenue slid 4.1% to $94.4m.

My Food Bag had previously warned that profit would take a hit this year as consumers tighten their wallets in an environment of high inflation and rising interest rates, with more customers choosing its lower margin 'bargain box' and trading down to smaller bags. Overall deliveries fell 9.4% in the first half to 732,000, although bargain box deliveries lifted 2.1%.

"Across the whole meal kit category, discounts have played a heavy role in attracting new customers during the first half of the year," said chief executive Mark Winter. "We've experienced higher than average churn from customers starting with us via discount deals." ......................................................
   more  ..........................................................

Shares in My Food Bag have lost 47% of their value this year, and closed on the NZX on Thursday at 58c.

Basil

#136
Oh dear...Nadia's Farm T.V. show not helping.
eps of only 2.4 cps in the current half but paying 3.0 cps dividend ?  Hmmm...that makes "perfect" sense in the current environment and appears unsustainable going forward.

If they can replicate 1H performance in the second half (and I am concerned they may not be able to do this for a number of reasons mainly revolving around the level of food price inflation and customers getting really hammered as they come off cheap 2-3% fixed price mortgage deals and face a new reality of 6%+) that's only 4.87 cps earnings for the full year. 

Of course the company are still creatively talking up the growth prospects, (playing defense for the ludicrously overpriced IPO as you would expect), but until there is a proven track record of growth extending past growth fueled by among other things, risks of shopping due to Covid infection and draconian lockdowns, there is no growth so if we apply a quick and dirty no growth PE of 8 to eps of 4.87 cps I see fair value at 39 cents.  (HUGE caveat to this indicative valuation is the assumption that the current level of eps can be maintained going forward), which quite frankly, seems highly unlikely.

I think Winner is right and MFB and MPG are in a race to the bottom.  Watch the chart and don't dare buy until there is a confirmed bottom as evidenced by a clear break up through the 100 day moving average, (if indeed this ever happens for either company).  TA is your best friend when future earnings are so uncertain.

As expected, shares getting punished this morning, 49 cps at time of posting.  Plenty of potential for more pain ahead with this one.  I feel so sorry for naïve first time investors who were enthusiastically extolled by the promotors to "Tuck In" like there was some great banquet to be had.    Heartbreaking stuff for many of these smaller investors who have little and cannot afford the loss.


lorraina

Foodstuffs looking to devote more space to frozen foods and ready meals will be another challenge .

Arbroath

I said this was going to 50c and now that it's there it feels like 30-40c is coming next year...

Basil, I have to say and this might come back to bite me but MPG look to have a better business than MFB...the difference being MPG have a chunk of bank debt they have to manage.  But MPG have more ebitda and more costs they can cut in a downturn than MFB imho...

Basil

Thanks for your thoughts mate.  I find it truly incredible that MPG have made such a mess of things when they have had the lions share, (didn't they have about a 50% market share a year or two ago ?) of a booming construction market over the years ?  I see they're only now looking at doing a cost out exercise...something that should have been done years ago in my opinion.
On the other hand MFB have a modest customer base that at least has some chance of growing at some stage down the track but frankly who knows when ?
I don't think there's any doubt about it, these are both very ugly puppies!

KW

Quote from: KW on Sep 10, 2022, 01:32 PMIts moving into being priced for a recession, and reduction of consumer discretionary spending which should hit companies like MFB as people tighten their wallets. 
.....
As mentioned previously, I think that this half year should be a good indication of their longer term prospects, so plenty of time to sit on your hands and watch.  Don't buy the downtrend. 

There you go.  Everyone has the answer.  Never buy the downtrend, or you'll end up beaten and bloody  8)
Don't drink and buy shares in a downtrend, you bloody idiot.

Basil

Quote from: KW on Nov 18, 2022, 01:20 PMThere you go.  Everyone has the answer.  Never buy the downtrend, or you'll end up beaten and bloody  8)
And we know this because you've drummed it into our heads for many years so a HUGE thank you to you !! 

winner (n)

MFB share price still doing its best to catch up with Metro Glass MPG ..... but MPG gone below 20 again is making it a bad harder for MFB to catch up

But MFB getting there - 20 cents doesn't seem too far away

Sad story though ..... but a few are still laughing at managing to do what they did,

You cannot view this attachment.


Basil

#143
QuoteAs mentioned previously, I think that this half year should be a good indication of their longer term prospects, so plenty of time to sit on your hands and watch.  Don't buy the downtrend. KW

I think the acid test is coming up in 2023 when we get the recession and the full effect of the cost of living increases with inflation still running high and interest rates maybe at a peak.  Plenty of scope for this to keep falling as more and more customers are forced to seek out lower priced food in harder times.

The other day I speculated with someone that this could be a buy at some stage though.  Just speculative but if they can stabilize the business at around 20% lower level's (which is about where I think it might finally land in late 2023) and about 3 cps in earnings, somewhere in the mid 20's (no growth PE of 8 in the middle of a recession) then this could have some potential coming out the other side of harder times.  I guess it depends on whether you want to invest risk capital into speculative penny dreadful's though?

Time will tell but, in the meantime, we know to watch the chart carefully 😊

Auto Rower

This coming recession on the back of the existing Bear market ,will be a full on Acid test for a lot of company's & some will go to the wall .
I will say this should not be One of them unless the wealthy eliteist Nadia (fluff)lovers get stung they have lots to spend on quality & Quality food is something a wealthy person does not scrimp on.
It would be interesting to set up on a poll for whom will go to the wall in the recession .
my favourite is mpg, not wishing this as it should be doing a lot better in these building boom times

Basil

#145
Quote from: Basil on Sep 09, 2022, 06:16 PMSpeed of the decline appears to be increasing and risks breaking down the fairly steady rate of constant decline into something worse.  There would appear to be a real risk of this being below 50 cents before Christmas. Sales comparatives cannot be helped by the fact that this time last year we were into a whopping 107 day Auckland region wide lockdown.  I would think Aug 2022 sales compared to the same month last year probably make for sober reading and its likely Sept, October and November will be much the same.   Maybe the same punters that thought it was a bargain at $1 will step in and give some support at 50 cents ?
Posted early September with the share price in the low 60's.
And so it came to pass we entered the 30's, closed at another all time low of 39.5 cps today.
Plenty of water to go under the bridge with tougher economic times for consumers with this one.
Just give it time and there's a very real chance the share price starts with a "2" handle.


Ferg

Quote from: Basil on Dec 07, 2022, 05:17 PMAnd so it came to pass we entered the 30's, closed at another all time low of 39.5 cps today.
Plenty of water to go under the bridge with tougher economic times for consumers with this one.
Just give it time and there's a very real chance the share price starts with a "2" handle.

Oh dear.  Where is the 'outrage' at promoters and vendors for over-hyping this IPO?  A long hard time ahead for those who "tucked in" at the IPO.

Minimoke

Quote from: NZInvestor on Aug 11, 2022, 07:15 PMThere was a bloke who made the mistake of expressing a view that essentially having an attractive person fronting an IPO was a distraction from the fundamentals. I agree with him 100%. Be wary of the attractive looking dividend.

When the IPO came out I recall I bought out my bargepole.
That was my original thought. I see no reason to change it. I see absolutely zero to warrant this as a buy at any price.

Mousehold

The current assault by HelloFresh can't be helping - someone on GeekZone was offering free HelloFresh boxes last week. I partook, with the free box arriving today, and I now seem to have free boxes to offer to others - quite bizarre. But DM me if you want a free HelloFresh box if I can still hand more out (and apologies to all MFB holders...).

Minimoke

Quote from: Mousehold on Dec 10, 2022, 09:03 AMThe current assault by HelloFresh can't be helping - someone on GeekZone was offering free HelloFresh boxes last week. I partook, with the free box arriving today, and I now seem to have free boxes to offer to others - quite bizarre. But DM me if you want a free HelloFresh box if I can still hand more out (and apologies to all MFB holders...).
I just got my free boxes ordered. 12 dinner meals for $15.00 And the ability to send free boxes as well. So let me know if anyone wants 12 free meals (plus p&P)

I see how Hello Fresh is working. Must be quite expensive - but seems a super effective way of dragging people away from MFB for at least a week.