OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

winner (n)

Quote from: Shareguy on Oct 27, 2022, 09:10 PMI can't help feel that it these levels OCA is going to attract some sort of interest.  How much lower can it go?

Possibly many take a takeover offer at $1.10 and think how lucky they were they got that

winner (n)

Love Jarred at the 10th Man. Here's a few bits from todays newsletter

- Earnings don't matter?
- it is sentiment that matters
- It pains me to see this. It pains me to see people spend their entire lives manipulating numbers in a spreadsheet, thinking it's going to give them some insight into what the stock market will do
- Earnings don't matter. Fundamental analysis does not matter. What matters is how people feel about a stock
- etc etc.

Market sentiment about OCA these days sucks eh ...... really bad ..... so until that sentiment changes little hope of a much improved OCA share price ---- and don't overlook that generally people don't behave rationally'

Same applies to other stocks in this sector but on a scale of 1-10 where 1 is 'really sucks' and 10 is 'sort of sucks' you's have to put OCA at 1 (2 if being nice) ... ARV at 2 and RYM and SUM at 5 to 6


Latest The 10th Man here
https://www.mauldineconomics.com/the...gs-dont-matter

BlackPeter

Quote from: Shareguy on Oct 27, 2022, 09:10 PMI can't help feel that it these levels OCA is going to attract some sort of interest.  How much lower can it go?

Quite easy ... downtrend will stop as soon as demand is higher than supply, caused by the fear to miss out growing larger than the greed to wait for still lower prices. In March 2020 it dropped down to 40 cents.

However - quite meaningless jitter for investors.

If you bought a house to live in some years ago for $500k, which used to be worth last year $1.2m and is now worth $1 m, you still have a house to live in and nothing has changed for you, right?

If you bought an OCA share for say $1 some years ago, it went down to 40 cents and up to $1.60 and currently down to 84 cents, you still have one OCA share - and both dividend (current yield juicy 6%) and earnings (earnings CAGR of 10) of this share just keeps growing. Sill the same great investment (obviously getting only better while the SP drops).

Sure - for buyers waiting to get in it is relevant whether they pay 80 cents, 60 cents or 40 cents for this amazing investment ... but as in all other things in life - the longer you wait the higher the risk to miss out.

Not many managed to get in for this amazing 40 cents deal on March 23, 2020. The day before it was 51 cents and the day after 52 cents. My lowest buy in around this time was in the early 60 cents ... and I am still pretty happy with this investment :) ;

777

Is this what you were talking about?  ;)

BUY   24/03/2020   50,000    NZD   46.5   23,250.00   46.40   23,296.40

BlackPeter

Quote from: 777 on Oct 28, 2022, 10:20 AMIs this what you were talking about?  ;)

BUY   24/03/2020   50,000    NZD   46.5   23,250.00   46.40   23,296.40

Market opened that day at 51 cents, went down to 38 cents and closed at 40 cents.

I mentioned the closing price (given this is an auction), but sure - the trade you mention is in the band.

Your trade?


Left Field

Quote from: winner (n) on Oct 28, 2022, 09:15 AMLove Jarred at the 10th Man. Here's a few bits from todays newsletter

https://www.mauldineconomics.com/the...gs-dont-matter

"He also goes on to say...
Economist Nouriel Roubini was tweeting unironically the other day about World War III. He thinks it is "likely." And a lot of people share that opinion.

Guys. It's not going to happen. Not only is it not going to happen, just the fact that you are saying that is a big sentiment indicator. I've been saying this for a while—sentiment today is worse than it was during the financial crisis. Much worse. This isn't just about the housing market imploding—people actually think that the world is going to come to an end.

Large groups of people acting irrationally, like I said. The opportunity here is to buy stocks. More precisely, the opportunity occurred on the last CPI release on Thursday, October 13—that was the moment—and we are already up 8% since then.

It's time to buy
"

Thanks for posting Winner.

However....I won't be buying OCA anytime soon. Much better opportunities in the market IMO.
"The difficulty lies not in new ideas... but in escaping from old ideas." (J M Keynes.)

Basil

#201
Quote from: Shareguy on Oct 27, 2022, 09:10 PMI can't help feel that it these levels OCA is going to attract some sort of interest.  How much lower can it go?

Classic value trap.  Its seems cheap because of the discount to NTA...BUT WAIT check out the discounts to NTA of some of the REIT's who have 100% of their assets working properly for them, not 68% of their assets caught in a vice like systemic Govt underfunding problem with care like OCA does. 

Then consider how ARV signaled how badly they're being affected by care costs and that's with only 28% of their units care focused.

After that consider what a huge move it was for the market leader Ryman to radically scale back on their new villages in regard to care.  For them to do that the board and CEO must have carefully weighed up the reputational damage that would do, (RYM have always been known for the caliber of their care and the decent size of their care facilities relative to independent living units suggesting to incoming residents that care would be there when it was needed), against what they obviously perceive as systemically and egregiously low returns on care that would appear to be a problem forever and a day going forward. 

Remember that National has only promised to increase care rates in line with inflation going forward so all this does is lock in future Govt care contributions at late 2023 historically low level's and that's if a National led coalition win the election).  We might as well sell everything and run for the hills if Cindy gets back in...

The Pied Piper can play his tune all he likes and if people want to follow him good luck to them.  I value this on an underlying earnings basis as a no growth company, (underlying eps has declined in real inflation adjusted terms by 17% since 2018) so they will be doing well to keep underlying eps constant in real inflation adjusted terms.  8 cps underlying realised profit and I apply a no growth PE of 8 (until such time if ever they can prove they can grow that figure and I am not convinced they can in the foreseeable future) and I get 8 x 8 = 64 cents.  That's around half asset backing and that's where they deserve to be in my opinion.  The bottom line is this is a company than cannot control its costs and appears to have very poor cost disciplines and far to much focus on impressing everyone with how well they're looking after everyone's else's interests including all things ESG.

I would only nibble there on the basis that some other company might have a crack at taking them over for about $1 and clean out a lot of dead wood, refocus the activities, add some desperately needed cost disciplines and grab some synergies for their trouble.

For me it's not worth punting on companies that are fundamentally systemically challenged with their business model unless they really are VERY cheap considering the extreme headwinds faced for the foreseeable future.

Your question certainly got tongues wagging this morning lol.

For existing shareholders sake I hope I am wrong with my 64 cent call but I'm not betting my own money on this until such time as I think the odds are in my favour.

winner (n)

#202
Value of OCA -

1) NTA - Reported as $945m but discount by 20% for pending revaluations = $750m
2) future value of losses looking after people etc estimated at $150m. Assumed current shortfall /care cost / loss / subsidy from property profits (or waht ever you want to call it) is $15m and this growing at 5%pa and using a discount rate of 15%

Value is 1) LESS 2) = $600m

Spooky indeed - market cap today $600m

Market maybe is forward looking after all and got it right

Whacc

Quote from: winner (n) on Oct 28, 2022, 09:15 AMLove Jarred at the 10th Man. Here's a few bits from todays newsletter

- Earnings don't matter?
- it is sentiment that matters
- It pains me to see this. It pains me to see people spend their entire lives manipulating numbers in a spreadsheet, thinking it's going to give them some insight into what the stock market will do
- Earnings don't matter. Fundamental analysis does not matter. What matters is how people feel about a stock
- etc etc.


Go tell that to Amazon investors today...

winner (n)

Suppose when share price close is 81 cents one takes some comfort that the WVAP was 82.69 cents ...not so bad after all

Basil

#205
I think I can safely say that nobody has issued more warning barks about this mutt than me.

I think I am also coming to an even deeper understanding that the market for retirement units is presently saturated and likely to remain that way for many years.  Really pleased to be out of this whole sector, especially this one.

Waltzing

#206
Lets face it where do they find staff from.

The whole country staff program was plain to see when the immigration minister from FIJI did not seem to understand high tech QUALIFIED drivers of agricultural equipment (HI TECH these days) can not be found at your local poly tech in the BOP or GISBORNE.....

wasnt it apparent then that there was a problem with immigration and maybe certain demographics just did not want more people coming here that were technically capable and had the wrong skin color? (European people not wanted). Remember the "Privilaged white farmers" comment.

White people dont apply please we have to decolonise the country and reindocinrate all immigrants.

The kiwi is 58 to the Dickie and your dollars are worthless. A young US guys with a Kiwi friend is taking her back the US becuase he can buy 10 acres one hour up north from NY for Yankee dollars and isnt staying here.

Why dont they just go and get 250 thousand uKE's well educated people and problem solved..

It would keep houses prices up and KIWI build coiuld house them quick smart no problem....

wasnt it obvious then chart start heading down and immigration was stalled that this was a sell... who still holds these?

dont worry Peters will solve all these problems when he is the New prime Minister and Luxon is allocated the tourism portfolio.....

Basil

Second chance for anyone that missed out on the IPO in May 2017 @ 79 cents is likely to be coming very shortly.  Can't go wrong there surely ?  Just remember it has been down to less than half that at 38 cents in early 2020.  I think the outlook is substantially more challenging now than it was in May 2017 when it listed.  NTA is basically irrelevant when 68% of your assets are earning truly pitiful returns and on basic care beds you're losing money.

Waltzing

To Attract internation staff you have to advertise in the language of european countries not in english or some local tongue...

classic example is this where the german translation was not very accurate.

Good example for teaching european languages and others in schools... do they still have schools?

https://www.stuff.co.nz/environment/130353050/the-dream-job-in-haast-that-hardly-anyone-wanted-is-now-hot-property

Basil

Another day, another multi year low, now 80 cents.  Test of the IPO price of 79 cents coming up either tomorrow or next week I reckon.