OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Mos

Quote from: ValueNZ on Aug 31, 2025, 12:40 PMI wrote to the Oceania Healthcare Board on Friday, I have attached the letter to this post for download. Alternatively you can read it on my substack


Tommy I think you on the right track and commend your activism. I engaged with the Board on this at an ASM around 5 years ago and Liz Coutts the Chair showed zero interest in a buy back initiative to create value then (from memory was more than 40% discount to NTA at the time). Her response implied that the Board thought their growth/building plan would create more value. Since then Oceania has built on a tonne of stock that has been very slow to sell. I think they were firstly not open minded to alternative (and more probable) ways of creating value and had secondly had misplaced confidence in their blue sky DCF models (easy to build a DCF spreadsheet model showing massive value creation - execution is a different matter altogether).

Probably the only way to get them meaningfully interested in the buy back idea is for it to be the CEO or Greg Tomlinson's idea. That is the challenge.

To be fair to Oceania they have divested around 18 of their weakest properties from a value creation perspective. It would be good to see this continue for the reasons you outline.

I can't get my head around continuing to build new care suites and apartments in Hamilton (slow sellers) at today's construction costs when they can effectively buy the existing portfolio at a 58% discount to NTA.

Also the variation in the standard of properties means the Oceania brand has no consistency ranging from top end premium to bang average or worse. It would be great to see them refining it to 20 great premium villages that are value creation engines and aggressively divesting what does not fit from value creation and brand perspectives. The progress towards this seems more of a laboured crawl than decisively swift. There is value in there but they do a good job of ensuring it does not show up anytime soon.

Keep up the good work.


Shareguy

#1801
Great post ValueNZ. You have made some good points. Have you noticed that there has been no insider buying for some time. Even at these levels. Speaks volumes to me.

Let us know how you get on. Best of luck..

Basil

Quote from: Mos on Aug 31, 2025, 07:51 PMProbably the only way to get them meaningfully interested in the buy back idea is for it to be the CEO or Greg Tomlinson's idea. That is the challenge.

I agree 100% with Mos.  Try and team up with Maverick and see if you can meet up with the CEO for a chat.  The trick is to let them think it was their idea.  You've never got a better chance as they've radically scaled back their new build rate so you are half way there.

Dolcile

A good letter and good to she shareholders holding the board to account

My concern is, I think you'll find that while NTA should reflect market value, the chance of them realising that value in the market is low. 

ValueNZ

Quote from: Dolcile on Sep 01, 2025, 11:44 AMA good letter and good to she shareholders holding the board to account

My concern is, I think you'll find that while NTA should reflect market value, the chance of them realising that value in the market is low. 
Thanks Docile.

Previous divestments were done at/near market value. There's a large margin of safety between NTA and what the sale price would be so even if they sold something at 0.85x it still makes sense to do.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Basil on Sep 01, 2025, 10:38 AMI agree 100% with Mos.  Try and team up with Maverick and see if you can meet up with the CEO for a chat.  The trick is to let them think it was their idea.  You've never got a better chance as they've radically scaled back their new build rate so you are half way there.
Thanks for your comments. Not a bad idea, but I'm currently in Aus on exchange so not really an option at the moment.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Mos on Aug 31, 2025, 07:51 PMTommy I think you on the right track and commend your activism. I engaged with the Board on this at an ASM around 5 years ago and Liz Coutts the Chair showed zero interest in a buy back initiative to create value then (from memory was more than 40% discount to NTA at the time). Her response implied that the Board thought their growth/building plan would create more value. Since then Oceania has built on a tonne of stock that has been very slow to sell. I think they were firstly not open minded to alternative (and more probable) ways of creating value and had secondly had misplaced confidence in their blue sky DCF models (easy to build a DCF spreadsheet model showing massive value creation - execution is a different matter altogether).

Probably the only way to get them meaningfully interested in the buy back idea is for it to be the CEO or Greg Tomlinson's idea. That is the challenge.

To be fair to Oceania they have divested around 18 of their weakest properties from a value creation perspective. It would be good to see this continue for the reasons you outline.

I can't get my head around continuing to build new care suites and apartments in Hamilton (slow sellers) at today's construction costs when they can effectively buy the existing portfolio at a 58% discount to NTA.

Also the variation in the standard of properties means the Oceania brand has no consistency ranging from top end premium to bang average or worse. It would be great to see them refining it to 20 great premium villages that are value creation engines and aggressively divesting what does not fit from value creation and brand perspectives. The progress towards this seems more of a laboured crawl than decisively swift. There is value in there but they do a good job of ensuring it does not show up anytime soon.

Keep up the good work.


Thank you.

I've also made online questions at past ASM's regarding a buyback, but nothing came out of it. I also sent an email earlier in the year which was met with a generic email thanking me for my interest in the company.

That's why this time I've taken a more formal approach, I've also sent the letters to their addresses listed on the register as well as HQ.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Basil on Aug 31, 2025, 03:36 PMThe biggest problem however is neither the board or management seem to have any concern for, of focus on shareholders at all and frankly they never have.

Well the board are shareholders themselves, so it doesn't really make sense to think they don't have concern for themselves. Which is why I'm optimistic about the chances of a buyback being implemented.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Basil on Aug 31, 2025, 03:36 PMGood luck getting the board to take a more shareholder centric focus.  You'll need it but I commend you for trying.  Stay on their case.  Hound them at the annual meeting is my advice.  How about this as a question for the next Annual meeting.  What the heck is the point of building new units especially care suites when you have so much unsold stock and could buy back your own shares for 41 cents on the dollar.  I'm almost tempted to buy a few and start the ferocious barking at the next annual meeting myself.  If they can't see the logic in what you're suggesting why are they even on the board purporting to be serving shareholders best interests ?  I'd suggest at the next meeting, you suggest that if they're not prepared to take some action they should resign.  I'd love to do the barking but I'm an old dog now and its time for the next generation to make their mark.  I look forward to you making some noise at the next annual meeting.    My advice, don;t hold back, really rip into them.
I'll definitely consider that if they haven't got a buyback implemented by then.

BlackPeter

#1809
Hmm ... Chief Legal Officer leaving immediately?

https://www.nzx.com/announcements/458383

She started only 20 months ago:

https://www.nzx.com/announcements/423712

Greekwatchdog

Clearly she has another job within the industry. This is a common occurence and just not exec level

BlackPeter

#1811
Quote from: Greekwatchdog on Sep 09, 2025, 11:20 AMClearly she has another job within the industry. This is a common occurence and just not exec level

Who knows, but given that her LinkedIn profile still (10. 09) shows her as Oceania Chief Legal and Risk Officer, I am not so sure about that option.

Wouldn't this be something somebody with her leadership and legal authority would fix first?

No idea, what happened, but it looks to me more like something for both sides somewhat surprising.

We shall see.

winner (n)

Quote from: BlackPeter on Sep 10, 2025, 08:43 AMWho knows, but given that her LinkedIn profile still (10. 09) shows her as Oceania Chief Legal and Risk Officer, I am not so sure about that option.

Wouldn't this be something somebody with her leadership and legal authority would fix first?

No idea, wht happened, but it looks to me more like something for both sides soemwhat surprising.

We shall see.

Gone to Stride Prop ...starts November

BlackPeter

Quote from: winner (n) on Sep 10, 2025, 08:45 AMGone to Stride Prop ...starts November

Interesting. Gives her time to update her LI profile.


Basil

#1814
Quote from: winner (n) on Sep 10, 2025, 08:45 AMGone to Stride Prop ...starts November
Nice long holiday before she starts the new position. Stride probably offered a LOT more money.  On top of that they have extra annual leave, (5 weeks minimum) and additional contributions to Kiwisaver above the statutory minimum.  Stride so generous with their staff, maybe even more generous than OCA if that's even possible, seeing as both companies have declining EPS.