OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Crackity

#1740
Interesting the investor presentation was rereleased separately at 5.04pm

Are they cap raising?




Turkey

No I don't think so, there was a mistake on pg 5 of original preso whichthey said on investor call they had picked up and would correct....but never let the truth get in the way of a good story...

winner (n)

Quote from: Turkey on May 23, 2025, 07:39 AMNo I don't think so, there was a mistake on pg 5 of original preso whichthey said on investor call they had picked up and would correct....but never let the truth get in the way of a good story...

I and I suppose a few others told them that the sales prices on the chart looked nonsense ....and they changed it and posted an updated presentation.

Buzz

Quote from: winner (n) on May 23, 2025, 08:16 AMI and I suppose a few others told them that the sales prices on the chart looked nonsense ....and they changed it and posted an updated presentation.

The 'Average Sales prices (resales)' were significantly understated for all three years, in the first presentation. CFO picked it up, not others.

Age is not a good measure of ability

Basil

CFO usually puts together that power point presentation in the first place so she's only fixing her own mistakes.  The one consistent senior management role through all the changes in the CEO role over the years has been the CFO.  She has presided over consistent poor performance well before, and for all the years after OCA listed.

Food for thought. Is she really any good ? Why wasn't the current efficiency drive initiated many years ago ?  Isn't that one of the core roles of a CFO to look for efficiencies and ways to grow earnings so what has she been doing all these years ?  Why does it take a new incoming CEO to try and make the business more efficient ?  What was Brent doing all the years he was there ?  So many questions with OCA and so few answers...

Ferg

Quote from: Buzz on May 23, 2025, 08:44 AMThe 'Average Sales prices (resales)' were significantly understated for all three years, in the first presentation. CFO picked it up, not others.

Some interesting numbers there Buzz.  Comparing HY25 to (amended) FY25 prices:

New apartments $1088 -> $1108 (up)
New suites $358 -> $356 (down)
Villa resales $582 -> $594 (up)
Apartment resales $914 -> $963 (up)
Suite resales $363 -> $358 (down)

Average prices in the second half year were up for apartments and villas, and down for care suites.  Whilst apartments will be skewed by sales The Helier, it is a good outcome nonetheless for ILU's.

There was a slight fall in average prices for care suites.  Care suites make up 56% of sales by volume, and around 31-32% by value so the impact is somewhat muted, or dwarfed by ILU sales.

Yes Kathryn was fixing her own mistake (mistakes are definitely not good), but one positive is that she was able to recognise it was wrong straight away on the investor call.  Any CFO should be able to look at a number and know straight away if it is roughly right or roughly wrong so good on her for seeing it and calling it straight away.  But I am curious as to what those numbers were....they were not H2 average prices, nor H1.

Basil

Full transcript of the call is on the other channel.  Gosh operational losses at existing villages are really running away on themselves.  All those oldies on cheap weekly fees fixed for life while village operational costs grow at low double digit percentages year on year on year...and many oldies living well past the time when their DMF fees stop accruing.  HUGE systemic problem that appears to be growing at quite an alarming rate.   I'm staying well away.  Only one worth owning is SUM and even then, only when real estate is going gangbusters.

winner (n)

Reporting Oceania performance the Ryman way and using PBTF as the measure of operational performance is revealing. Shown in table below.

Some have expressed concern how the 'losses' seem to be increasing and so they should be.

Oceania head up results "Building on Momentum". The TBTF sure has some momentum but I don't think they were referring to that.

You cannot view this attachment.

It's real concern when at analysts briefing they avoid discussing it in detail, just vague mumbo jumbo.

Basil

#1748
WOW !! That is scary. From the transcript, one of the analysts unable to understand why village operational losses grew for $5m in the first half to $22m in the second half. That, despite their so called cost out program.  Really scaling back new developments will really hurt future development profits.

Really interesting to compare 2018 line items, the first full year after it listed with 2025.
CEO's salary grown from $630K to $1.86m, nearly tripled....but she has come up with a new mantra of helping people live well as they age, or similar words to that effect...wow, how inciteful is that new policy, that's worth another million dollars on its own surely, (sarcasm)
CFO grown from a band of $430-$440K to $830-$840K, assumes she's the second highest paid at OCA, (never mind she makes mistakes year after year)
Other expenses grown from $52.5m to $82.2m
Total Wages and employee benefits grown from $113.3m to $178m per annum despite selling a whopping 18 of the villages they had at the time of the IPO.  Gosh, its obviously a great place to work.
In the meantime cash burn has gone ballistic and dividends have gone from 4.7 cps per annum to nothing.
Management are gorging themselves at the trough and shareholders don't even get the crumbs left on the table from their enormous banquet.
Directors and management telling everyone in their report about progress and growth.  Yeah, its pretty clear where the real growth is.

Totally uninvest-able but that won't stop the usual zealots from throwing more money down this rat hole.

Basil

#1749
Its taking the main protagonist on the other channel a lot longer than usual to try and put a positive spin on the OCA results and come out with the usual, no worries, next year is our year and growth is just around the corner....the same thing we've been hearing for so many years now I have lost count.  I guess some results are so bad its impossible to put a positive spin on them...

Shareguy

I see Jarden are saying no divi for the foreseeable future.

AFFO double analysts forecast of a $15m loss

Cash flows were the weak point of the result, with OCA's existing assets consuming $40m of cash over FY25.

Rymans result to come. It will also be bad. Hopefully not as bad as some expect.








Basil

"Dekker and Vishal use their own metric to assess cashflows from existing operations: Jarden AFFO. Although "lumpy", the analysts calculated Oceania's full-year Jarden AFFO ended up being a loss of $31 million – more than double analysts' forecast of a $15m loss".  Extract from businessdesk article

Dekker has the best handle of any of the analysts on the true extent of the problems at OCA, in my opinion.

Ferg

The $31m is very close to what I am seeing.  Take the receipts less payments, normalise the swings on debtors & creditors (which are a timing difference) and add back $32m of DMF realised, gets me to ($30m) normalised cash loss versus ($18m) using the same metric for the prior year.  There are some horrendous swings on creditors payments with -$10m last year and +$10m the year before.....what is that about??

Luckily next year will be better ay?  ;D

Ferg

Graphs for OCA:

You cannot view this attachment.

You cannot view this attachment.

You cannot view this attachment.

Over the period 2017-2025, CAGRs:
 ~ Sales +5.5% p.a.
 ~ NPAT% +0.1% p.a.
 ~ shares on issue +2.2% p.a.
 ~ EPS +3.3% p.a. (from 5.6c to 7.2c)
 ~ P/E -6.9% p.a.
 ~ share price from 83c to 61c

BlackPeter

Interesting to read old threads.

They teach you that our gurus or heroes or whatever frequently tend to unisono praise shares into the sky or beat them down into the mud. Some of us still might remember the amazing guru who told us probably less than a decade ago that 1 Ryman share will always be worth 5 SUM shares or 10 OCA shares. Check this ratio today. And no, he was not dumber than anybody else who can't see the future (which would be all of us).

Remember the times when Ryman was still the star and this never could change? Year right.
Remember the times when one couldn't hold enough OCA shares - year right.
Remember the times when SKL was a dirty word and people still selling the shares below 50 cents? - Yeah right.
Remember the highs and Lows of A2M - and everybody knew what a great and what a terrible company this was?

So - OCA still on the downbeat, is it? Actually - my Jarden (well, invest direct) account shows that OCA made me in the last 12 months 12.03%. Of course - just on the paper - tomorrow might be better (or worse).But still - market seems to see opportunities. Funny coincidence? - maybe, but maybe not such a bad investment after all?

So, what I am wondering is - everybody here really just keep kicking the dying horse and waiting for OCA to roll up its toenails and die as a going concern, to move afterwards on to the next bad run company (like WHS, HGH, ....?) or anybody seeing opportunities as well?

I heard NZ will have a significant shortage in hotel accomodation over the years to come. Same issue with rental accomodation.

Are there opportunities to review the use of some of the OCA properties? What about turning parts of the Helier into a luxury hotel or upmarket appartments? Can they sell some of the elder villages they have to Kāinga Ora (in this case I would not envisage mixed use, but whatever)?

Somebody mentioned recently that a new owner might be able to change course ... (T/O) - I heard Metlifecare isn't doing that bad these days.

Anybody else seeing opportunities?