OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Buzz

Quote from: Mos on Dec 23, 2023, 06:03 PMHard to argue with 7.7% YTM. I prefer the shares but can see your rationale.

Agree Bonds for a sustainable income, whereas the equity has suspended dividends and they were miserable anyway. Equity though is already up 9% from its lows, so that's more than a whole year of Bond returns in a few months from the equities, albeit probably not realised, yet.
Age is not a good measure of ability

lorraina

Quote from: Basil on Dec 23, 2023, 03:32 PMHas the dog gone completely loopy with excess Turners profits or is there more to this story you might wonder.

Crikey .???????????????
The dog's gone NUTS.
OCA and then having a good word for 2CC..??
Next you will be buying back into PAZ .[Well their AiOra products really worked for you.]


Basil

LOL its not called the silly season without good reason.
The red Barron gave the dog a pass at Christmas so I figure if he can do it so can I 😊
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jlf---13Q0g

snapiti

the hound should be careful with this one, hope you have not sniffed out a hedgehog
never buy or sell shares driven by emotion, show conviction to your purchases

Breezy

Quote from: lorraina on Dec 23, 2023, 08:27 PMCrikey .???????????????
The dog's gone NUTS.
OCA and then having a good word for 2CC..??
Next you will be buying back into PAZ .[Well their AiOra products really worked for you.]


Must be Groundhog day once again.

Greekwatchdog

#755
Quote from: Basil on Dec 10, 2023, 10:57 AMNewer posters would do well to go back right to the start of this thread and the thread on the other channel, (I used to post as Beagle on the other channel) and glean as much info as they can and see who has been right over time.  I have made a huge effort, (nobody has tried harder) over recent years to warn about the weaknesses of their business model.  Now we have two leading analysts bold enough to call OCA out I am happy to leave them to do the work, and certainly won't report what I've already shared before but I will share a couple of big picture insights I have with you newer posters.

Right back at the IPO when private equity were running the business they had a very, very tight focus on costs, (what you would expect from a private equity owner).  Their EBITDA margin on care was 19% and care has always been a huge part of their business and always will be.  At the IPO we were promised a 6 year transformation process whereby older basic care facilities would be disestablished and these fancy new care suites, (which was an unproven concept at the time and I maintain is still that way) would be built and this was to transform returns on care.  It would take a few years but Earl Gasparich, the CEO at the time assured us the "inflection point" was only a few years away and we would start to see improving returns thereafter.

Time and time again thereafter we have been assured returns will be improved from care and even as recent as the FY23 annual meeting call senior management said returns from care have bottomed and will improve now but their EBITDA margin on care went down to less than 10% in the current half, in fact just on half the return on care when this floated nearly 7 years ago!  So much for their much-hyped transformation program!

So why has this care suite concept failed and why are there hundreds of unsold care suites, more than 4 years sales worth at their most recent result?  (Think about how ridiculous) it is if a car yard had 4 years worth of stock!  How is it that SUM can sell down a village in 6 months or ARV within a year but OCA take several years?

I maintain the care suite concept is broken and doesn't work other than for a very small percentage of the population.  An anecdotal story might help you understand why.  First up the DMF fees are extremely expensive.  My Mum was diagnosed with a terminal condition a few years ago and told she had about 6 months to live.  I wanted the best for her and was keen to see her in a care suite in the Sands with a sea view but the cost would be circa $75,000 ($500,000 x 15% and you pay the 15% whether its 1 day or 364 days).

We found her very good care in a almost brand new local facility, (so her friends could easily come and see her) that her doctor recommended for $45 a day for a premium room with a nice sea view.  It cost us a tiny fraction of the $75,000, less than $10K from memory and was better for my Mum as her old friends who lived locally could see her regularly.  If you know you have a terminal condition, why would you choose a care suite?  The answer is most who care about what their kids and don't want to waste money and put their kids through, potentially years of anguish waiting for the care suite to eventually resell) wouldn't.

This is why OCA have hundreds of unsold care suites and that part of their business model is broken.
RYM have a fully refundable care suite package where the money is fully refunded within 30 days on a resident passing so why would you choose an OCA care suite where you lose 15% per annum?

Yes they are at their limit of borrowing capacity.  Yes the operational losses at a village level are confronting and a major weakness in their business model. Just keep building more villages that lose money, what could possibly go wrong lol

As an asset play, not that I think NTA is especially relevant, its earnings that really matter, I note ARV trade at less than half NTA and have a much lower exposure to loss making care.

Be careful who you follow on the other channel.  A lot of people have followed another poster on there for years and where's that got them?  Right down the toilet is where.  He foretells untold riches ahead.  I have been warning for years about the major weaknesses in OCA's business model ever since it was $1.40. 
I don't like OCA even at the current price.  Because they have cried "wolf" so many times before on future growth I will only believe it when I see it.  8 cents underlying earnings is about all they have ever delivered despite all the huge volumes of talk about transformation over the years 

I think the culture of OCA is very wrong.  All their focus is on ESG and patient care regardless of cost.  Shareholders are treated with scant regard and I think there is very poor cost control within the business. I'm calling out the CFO as very weak and ineffective in that regard.

More recently, I think its a major fresh concern that despite no explicit Covid costs in the latest half year result, the EBITDA margin on care plunged badly to an all-time low, despite the company claiming earlier in the year it would recover.  It shows the company has very few, if any effective cost control disciplines and no forward insight into profit.  they never mention underlying eps in their presentations and over the years have had a culture of concealment of the level of unsold stock.

I can't see anything to like about their business model or the way the business is being managed.  Sure, it would be remiss if I didn't acknowledge they are trying to reduce their exposure to care and have made some progress in the current half, but I think the best analogy to use is to think about a big ship with small rudders.  It takes a very long time to change direction.  Many, many years.  It's been nearly 7 years now so maybe reflect on what little progress have been made this far.  There's a lot better places to invest your capital.    If you must invest in the retirement sector, pick the dog with the least fleas I reckon.  That's SUM in my opinion.

I am still in shock you have bought in, including bonds.

This is one of your posts from 10th Dec. Nothing has come out of OCA management for you to have changed your opinion and you still have doubts on the Property Market + you have mentioned on another post recently that there are too many units being built (despite a tsunami coming).

You have been scathing of Posters from ST for having there positive views, rightly/wrongly.

I suppose its easy for you being a momentum trader to pick a time when to buy in and then soak up the glory if it all turns out well for you and take the kudos from your followers.

May will be an interesting month of May especially if the result is not too your liking. Whats next you will buy back into ARV?




Breezy

Quote from: Greekwatchdog on Dec 24, 2023, 08:19 AMI am still in shock you have bought in, including bonds.

This is one of your posts from 10th Dec. Nothing has come out of OCA management for you to have changed your opinion and you still have doubts on the Property Market + you have mentioned on another post recently that there are too many units being built (despite a tsunami coming).

You have been scathing of Posters from ST for having there positive views, rightly/wrongly.

I suppose its easy for you being a momentum trader to pick a time when to buy in and then soak up the glory if it all turns out well for you and take the kudos from your followers.

May will be an interesting month especially if the result is not too your liking. Whats next you will buy back into ARV?




Highlights once again why you should take most of the stuff posted on these forums as amusement rather than anything you should take seriously.

Greekwatchdog

Quote from: Breezy on Dec 24, 2023, 09:04 AMHighlights once again why you should take most of the stuff posted on these forums as amusement rather than anything you should take seriously.

True, however there are far to many personal barbs going on to make it so especially towards people on ST, then some on here think they are the Pied Piper.

People on these sites need to remember DYOR as its your money stop using others on here as advice as they certainly won't be paying back your losses.

Back to OCA. Its long terms, its always been that way. Management and the board suck given there contempt towards investor's information and murky reports.

BlackPeter

Quote from: Basil on Dec 23, 2023, 03:09 PMOkay here it is, the most surprising post from me all year. No its not April fools day and no, your eyes are not deceiving you, I recently took a substantial position in OCA.  Almost beggars' belief doesn't it after what I've said about the company in recent years.  All the proof you ever need that a Beagle will sniff under every single rock, even the most unlikely ones if he thinks there's a feed under there.  Unpack my thinking a bit more after Christmas.  Merry Christmas all.

Well, when I did the same with TRA (buying in after earlier pointing to some risks) I got caned. Not by the SP - which did rise nicely, as expected, but by some of the posters ...).

Wishing you (well, all of us) for the coming year the pleasant feeling of a SP with tail wind ... and no heckling posters.

Good you saw the light. Welcome on board ... and yes, I think now is a great time to get into OCA.

Merry Christmas to all.

Untamed

Perhaps in the New Year, we should collectively communicate that to management? After all, we own a part of this company. That gives us the legitimate right to ask questions and express our concerns, and have them addressed.

QuoteManagement and the board suck given there contempt towards investor's information and murky reports.

Basil

#760
Bonds are a very different asset class than shares.  I am not sure from the posts above all realize that.
Buying a high yield bond, (I don't own any OCA shares), with 37% debt ratio protected by a master trust security deed that puts bondholders on the same footing as the banks seems like a reasonable security position to me, all the more so with management determined to get that debt down by suspending dividends (which may remain suspended for some time), and with an ocean of new stock to sell.

I'm also cognizant of a new mantra within the entire sector that's emerged this year which is forcing all to look very closely at their cash flow.  All other companies in this sector have made moves or noises about moderating their build rate going forward to match demand and I expect OCA to follow suit.  As their huge stock levels slowly come down, I expect their debt ratio to reduce in the years ahead.

I'm also very cognizant as a bondholder there's a fallback position if things go wrong which protects my security level.  In the extremely unlikely event things go badly wrong and shareholders have to put their hands in their pockets for a capital raise, that's not my problem.

GWD - All I will say in response to your post is no, nothing has changed, but my security position as a bondholder is good - very good especially after the dividend suspension which clearly signals the company is determined to get that debt ratio down.  SUM bonds trade at 6.2% so I am being paid quite well for the very slight extra risk here.  I'm comfortable that the banks won't let OCA get too far over its ski's.  I think they've already had a word to OCA management and that's why the dividends are suspended.


winner (n)

#761
Been pointed out that OCA share price up 9% from its lows ...that's pretty good ...and was pointing out outperforming the bonds

Interesting how the big 4 have performed v 52 week lows -

SUM +26%
RYM +17%
ARV +15%
OCA +9%

Hmmm.........the ' pecking order' remains in intact and unsurprisingly OCA is still the sector laggard. OCA share price might have done OK of late but is still a relatively significant underperformer ....possibly one reason Basil ain't buying OCA shares.

No worries ....2024 is a new year .....and a year of hope

Henry Filth

Welcome aboard the OCA Bond Express, Basil. Just make sure that you understand the potential tax fishooks of discounted secondary market bonds at maturity. Snoopy has some good stuff about it over on the other channel.

Happy New Year - I hope  you get something you want.

Breezy

Retail punters getting a chance to move the price up while the big players are laying on beaches in various places, lets see what happens in a couple of weeks or so once they are back.

Basil

For what its worth the Mrs and I were out for a drive the other day and drove past the Helier and were very impressed with the quality of the village's appearance from a street view but noted it appeared as quiet as a morgue and very few apartments had curtains, so it would seem the vast majority of the village is still empty.  I told my wife the weekly opex to stay there is $550 and she said, that explains it!  I am sure many of us recall the days where a premium site like that would have sold out off the plans long before it was finished.  Gosh, how times have changed.