OCA - Oceania Healthcare

Started by Benji, Jun 24, 2022, 03:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Untamed

#1665
Quote from: Basil on Feb 08, 2025, 06:23 PMGreat they are confident with their pricing but if you don't mind me observing, we've heard that song before from them many times over.

I don't mind you "observing" at all. And yep, I hear you.

QuoteHard to belive loyal holders still think this company will generate great levels of wealth for them in the future when all that's been demonstrated in the last 8 years is this company is a capital destruction machine. Looks to me, all they are doing is rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.

Stockholm syndrome is alive and well on the NZX, no finer example of proof than this company.

I don't disagree with any of that, but you do need to remember, that some of us cannot afford to sell at a loss, unless we are talking about an absolutely "dog" company, that is clearly going backwards. Someone like you, can probably afford to "wear" the occasional loss, and can take your money and move onto something better else. I can't do that. As I have said recently, I'm not overly happy with the way things are tracking now either, and if and when there is a takeover offer, that is high enough for me to get out, I won't lose any sleep, or tears over accepting an offer. I invested in OCA for various reasons, but I'm not a blind loyalist. If those reasons for investing, no longer apply, or the company is no longer aligned with my personal principles with regard to aged care, I will have no problem pulling out, providing I can at the very least, break even. I don't have blind loyalty to anyone. So, contrary to what you probably believe, your Stockholm Syndrome analogy does not apply to me.

I never believed OCA would generate wealth for me. I don't have enough money to ever get wealthy from investing. All I was ever looking to do, was to build a little extra financial security for my old age. I have actually done that (across my portfolio), despite small losses in some areas. Because the money I have invested over the last however many years, is money I saved. I would never have saved that much, without the motivation to save, that investing gave me. So I have zero regrets about any of it. OCA may still manage to turn things around. I'm not holding my breath, especially given that they have now apparently rescinded on what they said at the last results presentation, that the next update would be March. Now they say, May. That is disappointing to say the least.

Anyway, to use a saying that I generally detest - "it is what it is" - and at this point some of us just have to stay the course, for at least a bit longer. We are not all the same, nor are we all "in the same boat."

ValueNZ

Quote from: Basil on Feb 08, 2025, 06:23 PMGreat they are confident with their pricing but if you don't mind me observing, we've heard that song before from them many times over.

At least the share price is holding at 80 cents just 1 cent above the IPO price 8 years ago. I suppose that's something. Probably best not to think about the last 8 years inflation and not wonder what the share price should be just to hold it's value in real inflation adjusted terms,(no return whatsoever, just hold it's value), or what it should be taking into account the capital raise years ago at $1.30 not forgetting no dividends for quite some time now and very modest unimputed ones before that.  Not forgetting too, the opportunity cost of investing in OCA, what you could have made investing in SUM much better company.

Hard to belive loyal holders still think this company will generate great levels of wealth for them in the future when all that's been demonstrated in the last 8 years is this company is a capital destruction machine. Looks to me, all they are doing is rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.

Stockholm syndrome is alive and well on the NZX, no finer example of proof than this company.
Just as well the WAHS are going to win the NRL this year and everything going forward for OCA will be brilliant, or so some say...

For the second time today I'll use a line from the Sailor.

I'm not interested in what has happened but what will happen.

It's simply not true to say the company has destroyed massive amounts of wealth either. In fact it has created massive amounts of shareholder wealth. I am not talking about the squiggly line at which people transact their shares. Price is not value.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Untamed on Feb 08, 2025, 07:04 PMI don't mind you "observing" at all. And yep, I hear you.

I don't disagree with any of that, but you do need to remember, that some of us cannot afford to sell at a loss, unless we are talking about an absolutely "dog" company, that is clearly going backwards. Someone like you, can probably afford to "wear" the occasional loss, and can take your money and move onto something better else. I can't do that. As I have said recently, I'm not overly happy with the way things are tracking now either, and if and when there is a takeover offer, that is high enough for me to get out, I won't lose any sleep, or tears over accepting an offer. I invested in OCA for various reasons, but I'm not a blind loyalist. If those reasons for investing, no longer apply, or the company is no longer aligned with my personal principles with regard to aged care, I will have no problem pulling out, providing I can at the very least, break even. I don't have blind loyalty to anyone. So, contrary to what you probably believe, your Stockholm Syndrome analogy does not apply to me.

I never believed OCA would generate wealth for me. I don't have enough money to ever get wealthy from investing. All I was ever looking to do, was to build a little extra financial security for my old age. I have actually done that (across my portfolio), despite small losses in some areas. Because the money I have invested over the last however many years, is money I saved. I would never have saved that much, without the motivation to save, that investing gave me. So I have zero regrets about any of it. OCA may still manage to turn things around. I'm not holding my breath, especially given that they have now apparently rescinded on what they said at the last results presentation, that the next update would be March. Now they say, May. That is disappointing to say the least.

Anyway, to use a saying that I generally detest - "it is what it is" - and at this point some of us just have to stay the course, for at least a bit longer. We are not all the same, nor are we all "in the same boat."

The price you paid is irrelevant to whether you should hold your shares at today's prices. Ergo not selling because you would realise a loss is simply irrational.

Great post other than that. I also have found investing a great motivator to be frugal and work hard, finally starting to see some fruit bearing from that.

Untamed

#1668
Quote from: ValueNZ on Feb 08, 2025, 08:13 PMThe price you paid is irrelevant to whether you should hold your shares at today's prices. Ergo not selling because you would realise a loss is simply irrational.

In your opinion maybe. But as I said, we are not all the same, and neither are our situations. MY situation is very different to yours. I am also a hell of a lot older than you, so I do not have the luxury of time, to wait indefinitely for any company to provide me with a return, whether that be dividends or capital gain. So, I disagree with you. My average buy in price absolutely does have a bearing on whether I can sell at any given point, assuming I wanted to. I have sold out of companies that were, in my opinion, going nowhere, in the past. At a small loss. Which was the right decision for me at the time. Had I continued to hold, the value of those holdings would be worth next to nothing now. OCA is not in that category. I have no doubt that OCA will eventually come right, but whether I want to leave my investment tied up for too many more years, hoping to make a decent capital gain, remains to be seen. Probably not. As Basil has said, and its not often that he and I agree, but I do in this instance, sometimes, at some point, one has to think about the wisdom (or not) of tying up money in a company that is no longer paying dividends, and a share price that continues to be less than my average buy in price. Retirement is looming, I own no property (in case you are not aware, I live in my caravan), so I need to seriously think about what is the best thing to do with what little I have in the way of investments. Which, by the way, is miniscule - my total portfolio is only worth around $30,000. Small bikkies compared to yours, or anyone else's here. I guess the point I'm trying to make is, always remember, that one size does not fit all. You are young and I am really impressed with what you are doing/achieving, but you sometimes come across as "cocky." Sailor Rob is very knowledgeable and a savvy investor from what I can tell, but he is a grumpy bastard, and that gets people's backs up, often. So just be yourself. Learn from him, but don't adopt his personality. One grumpy bastard is more than enough  ;)

QuoteGreat post other than that. I also have found investing a great motivator to be frugal and work hard, finally starting to see some fruit bearing from that.

Had I started at your age, I'd be home and hosed by now. No question. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

ValueNZ

Quote from: Untamed on Feb 08, 2025, 08:30 PMIn your opinion maybe. But as I said, we are not all the same, and neither are our situations. MY situation is very different to yours. I am also a hell of a lot older than you, so I do not have the luxury of time, to wait indefinitely for any company to provide me with a return, whether that be dividends or capital gain. So, I disagree with you. My average buy in price absolutely does have a bearing on whether I can sell at any given point, assuming I wanted to. I have sold out of companies that were, in my opinion, going nowhere, in the past. At a small loss. Which was the right decision for me at the time. Had I continued to hold, the value of those holdings would be worth next to nothing now. OCA is not in that category. I have no doubt that OCA will eventually come right, but whether I want to leave my investment tied up for too many more years, hoping to make a decent capital gain, remains to be seen. Probably not. As Basil has said, and its not often that he and I agree, but I do in this instance, sometimes, at some point, one has to think about the wisdom (or not) of tying up money in a company that is no longer paying dividends, and a share price that continues to be less than my average buy in price. Retirement is looming, I own no property (in case you are not aware, I live in my caravan), so I need to seriously think about what is the best thing to do with what little I have in the way of investments. Which, by the way, is miniscule - my total portfolio is only worth around $30,000. Small bikkies compared to yours, or anyone else's here. I guess the point I'm trying to make is, always remember, that one size does not fit all. You are young and I am really impressed with what you are doing/achieving, but you sometimes come across as "cocky." Sailor Rob is very knowledgeable and a savvy investor from what I can tell, but he is a grumpy bastard, and that gets people's backs up, often. So just be yourself. Learn from him, but don't adopt his personality. One grumpy bastard is more than enough  ;)

Apologies if I come across as cocky. But what I said holds up. If you're required to sell to pay for something then the buy price is still irrelevant, you just take the price the market gives you. Even if it's lower. That's just the risk you take on by having a relatively short investing horizon.

Other than that a decision to sell should be on the basis of value.

If I buy a dollar for 10c and it rises to 50c should I sell because I just 5xed my money? Nope, you'd be selling a dollar for 50c.

Quote from: Untamed on Feb 08, 2025, 08:30 PMHad I started at your age, I'd be home and hosed by now. No question. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.
I am incredibly privileged, no doubt about it.

I wish you the best.

Mjrstar

I'm with vnz.

If your money can work harder for you elsewhere, within  your risk tolerance that's where it should be regardless of average purchase price


If it cant work harder elsewhere then thats great!

I have sold a few loss makers that have FINALLY turned around but like to think the best lessons aren't free and we learn as we go..

On oca, does anyone know roughly how many sales they'd need to make at the helier to break even.

Untamed

#1671
Quote from: ValueNZ on Feb 08, 2025, 09:16 PMIf you're required to sell to pay for something then the buy price is still irrelevant, you just take the price the market gives you. Even if it's lower. That's just the risk you take on by having a relatively short investing horizon.

That's an entirely different scenario. I'm not talking about selling shares to pay for something. I'm talking about needing to consider whether staying invested in OCA, is the best use of what money I have, given that OCA is providing me with literally nothing right now. No dividends, and no capital gain (on paper currently). So Basil is right (don't gloat  ;) ) - one does have to wonder just how long we are going to have to wait with this company.

Having said that, I don't need to sell, so why would I choose to sell at a loss? I don't have disposable income for investing now, beyond what I already hold. So I cannot wear a loss, as easily, or as painlessly, as some of you probably can.

But I do have to face the reality that I could be dead before I get any return from OCA.
P.S. I'm really not doing a good job of explaining this

Waltzing

#1672
sometimes a share can turn around due to the market getting a lift and you can sell out at cost or even better a profit..

a case in point is ANZ and WBC... both hit by the investigations back in 2017 into improper business operations.

Today both these stocks are back where they were and even higher than in 2016..

now this might been seen as exceptional due to buy backs..

a weak KIWI means that OCR may in fact take longer to come down..

but if inflation in tamed in a year or two and the OCR comes back down and the government does something to help this sector an investor can rotate out...

Unfortunately the writing was on the wall for this sector a while ago and this companies complex accounting made it difficult to see the real picture...

its always very difficult to make these decisions but the best thing is to model the possible loss in a spreadsheet and model investing in other companies to see when your investments turn from debits to credits..

Buzz

The growing role of nurse practitioners, an interesting insight to OCA's nursing staff model
Age is not a good measure of ability

Untamed

There are now five OCA facilities cutting staffing hours:

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/541822/slashed-staffing-hours-trigger-protest-at-auckland-aged-care-home?fbclid=IwY2xjawIbMb9leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHbsAh7XjvmbAJ348KlSP_7_pycqTduvT7PIAoQ4M3_09zZoe3dmimnbk4g_aem_Ucv1Neq5NIZc7-WpwMsWnQ

Funny how, so far, cuts to staffing hours is apparently the only cost-cutting measure Suzanne has taken.

Bring on the takeover offer. I am no longer interested in this company.

Greekwatchdog

Quote from: Untamed on Feb 14, 2025, 09:18 AMThere are now five OCA facilities cutting staffing hours:

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/541822/slashed-staffing-hours-trigger-protest-at-auckland-aged-care-home?fbclid=IwY2xjawIbMb9leHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHbsAh7XjvmbAJ348KlSP_7_pycqTduvT7PIAoQ4M3_09zZoe3dmimnbk4g_aem_Ucv1Neq5NIZc7-WpwMsWnQ

Funny how, so far, cuts to staffing hours is apparently the only cost-cutting measure Suzanne has taken.

Bring on the takeover offer. I am no longer interested in this company.

Your passion for the industry is compelling, however the time has come for changes. I am ok with this as long as they do not compromise the quality of care they the residents require.

Whilst there are disgruntled staff they tend to be pissed because changes like this cost them. Could they run leaner and become more efficient with a reduced work force? Has the occupancy fallen? Are staff numbers high still because of Covid?

Ultimately OCA Management need to improve the performance of the business and they believe they can without compromising quality of care. Time will tell.

Whilst you are obviously pissed with the decision, your willingness to see another NZ Asset to foreign Invader is disappointing especially given MET and ARV were sold off cheaply.

We are all here to get a return on our money and frankly OCA have been disappointing with the returns on our dollars over the last 4 years, yes given that Covid hit them the hardest. Excuses I am over.

Time to start making money for the shareholders, just not employing people for the hell of it. Starting to make this sound more like an inept over bureaucratic Government agency which OCA is not.


Untamed

Quote from: Greekwatchdog on Feb 14, 2025, 10:06 AMUltimately OCA Management need to improve the performance of the business and they believe they can without compromising quality of care. Time will tell.

Once, I would have given them the benefit of the doubt on this. But my experience and gut instinct tells me that cutting care staff (in particular) absolutely will have an impact on residents. Sure, they will probably still get their showers, assistance with dressing and toileting, but "care" is a hell of a lot more than simply personal care tasks. OCA stated in that article that they will still be meeting government guidelines for staffing levels. Those of us in the know, understand that those guidelines are just that - guidelines - which were created some years ago. There is currently an ongoing campaign for "Safe Staffing Levels" with submissions already made to government, asking for regulated staffing levels, not just guidelines. The current guideline levels are inadequate and below what is considered "safe staffing levels." So OCA's assurance that they are still meeting the guidelines, are meaningless.

If people simply want Mum or Dad clean, and fed, sure - go ahead and cut staffing levels. But if you want more than that for your parent, reduced staffing levels should concern you.

QuoteWhilst you are obviously pissed with the decision, your willingness to see another NZ Asset to foreign Invader is disappointing especially given MET and ARV were sold off cheaply.

Yep, I agree. I am disappointed in myself for now being open to a takeover. Go back through my many posts on OCA and you will see that a takeover has always been the very last thing I ever wanted. I will publicly admit, here and now, that in hindsight, I should have never invested in the RV sector. It is a sector that is "too close to home" and yes, I also admit to becoming emotionally invested in OCA. So, I have nobody to blame but myself.

QuoteWe are all here to get a return on our money and frankly OCA have been disappointing with the returns on our dollars over the last 4 years, yes given that Covid hit them the hardest. Excuses I am over.

Time to start making money for the shareholders, just not employing people for the hell of it. Starting to make this sound more like an inept over bureaucratic Government agency which OCA is not.


Nobody in this sector is employing people just for the hell of it. Well not the staff on the ground anyway.

mike2023

Many care homes have cut staff hours and the biggest cuts are not to nursing staff, mainly support like activities, cleaners, laundry and maintenance. I have family working in one unlisted company. What they actually do with care is reduce minimum hours and offer extra shifts or employ casuals on an as needed basis. If you saw how much maternity leave these places are handing out, it's almost like the place to work when you plan on having kids, I have heard of people coming back 6 months pregnant.

Basil

#1678
Before this was listed under private equity ownership they were making $19.5k EBITDA per annum per care bed.

8 years into the transformation program that was supposed to lift returns on care they are now making $8.5k EBITDA, less than half.

Worse, in inflation adjusted real terms compared to $19.5k 8 years ago, they are only making approx one third of what they used to make.  That's seriously messed up.  No surprise to me that the new CEO is trying to clean up that mess to some degree.

Of course it would be lovely if staff had heaps of time to talk to lonely old people for longer than while they are attending to their physical needs but we don't live in a perfect world.

BlackPeter

Quote from: Basil on Feb 14, 2025, 11:18 AMBefore this was listed under private equity ownership they were making $19.5k EBITDA per annum per care bed.

8 years into the transformation program that was supposed to lift returns on care they are now making $8.5k EBITDA, less than half.

Worse, in inflation adjusted real terms compared to $19.5k 8 years ago, they are only making approx one third of what they used to make.  That's seriously messed up.  No surprise to me that the new CEO is trying to clean up that mess to some degree.

Of course it would be lovely if staff had heaps of time to talk to lonely old people for longer than while they are attending to their physical needs but we don't live in a perfect world.

So - at the moment we seem to have some people who want Platinum care for everybody, but unfortunately clients and state seem only to be prepared to pay for Bronze.

Here might be a solution: OCA (and other care providers) could, and I think should cost a standard care program which is sufficient to satisfy the legal requirements ... and offer a top-up solution (as many levels as you like: Silver, Gold or Platinum care) with the customer choosing (and paying) whatever option suits them.

Asking for the Rolls, but only prepared to pay for the Mini clearly does not work.

What about that?