Main Menu

MFB - My Food Bag

Started by nztx, Jun 25, 2022, 02:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

KW

Quote from: Hectorplains on Nov 01, 2023, 10:11 AMNo surprises in that.  Apparently, HF burnt $22m on marketing in NZ last year.  That has bought them significantly more visibility.  They grew revenue but profits fell. 

 

The end of the free money era, where companies subsidised consumers by funding their non profitable business operations with endless cash provided by shareholders, will eliminate more than a few household names in many industries over the next year or two.  
Don't drink and buy shares in a downtrend, you bloody idiot.

Hectorplains

Quote from: KW on Nov 02, 2023, 11:05 AMThe end of the free money era, where companies subsidised consumers by funding their non profitable business operations with endless cash provided by shareholders, will eliminate more than a few household names in many industries over the next year or two. 

Jarden's has cut their target price 44% to 25cps but retained their buy rating.

The collapse of Supie should sound further warning, if any at all is really required, for investment in the 'conveniently delivered to you sector.'


Hectorplains


winner (n)

Updated this chart for a laugh

Could say MFB share price doing worse than Metro Glass share price

Doesn't bode well for future

But then it's a new ball game and we should only be looking at where to now, forgetting the past

You cannot view this attachment.

Hectorplains

A thorough debunking of the myth that meal kits are a cheaper option than supermarket shopping. Contrary too to MFB's website claim that their Bargain Box is," a cheaper average price than supermarket delivery."  Sounds like pork pies are on the menu.


Mos

Quote from: Hectorplains on Nov 09, 2023, 11:54 PMResults due in two weeks. 

In 2022, about 90% of US customers at the five major meal delivery services canceled their subscriptions by the end of the year.

I'm struggling to see MFB surviving the next 18 months. 

This is the challenge with MFB investment case - no confidence it will still be around and prospering in 5+ years.

Auto Rower

#306
Quote from: Hectorplains on Nov 12, 2023, 06:07 PMA thorough debunking of the myth that meal kits are a cheaper option than supermarket shopping. Contrary too to MFB's website claim that their Bargain Box is," a cheaper average price than supermarket delivery."  Sounds like pork pies are on the menu.



Not Only cheaper but by far superior Quality .
In fact you cannot even find food of the quality and freshness any big supermarket chain .
Is what it is a unprofitable kiwi company pedling top quality fluff battling against a big yank outfit

Hectorplains

Harbour ceasing to have substantial holding. They sold the last tranche at 15cps.  40 % discount to where Jarden values MFB, at 25csp and that with a "buy" rating too... Which is all a little odd when Harbour is owned by Jarden. So, it's almost like they aren't following their own advice.  Do as I say, not as I do.  That is if anyone is still listening, after all they were the arranger and joint lead manager of MFB's IPO.


Mos

Quote from: Hectorplains on Nov 13, 2023, 06:38 PMHarbour ceasing to have substantial holding. They sold the last tranche at 15cps.  40 % discount to where Jarden values MFB, at 25csp and that with a "buy" rating too... Which is all a little odd when Harbour is owned by Jarden. So, it's almost like they aren't following their own advice.  Do as I say, not as I do.  That is if anyone is still listening, after all they were the arranger and joint lead manager of MFB's IPO.



Interesting. Jarden "buy" rating helpful for their asset management selling down. Nothing to see here, all Chinese walls working no doubt.

Hectorplains

Or Chinese Whispers.  It was actually "bye" as in get it gone! 

Popeye

This stock has become a bet on the survival of the business.

If they can stay in business and squeeze out a return on sales of say 5% then shareholders could be rewarded at current price levels.  Richly rewarded if some growth could be achieved eg. diversification, using automation to achieve scale economies.

If the business model is a bust and home delivery is a fad or uneconomic, then kiss goodbye to your dosh. 

So is it a boom-bust industry that will have its time in the sun again when the economy picks up?  Or was it all a mirage that is now coming into focus?  I would say if they can make some money at this point in the cycle, and they can offer a convincing outlook narrative then they could be worth a small wager.  Until then they are a crap-shoot...

Mos

Well put Popeye. I don't know which so will stay clear. If I was forced to bet on one of the two options I would back the transitory flash in the pan option (in the spirit of Pumpkin Patch). However, I could be wrong.

Basil

#312
I still find it remarkable that many so-called investment professionals (AKA institutions), were stupid enough to believe the lies that this was a growth company when "Blind Freedy" could see the growth they'd experienced in the lead-up to the float was built off the back of Covid lockdown demand.

As for the promotors creative attempts at building contrived apparent demand by limiting investment to recent MFB customers and then strongly encouraging them to "tuck in" as though there was a huge banquet to be had.... predatory behavior at its very worst.

A truly disgraceful fiasco from the beginning to what I think in due course will be the end.


Mos

Yep. Pretty typical process and outcome for a Private equity IPO though. MyFoodbag - where private equity eats investors lunch. Adds a bit of cost to the meals for the customers who bought in.

Hectorplains

Mid year out, in the Chair's eyes this represents a "successful period of transition."  I'm not convinced that they're out of the woods yet. 

NPAT:  $2.5 million.  58% down on the same period last year. 
Ebitda: $7.4m. 36 % down..
Revenue: $83.8m. 11% down.
Gross margin: 1.4% down
Deliveries: 652K.  80k down
No dividend

Active customers up 57k - 61k but that growth appears to be in their "bargain box."  Which doesn't tally with the minimal reduction in margins.