Main Menu

MFB - My Food Bag

Started by nztx, Jun 25, 2022, 02:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Auto Rower

Quote from: Basil on May 11, 2023, 06:35 PMMPG have a LOT of debt and are a complete basket case in my opinion.

Leaving aside the atrocious rort of naive investors' money
The $64,000 question regarding MFB is do they have a sustainable business model or not ?
Is there some point where it might actually be a fair risk reward price to consider "tucking in" ?
I don't know.    Is there anyone who wants to take a shot at opining on this ?
Is there a pretty good chance this is headed to receivership or not ?
That's the elephant it was such an atrocious ipo ,no one can forgive them .
But there are a lot less profitable & un profitable companies out there priced a lot sillier so there may well be a tucking in point .
In another week 8 days to be precise  after the earnings results we will know if we have missed the chance to tuck in to a food bag or missed picking up a sick bag . 

Ferg

Quote from: Basil on May 11, 2023, 06:35 PMIs there anyone who wants to take a shot at opining on this ?

Happy to opine on a forecast but not their "value"....this is based on the H1 result and the recently released FY23 trading update:

Hard to see how volumes can be down 11.8% while revenues are down 8% - to achieve that requires an extraordinary shift in the average price paid.  It could be "8%" is "8.9%" rounded down.

I believe GM% will be relatively neutral - MFB have shown they can manage those costs.

CM% will be round 24 to 24.5% which is down on last year's 27.2%.  Whilst there will be some cost savings due to lower volumes assembled and delivered, there will be fixed cost components that cannot be avoided.  Note volumes in H2 will be about 100k meals less than H1, which was 730k.

Assuming no reduction in marketing spend versus H1 (they have to sell their way out of this hole) and no change in overheads, then EBITDA comes in at $18m which is at the lower end of the guidance figure of $18-$20m.  Take off ITDA and I get NPAT of $8m for the year (which is about $2m for H2 added to $6m for H1).  YoY drop of -$12m or -60%.  Reducing marketing activity and spend may provide some temporary financial upside to this forecast, but at what future cost?

I also noticed in their HY report they have taken on debt so they are not "debt free".....and current liabilities outweigh current assets by almost 5:1 which is horrendous.  Assuming they remain solvent, they need to turn around the volume declines to get out of this and not pay any sort of dividend until they are debt free.

IMO the investment case = highly speculative.

Basil

Nice synopsis Ferg.  Thank you.

Onemootpoint

Quote from: Ferg on May 11, 2023, 09:57 PM.....and current liabilities outweigh current assets by almost 5:1 which is horrendous.  Assuming they remain solvent......

That says it (nearly) all and enough for me to (again/ still) say, no thank you.

Left Field

#229
I struggle to see much joy for holders in this result.

(Kudos to Ferg for his accurate prediction in post #226.)

https://www.nzx.com/announcements/411678

• Revenue of $175.7 million, down 9.4% compared to FY22
• EBITDA of $18.2 million, compared to $34.0 million in FY22
• NPAT of $7.9 million, compared to $20.0 million in FY22
• NZ's most affordable meal kit, Bargain Box, grew active customers by 12% year-on-year
• Transformational investment in automated pick technology rolled out at assembly centres
• Cost reduction initiatives implemented to ensure alignment with current demand
"The difficulty lies not in new ideas... but in escaping from old ideas." (J M Keynes.)

Crackity

Quote from: Left Field on May 19, 2023, 08:42 AMI struggle to see much joy for holders in this result.

(Kudos to Ferg for his accurate prediction in post #226.)

https://www.nzx.com/announcements/411678

• Revenue of $175.7 million, down 9.4% compared to FY22
• EBITDA of $18.2 million, compared to $34.0 million in FY22
• NPAT of $7.9 million, compared to $20.0 million in FY22
• NZ's most affordable meal kit, Bargain Box, grew active customers by 12% year-on-year
• Transformational investment in automated pick technology rolled out at assembly centres
• Cost reduction initiatives implemented to ensure alignment with current demand


Their solvency looks like an issue to me - current assets of 4.6 mill / current liabilities of 25.1

I'd be nervous of trading while insolvent if I was a director


lorraina

I like writing off intangibles and then seeing how a company's balance sheet looks.
MFB 'total equity is $57,978 mil.
However, taking out the $85,263 mil of intangibles the total equity becomes a negative -$27,285 mil.

Teitei

Using debt to pay dividends in the last 2 years.

That is enough to put most prudent investor off!

Basil

Quote from: lorraina on May 19, 2023, 09:17 AMI like writing off intangibles and then seeing how a company's balance sheet looks.
MFB 'total equity is $57,978 mil.
However, taking out the $85,263 mil of intangibles the total equity becomes a negative -$27,285 mil.
My goodness.  I remember how things worked out for Evolve who had a similar situation in their balance sheet with wildly overstated intangible assets.  Massive destruction of shareholder value there too.


lorraina

The question then is ; do MFB's intangibles have any value,and if so what.?
As far as I am concerned they have between Nil and bugger all,based on current earnings..

Basil

#235
Quote from: lorraina on May 19, 2023, 09:33 AMThe question then is ; do MFB's intangibles have any value,and if so what.?
As far as I am concerned they have between Nil and bugger all,based on current earnings..

MFB = More Fudged Books.  The whole float was fudged in my opinion.  Dressing this up as a growth company when you, I and many other experienced investors could clearly see the only reason for some temporary growth was Covid and people unable or too scared to go to the supermarket.

Crackity

Quote from: Basil on May 19, 2023, 09:36 AMMFB = More Fudged Books.


Mush For Brains if you buy these

Basil

Quote from: Crackity on May 19, 2023, 09:39 AMMush For Brains if you buy these

LOL Post of the week !!

Waltzing

A Puke Bag  stock...

Sideshow Bob

Quote from: Crackity on May 19, 2023, 09:39 AMMush For Brains if you buy these

First trade through at $0.20 - 1.5c higher than yesterdays close.
"Mayor Quimby Even Released Sideshow Bob — A Man Twice Convicted Of Attempted Murder. Can You Trust A Man Like Mayor Quimby? Vote Sideshow Bob For Mayor."