STU - Steel & Tube Holdings

Started by Shareguy, Jun 24, 2022, 03:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Shareguy

Craigs say

Encouragingly, the Group's $80m bank facility with ANZ has been extended out to 2028, however with net debt continuing to track higher ($55.8m as at Oct-26 vs. $48.0m in Jun-26), Carling remains concerned about the Group's B/S positioning, given STU continues to be loss making

Crackity

Plenty of feedback re my missive against poor old Susan Paterson y'day. Most of you agreed: I don't know how more plainly I can put it, but Paterson's performance as a chair was shocking, no ifs or buts — the company lost most of its value during her watch and investors in the company have been left out to dry. One reader questioned how much Paterson was paid during her time. My back of envelope calculations imply well over $1m, and she owns roughly $70,000 worth of STU shares. The brains trust at the IoD will have you believe that an "independent" director and chair is a good thing, but I mean, here we have a real world example of very little alignment with shareholders and a poor performance as a result. You can't tell me the two aren't linked. I am quite certain that a director who had a material part of their wealth deployed into Steel and Tube would be thinking about things quite differently.

What gives? Why are we so content with a sorry state of affairs where so-called professional directors are paid well, do a poor job, and the shareholders turn a blind eye or, worse, are considered a "noisy minority" (heaven forbid). See the IoD's piece of fan fiction below, from their "Four Pillars"


To date, I have not read a single critical media story about Paterson's time as chair, or her replacement who appears to be cut from the same "professional director" cloth. This is not accurate: the columns I publish on BD and here count. I wrote about Steel and Tube vs Vulcan recently.

Anyway. I digress. When I published my article in BD critical of the IoD some time ago their comms person, a man called Aaron, wrote to my editors to complain about my column. He wrote "I realise he [Eden] might not know this, as corporate governance doesn't appear to be his strong suit", which is precisely the kind of sneering comment you expect from a group that refers to unhappy shareholders as a "noisy minority".

Anyway, here's a statement on corporate governance from Robert Stempel, who chaired GM in NZ (the book I found this from, now long out of print, misprints his name as "Semple".


It's a pithy and to-the-point piece on the duty of a board. Ironically, Stempelwas voted out (poor old Stempel took over the company as the gulf oil crisis reared its head, and the world entered into recession).


Eden trying to get me to pay for his substack - i havent but he's not wrong in the above comments 🤔