Recently listed. Investor presentation.
http://nzx-prod-s7fsd7f98s.s3-website-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/attachments/SMI/435027/423350.pdf
I confess I have a guilty pleasure in that I am slightly addicted to watching "Gold Rush" on the Discovery channel, but I know nothing of any real substance about gold mine economics, however, the numbers as presented look quite interesting.
Who's going to join with me on this speculative "Gold Rush" adventure? What could possibly go wrong lol
Disc: I have bought a small stake.
Quote from: Basil on Jul 29, 2024, 11:47 AMRecently listed. Investor presentation.
http://nzx-prod-s7fsd7f98s.s3-website-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/attachments/SMI/435027/423350.pdf
I confess I have a guilty pleasure in that I am slightly addicted to watching "Gold Rush" on the Discovery channel, but I know nothing of any real substance about gold mine economics, but the numbers as presented look quite interesting.
Who's going to join with me on this speculative "Gold Rush" adventure? What could possibly go wrong lol
Disc: I have bought a small stake.
Admittedly - I don't know a lot about goldmining as well. Used to own some miners, though to add diversity in my portfolio (e.g. OGC), and some of them did overall ok in my portfolio (no x-baggers, but over the long term some acceptable return plus providing the hoped for decoupling from share indices, while others (in the exploratory phase) just kept draining shareholder funds. There are always excuses for another CR.
One thing I noticed is that at least the larger miners seem to consider NZ share-holders as an "after"-thought - even the ones active in NZ. Sold my OGC shares when I noticed that I have to provide a Canadian tax return (and this was before they pulled out of NZX and ASX) - or lose a big share of my dividends to the Canadian IRD.
But - this is probably not relevant for Santana (assuming they operate only in NZ, do they)? Current political constellation looks good for them - Shane Jones does not care about destroying the environment ... only thing is - every time the political pendulum swings right, it turns back to left (and vice versa) - and lets face it, while goldminers try to pretend to be environmentally sensitive, it is much easier to find information about goldminers destroying the environment than information about them improving it.
I recon as long as one just uses the pocket money and does not need to live close to the mine, it is probably ok.
Quote from: BlackPeter on Jul 29, 2024, 12:23 PMI recon as long as one just uses the pocket money and does not need to live close to the mine, it is probably ok.
Disc: Half of one percent portfolio allocation, so yes, just chump change for me. You're absolutely right about the new Govt's attitude to mining. If there's Gold in them there hills, let's dig it out ! 250 jobs created. I doubt anyone on an unemployment benefit and a Green party member will be applying for one of them lol.
Left field started the conversation last week.
I went into this quite deep after selling down dividend payers that stopped or reduced dividends. Mhj,stu,hgh,fbu.
I'm looking at those potential Juicy dividends but of course they have to make their timelines.
Pfs this year,final investment decision mid'25,first production mid '26.
Good luck to that I suppose.
Quote from: Clearasmud on Jul 30, 2024, 01:17 AMLeft field started the conversation last week.
I went into this quite deep after selling down dividend payers that stopped or reduced dividends. Mhj,stu,hgh,fbu.
I'm looking at those potential Juicy dividends but of course they have to make their timelines.
Pfs this year,final investment decision mid'25,first production mid '26.
Good luck to that I suppose.
Thanks. Do they anticipate a capital raise to fund this project and capex prior to production?
Quote from: Basil on Jul 30, 2024, 10:49 AMThanks. Do they anticipate a capital raise to fund this project and capex prior to production?
They probably do.
They said payback is 1 year at current gold prices so that assumes a loan of $200m?
There are 35 to 40 million unlisted options mostly at $1.08
Pretty cool adventure. Like being part of the Gold Rush series on Discovery channel but you don't have to get your hands dirty lol
Quote from: Clearasmud on Jul 30, 2024, 11:03 AMThey probably do.
They said payback is 1 year at current gold prices so that assumes a loan of $200m?
There are 35 to 40 million unlisted options mostly at $1.08
I suppose that's assuming everything goes to plan?
Rule of thumb for any project you haven't done before is to multiply with two and take the next higher dimension - ok, maybe 20 years are too conservative if everything goes right, but I haven't yet seen a lot of mining companies which returned the capital in a year.
Say 2 to 3 years if everything goes well - so, they will need $500m.
Why do I need to think back at Pike River? Sure, they searched for black gold, but they had as well a quite attractive business case, didn't they?
http://nzx-prod-s7fsd7f98s.s3-website-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/attachments/SMI/435256/423621.pdf
Latest drill results marked as price sensitive...I confess I have no idea of the significance of them but they do say at the end a reserve upgrade is likely.
Yeah BP I hear you. Watch the Gold Rush series on Discovery channel and learn what could possibly go wrong, usually does lol. I think of this as "horse racing" punting, without the Govt and TAB skimming off ~ 30% of the prize pool. You might win big or lose most or all of your money. "Bet" accordingly lol
Quote from: BlackPeter on Jul 29, 2024, 12:23 PMOne thing I noticed is that at least the larger miners seem to consider NZ share-holders as an "after"-thought - even the ones active in NZ. Sold my OGC shares when I noticed that I have to provide a Canadian tax return (and this was before they pulled out of NZX and ASX) - or lose a big share of my dividends to the Canadian IRD.
But - this is probably not relevant for Santana (assuming they operate only in NZ, do they)? Current political constellation looks good for them - Shane Jones does not care about destroying the environment ... only thing is - every time the political pendulum swings right, it turns back to left (and vice versa) - and lets face it, while goldminers try to pretend to be environmentally sensitive, it is much easier to find information about goldminers destroying the environment than information about them improving it.
... just had a look into their latest annual report (https://www.annualreports.com/Company/santana-minerals-limited) and noticed that I was wrong.
They do have operations running as well in Cambodia and Mexico (oh, dear ...).
Anybody interested in investing into them clearly needs to understand the whole company. What is their environmental record in these other countries? Any past liabilities which still might blow up? What are the political risks? What is the likelihood they manage to operate in these countries without the need of "off the ledger payments" (aka brown paper bags)? What is the risk that a regime change in any of these countries might bite them and how will this impact on their overall viability?
Might be interesting to read in this context e.g. about OGC's history over the decades ... can be fun if your capital is taken hostage by various political militia groups (like e.g. OGC in the Philipines).
Clearly - an investment in this company is not just about finding some nuggets in central Otago. This brings all the complexity and risks of a large international mining company (like e.g. Rio Tinto), but without the legal, political and financial backing.
Not my idea of having fun, but hey - each investor is different ...
Thanks for sharing your perspective and for the link.
Read through the annual report and agree this is very speculative.
It's rare for me to make a pure momentum play, (reasonable uptrend on the ASX listing) but it's just at a level that i would call a "punt"
Not sure if you are aware, (good friend has done extensive work on the water treatment systems at the Waihi Gold mine) that they can filter and treat the water used in mining to a good standard now.
Of course, I can't attest to how they will go about this in N.Z. or elsewhere but our environmental laws, (Shane Jones refreshing approach to new projects notwithstanding) are very, very strict. 250 new jobs is pretty good plus all the downstream benefits for regional suppliers and the overall economic multiplier effect. I hope it works out well for everyone.
http://nzx-prod-s7fsd7f98s.s3-website-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/attachments/SMI/436369/424986.pdf
More encouraging drill results at RAS, just east of Queenstown.
Looks like its going to be a LOT bigger than the Waihi mine which has been going since 1988 !
Market seems to like it and Gold hitting an all-time record of US$2,500 per ounce on Friday last week, up ~ 20% for the year.
I'm up nearly 20% on this little speculative play in just on 3 weeks. Better stay tuned to Gold Rush on the Discovery channel to keep up with all the latest stuff with Gold mining.
Quote from: Basil on Aug 19, 2024, 03:23 PMhttp://nzx-prod-s7fsd7f98s.s3-website-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/attachments/SMI/436369/424986.pdf
More encouraging drill results at RAS, just east of Queenstown.
Looks like its going to be a LOT bigger than the Waihi mine which has been going since 1988 !
Market seems to like it and Gold hitting an all-time record of US$2,500 per ounce on Friday last week, up ~ 20% for the year.
I'm up nearly 20% on this little speculative play in just on 3 weeks. Better stay tuned to Gold Rush on the Discovery channel to keep up with all the latest stuff with Gold mining.
Chris Lee with 1.2% must be pleased.
Stock up aud29c today = close to a million $ to his account.
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/437772/attachment/426839/437772-426839.pdf
Very exciting project. 2.5 million ounces is HUGE !
Quote from: Basil on Sep 10, 2024, 11:51 AMhttps://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/437772/attachment/426839/437772-426839.pdf
Very exciting project. 2.5 million ounces is HUGE !
It is. Not sure, though about the percentage of mining companies which actually delivered to the big promises they made. Let me tell you from experience - it is less than 100%, and actually I'd say its significantly less than that. Lets put it differently - I could not name any mining company which regularly or even frequently delivered on their promises.
During the times I was as well with a small toe in mining (a decade or more ago), I only seemed to have the bad luck that my miners always promised big, but delivered small (if at all).
But yes, the business cases always looked amazing and the reserves huge.
Typical issues I remember:
Bad weather (Ok - I note Otago is semi arid, but hey - who knows what climate change will bring);
Politics and strikes (OK - worse in the Philippines, but not sure what will happen here if after the current stunt of the cigarette and gun lobby some other party takes over the reigns)
Equipment breaking unexpectedly. That's something which seemed to happen frequently - and most of the mining equipment is really expensive and hard to source.
Environmentalists stopping the operation or just making it uneconomical. Sort of coupled with Politics, but always a risk in a country with a still somewhat operational justice system.
Problems (as above) in some other parts of the world sucking company resources. I hear Santana has as well interests in other parts of the world - did I hear Cambodia and Mexico?
Ah yes, and obviously -
reserves are just an estimate. Sometimes they increase, but sometimes they decrease as well.
And hey - we don't even know whether the
gold price is a one way street to riches. Actually - it does go up and down, and given that we reached peak human - who knows whether the demand for new gold will really sustain the current (rather high) gold price? Plenty of old gold around when the old people die and less and less young people inherit whatever they had.
Anyway - the plans always look great.
Good luck to holders (and I mean that). I do hope they have previous mining experience so that they know what they need to look for. It's a dangerous world out there.
I will be watching with interest.
Discl: Some previous mining experience ... OGC, TAP, Pike River, Chatham rise, ATC (yes, they owned a mine as well ...) to name only some of them. I have seen all of above (including gold price dropping). Most of these companies helped to reduce my principal :) No - not really funny, but maybe its an experience people have to go through?
Just a very small flutter for me BP but the drill results do look very encouraging. Decades ago when Mineral resources owned the Waihi gold mine I got a ten bagger out of it.
This mine is a lot bigger so you never know, it might happen again or I might burn $30k with nothing to show for it.
Time will tell.
Quote from: Basil on Sep 10, 2024, 05:13 PMJust a very small flutter for me BP but the drill results do look very encouraging. Decades ago when Mineral resources owned the Waihi gold mine I got a ten bagger out of it.
This mine is a lot bigger so you never know, it might happen again or I might burn $30k with nothing to show for it.
Time will tell.
I am pretty sure you will be fine, no matter how it will go (and yes, I do wish you good luck).
Probably more worried about the investors who can't afford to set 30k (or whatever sum they invest) into the sand.
I guess at the end of the day is mining for a start up like Santana Minerals just a gamble. And yes - nothing wrong to spend an evening at the casino (with a prior determined budget of money you can afford to lose) or to invest money into Lotto tickets as long as the money does not go from any other essential bills one needs to pay. So - absolutely no issue about putting money into a mining start up with little diversification, as long as one considers the invested capital not different to a Casino chip.
What I am more worried about is about the people who put money they can't afford to lose into such ventures ... and that's the reason I try to provide a bit of balance. The thing with mining is - its a high risk venture and it is easy to lose it all, but sure - it can be as well (if done professionally and with some good luck) a high reward game. Which one of these it will be, nobody can say in advance.
Just out of curiosity - do they publish a business case for their NZ venture ... and is it clear whether their NZ mine is financially decoupled from their other (money consuming) adventures in Cambodia and Mexico (one of the risks I raised above)?
At what point in time do you know whether they are successful (or not?) - and will at that point in time still be an opportunity for investors to rescue some of the money which they poured into the project?
To be honest - I noticed with surprise that even Simply Wall Street (the guys who paint everything in pink) agree with my concerns on this company. They point to high risks and a potential breakeven further than 3 years away, which is basically clear text for them having no idea whether they ever will make money.
Anyway - I am sure the ride will be fun for the people who are willing and can afford to pay for the ticket ... no matter where the cart ends up in the end.
Good work adding perspective BP and highlighting the risks of which there are many.
Might not even get consented by the Government appointed panel that's being set up- to review these things under the fast track process.
I think if / once they get consent they will be after finance for the capex for it and no doubt that will involve a capital raise and some debt. Don't know much more about the process but yes, I'd be prepared to tip another $30K in if they make a very good business case., Not an avid Gold investor by any means, I just have fond memories of Mineral resources profits and am a bit addicted to watching the Gold Rush series on the Discovery channel. Getting older so I thought I'd have a Gold mining adventure, without having to get my hands dirty.
As you suggest and is acknowledged. It really is a punt but the drill results do look incredible, so I guess I think the odds are in my favour a little bit. I suppose we all have a bit of "gambler" in us eh. Thanks for your good wishes, I'll probably need them lol. :)
Gold hit another all time record overnight on the US market, around $2,580 an ounce U.S.
Gold for December delivery over $2,600 an ounce and up 35% this year.
Interesting segment on Gold this morning on CNBC. Since 1997 its matched the S&P500 and is up 700%. Gold miners however, they had some major mining ETF on there, up only 55% in that timeframe.
Couple of thoughts I had. Obviously, a lot of money gets spent on "picks and shovels" so to speak and those returns suggest very strongly you are better off holding the physical asset.
That said, compared to a lot of Australian mines which are extremely remote and dry, the rise and Shine prospect in central Otago with ready access to power, water and spare parts for machinery, (can be airfreighted to Queenstown airport only one hour's drive away), seems to have some significant advantages.
My ten bagger on Mineral resources which owned Waihi mine decades ago probably gives me more appetite to have another go especially seeing as this has the potential to be several times larger than the Waihi mine. I'm guessing economics of scale come into play a lot.
Modern portfolio theory suggests having around 5% of your portfolio in alternative type assets. I rather own gold or gold miners any day of the week, which has proven to be a useful store of value for thousands of years than crypto, tulips, deer, goats or whatever else is the latest craze.
Interestingly, my good friend who designed the water treatment plant at the Waihi gold mine told me the other day that technology has improved a lot in the decades since then and they can treat the water being discharged to a very high standard. I'm no ESG enthusiast by any means but I know they use some nasty stuff to extract the gold so I am pleased to hear that.
Anyway, it's been an interesting ride so far, up ~ 50% in just 6 weeks. Maybe on my way for a ten bagger again, let's see.
I've just had a quick look. So correct me if I'm wrong...
It looks like they are saying project NPV is NZ$1b (@10% NPV). Firstly I'd say a 10% discount rate for an early stage gold mine, seems extremely low.
Secondly with a market cap of $430m relative to the project NPV (even at 10%) it doesn't scream 10 banger potential..
Waihi still going long after it was supposed to be uneconomic. They can only estimate the resource based on the early stage drilling done to date.
10% discount rate not that high now but by the time this gets going and interest rates are a lot lower.
Quote from: BlackPeter on Sep 11, 2024, 03:31 PMI guess at the end of the day is mining for a start up like Santana Minerals just a gamble. And yes - nothing wrong to spend an evening at the casino (with a prior determined budget of money you can afford to lose) or to invest money into Lotto tickets as long as the money does not go from any other essential bills one needs to pay. So - absolutely no issue about putting money into a mining start up with little diversification, as long as one considers the invested capital not different to a Casino chip.
Quite agree with your tenor BP, but think visiting the casino is different - you know before your visit (or should:), that your expected return is going to be negative, the price you will pay for a few enjoyable hours of ambiance and flashing lights. I expect, on average, to get a return on SMI, but as you say, history shows that most gold miners go belly up (or get absorbed by another) after some years, eating thru a lot of capital before finally giving up.
If any of you have time and patience, visit the New Talisman (NTL) thread on the other site for an example.
Quote from: teabag on Sep 15, 2024, 11:55 PMQuite agree with your tenor BP, but think visiting the casino is different - you know before your visit (or should:), that your expected return is going to be negative, the price you will pay for a few enjoyable hours of ambiance and flashing lights. I expect, on average, to get a return on SMI, but as you say, history shows that most gold miners go belly up (or get absorbed by another) after some years, eating thru a lot of capital before finally giving up.
If any of you have time and patience, visit the New Talisman (NTL) thread on the other site for an example.
Good reference to the NTL thread. While I never really followed them, I remember that the thread has seen many years of (groundless) hope and increasing frustration coming through. Certainly another great resource for hopeful investors to do their research before the plunge - just to help managing expectations.
And yes, you are right re the casino comparison. One would certainly hope that the average return for gold startup's is positive (rather than at the casino, where the odds are always against the player). However - to be honest, I don't know whether this is true. I only found in a brief research a reference that the chance to turn a promising anomaly (i.e. promising drilling results) into a money making mine is less than 1% (another reference said 0.1%).
However - I don't know, where on that path Santana sits. I understand they invested already into several sets of drillings, i.e. their odds should be definitely better than that, and I don't know either whether the total money invested by all gold startups is smaller or larger than the total money made by all gold startups.
The latter would be an interesting point for prospective gold mining investors. Does anybody know and have a reference?
Quote from: Basil on Sep 14, 2024, 12:17 PMGold hit another all time record overnight on the US market, around $2,580 an ounce U.S.
Gold for December delivery over $2,600 an ounce and up 35% this year.
Interesting segment on Gold this morning on CNBC. Since 1997 its matched the S&P500 and is up 700%. Gold miners however, they had some major mining ETF on there, up only 55% in that timeframe.
BP, that's not start-up's per se, but the major gold mining ETF CNBC quoted was only up 55% since 1997 with the physical commodity itself was up 700%. All the evidence you really need that you are better off holding bullion than gold mining shares. I have some silver bullion already so this investment, while acknowledging is more speculative, sits alongside that position.
In terms of it being a ten banger, it is already for those that got into this in the early days in early 2021 on the ASX for under 20 cents. How much more juice since it was listed on the NZX a few months ago, time will tell but it's a huge resource and is already, based only off very early-stage drill results, said to be more than twice the size of the Waihi mine. Waihi has been going for decades and was as mentioned earlier, very lucrative so I am happy to ride this for quite a few years and see where it takes me.
Anyone interested should check out the back story of Macraes Mine Otago (NZ's largest currently active Gold mine producing over 5 mill ounces of gold since 1990.)
Suffice it to say as I recollect it, the Aussies got a bargain at NZ shareholders expense.
After listing on NZX circa 199O and attracting NZ shareholders $'s
https://natlib.govt.nz/records/22186830?search[subject_text]=Macraes+Mining+Company&search[path]=items
Around 1993 threats of closure and hard times drove down the SP and led to the company exiting NZX (and takeover by Oceana as I recall)
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/hard-times-for-oceana-gold/ZDTD5UJT76554VSIXGWZ44NO5Y/
Once the shift to ASX and OceanaGold was complete..... Oceana started finding fabulous 'new' reserves.....
https://www.mining.com/oceanagold-extends-mine-life-boosts-reserves-at-macraes/
I wish investors well. I'm happy to give this one a miss. (JMO...GLH's)
The back story on the Wahi gold mine. Interesting times in the 1980's with Mineral resources and was quite an adventure.
https://www.waihigold.co.nz/education/history/timeline/
3:1 share split is all go
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/438845/attachment/428065/438845-428065.pdf
Santana shares on fire. I'm up just on 70% in less than 2 months. If only all investing was this lucrative.
Great to point out the risks but back stories about how overseas companies have diddled Kiwi's are pretty common and that doesn't stop us investing in all sorts of things now. Besides, I can't sell this being in such a strong uptrend because I'm too scared KW will give me a really good thrashing if I do lol (price at time of editing, $2.65). 3:1 stock split will take it back under a buck...for a while. Once they get consent for the mine, I think we're off to the races and this will end up being several times bigger than the Waihi mine. What could possibly go wrong lol
Annual report. https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/439077/attachment/428336/439077-428336.pdf
Santana made the cut for fast track approvals process. Page 7 item 2 in the PDF included in this article.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/livestream-government-to-make-fast-track-approvals-announcement/EJ4QKFMPTRD3RGHT2ZBUF4Z5F4/
Quote from: Basil on Oct 06, 2024, 04:56 PMSantana made the cut for fast track approvals process. Page 7 item 2 in the PDF included in this article.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/livestream-government-to-make-fast-track-approvals-announcement/EJ4QKFMPTRD3RGHT2ZBUF4Z5F4/
Will be interesting to see, whether the next government will honour these fast track approvals ... if they get approved by that time anyway.
According to Dr. Google:
QuoteGold mining is one of the most destructive industries in the world. It can displace communities, contaminate drinking water, hurt workers, and destroy pristine environments. It pollutes water and land with mercury and cyanide, endangering the health of people and ecosystems.
Clearly an activity highly suitable to a fast tracking process without sufficient investigation.
Interesting as well to see whether the company needs to stamp up a sufficiently sized bonds / securities - just in case something goes not to plan. Sh*t happens, and in gold mining it seems to happen particularly frequently.
Since its made the initial cut, the process now is a panel of environmental and planning experts has about 6 months to approve or decline the application so if approved it will be well before any prospect of an unholy alliance between the Māori party, Greens and Labour get into office.
A good friend of mine designed the water treatment plant for the Waihi gold mine and told me recently that technology has improved a lot in the last few decades, and they can now treat the discharged water to a very good standard. I think its an exciting project and will provide a substantial number of highly paid employment opportunities in Otago.
Announced on Friday. https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/439492/attachment/428931/439492-428931.pdf
Quote from: Basil on Oct 06, 2024, 06:22 PMSince its made the initial cut, the process now is a panel of environmental and planning experts has about 6 months to approve or decline the application so if approved it will be well before any prospect of an unholy alliance between the Māori party, Greens and Labour get into office.
A good friend of mine designed the water treatment plant for the Waihi gold mine and told me recently that technology has improved a lot in the last few decades, and they can now treat the discharged water to a very good standard. I think its an exciting project and will provide a substantial number of highly paid employment opportunities in Otago.
Announced on Friday. https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/439492/attachment/428931/439492-428931.pdf
I share your views on the "unholy alliance" - its just, deciding between them and the current lot feels like the ancient shippers choice whether to sacrifice their crew to the sea monster Scylla or their ship to the sea monster Charybdis ...
But back to Santana: I am sure that your friend is correct that the technology has improved. It always does. So has the technology to keep nuclear plants safe, and accidents are still happening. The thing is - both humans and nature (Earthquakes, storms, floodings) tend to throw curve balls, and history shows that we are again and again "surprised" when the next earthquake or the next deluge is a bit stronger than "expected". Artificially reducing the checks by prioritizing commercial interest over safety and scrutiny is a recipe for disaster. It always was - and I remember a poster telling us that history is the best guide for the future.
Remember - Pike River Coal was as well "scrutinised" by a government deciding to throw out the Health and Safety Requirements for Mining and criminally under-resourcing Work safe inspections. Actually - a National /NZF government as well. Cheers to Bolger / Shipley and Winston First, and their respective parties have now another opportunity to further reduce our environmental and safety standards. Well, ask the people of Greymouth and the shareholders of PRC how well that went last time.
While I am sure the PRC shareholders enjoyed the opportunity to build their mine on the cheap, I doubt they enjoyed the total loss of their capital. Scylla and Charybdis?
Obviously - I know, that a coal mine and a gold mine have quite different risks, but if you have the same reckless government removing all safety stops, its not hard to predict the outcome. Only difference is - coalmines without proper oversight "just" kill the staff (as tragic as this was for anybody involved), while gold mines without proper oversight can make large landscapes uninhabitable and poison rivers and groundwater for generations. Choose your monster - I know which one I would prefer.
With all due respect BP, you're drawing a long bow comparing Pike river coal mining with gold mining and "rather conveniently" choose not to compare the proposed Santana project to other successful gold mines like Waihi that have been providing hugely beneficial economic gains and hundreds of high paying jobs for decades without any major environmental calamity.
Yes, I realize as a country we can continue to rely on agriculture, tourism and other safer environmental endeavors and that probably means we continue down the track of "enjoying" a much lower standard of living than Australians who take the approach, if there's valuable materials in the ground, lets dig them up.
Which is the right approach is something people have been debating for generations and won't be resolved on here so it's probably better we accept we have different viewpoints on this and leave it at that.
I note yesterday Santana's rise and shine mine got fast track approval and a share split 3:1 is proceeding later this month.
Fast track approval https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/439505/attachment/428958/439505-428958.pdf
Share Split https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/439521/attachment/428967/439521-428967.pdf
Quote from: Basil on Oct 07, 2024, 10:52 AMWith all due respect BP, you're drawing a long bow comparing Pike river coal mining with gold mining and "rather conveniently" choose not to compare the proposed Santana project to other successful gold mines like Waihi that have been providing hugely beneficial economic gains and hundreds of high paying jobs for decades without any major environmental calamity.
Yes, I realize as a country we can continue to rely on agriculture, tourism and other safer environmental endeavors and that probably means we continue down the track of "enjoying" a much lower standard of living than Australians who take the approach, if there's valuable materials in the ground, lets dig them up.
Which is the right approach is something people have been debating for generations and won't be resolved on here so it's probably better we accept we have different viewpoints on this and leave it at that.
I note yesterday Santana's rise and shine mine got fast track approval and a share split 3:1 is proceeding later this month.
Fast track approval https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/439505/attachment/428958/439505-428958.pdf
Share Split https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/439521/attachment/428967/439521-428967.pdf
Look Basil, I fully understand the differences between coal and gold mining. What the two examples have in common is that PRC was approved under a government which allowed all sorts of short cuts re environmental standards as well as re health and safety - and it looks like history is repeating itself with Santana.
I realise that Waihi has been allowed to extend ... but whether the risks the environmentalists highlighted will eventuate is a question we only can answer in another generation or two.
Always dangerous, if you solely listen to one side of the story (the one which is paid for by the company); Have a look at the other side:
https://www.oursnotmines.nz/situation
And don't forget, that Waihi at least had to go through the full approval process - i.e. whatever happens, it will have been better vetted than Santana ever will. Santana on the fast track is clearly the hope for profits over environmental or health and safety considerations.
PRC did show us, how this can work out.
Santana's rise and shine proposed mine is not on DOC land.
This is the opening statement from Santan's Chairman in their recently released annual report.
He seems quite adamant that the fast-track approval process will have the same standards as a normal RMA approval process, just with a more focused approach. I guess you either believe him or you don't. I think we can all take it as read, you are deeply skeptical BP
QuoteDear Shareholders
It is with great pleasure I present you the Company's Annual Report for the year ending June 30, 2024.
The year has been one significant progress for the Company. Of particular note has been the completion of a
scoping study on our Rise & Shine (RAS) discovery within our overall Bendigo-Ophir Gold Project. This returned
extremely solid commercial outcomes and justified a rapid push through feasibility studies and the seeking of
development approvals.
Our continued resource definition drilling at RAS aimed at upgrading the Resource Categorisation from
predominantly Inferred to Indicated delivered some great intercepts and with it a more refined and predictable
resource model to plan from.
Whilst we have been and continue to meticulously collate baseline data and assessments to ensure our project
does not have any materially adverse impacts on the environment, a surprise unveiling of a newly proposed
Fast Track Consenting Bill by the new Luxon Coalition Government was greatly welcomed. Whilst the proposed
Bill offers us no shortcuts and maintains the high standards of the original RMA approvals process, it does
potentially provide a faster and prescribed timeframe for permitting.
This proposed elimination of sovereign risk that investors, and financiers of all future significant projects were
facing in development projects in NZ is well received
Quote from: Basil on Oct 07, 2024, 11:42 AMSantana's rise and shine proposed mine is not on DOC land.
This is the opening statement from Santan's Chairman in their recently released annual report.
He seems quite adamant that the fast-track approval process will have the same standards as a normal RMA approval process, just with a more focused approach. I guess you either believe him or you don't. I think we can all take it as read, you are deeply skeptical BP
Absolutely - I am sceptical. And lets face it - he would say that, wouldn't he? Normally we are both deeply sceptical when company chairs or CEO's make noises and promises like that - aren't we? Sure, it helps, if they have a longstanding history of keeping their promises, but does the Santana chair?
I guess the difference is - this time you are a holder and I am not. I am sure we agree that sometimes they get it right and sometimes they get it wrong ... and predicting in advance which is which is impossible ... so, its just a risk with a potentially fatal outcome.
Hard to see why a government with a long history of putting individual profit both over environmental concerns (they did happily oversee decades of environmental deterioration in NZ) and workers health (PRC, various logging companies, agriculture) should behave this turn differently. But hey - I guess time will tell and given that I didn't like the other bunch either (but for quite different reasons) is it hard to decide which evil to pick. Individual decision whether people prefer to be eaten by Scylla or drowned by Charybdis.
Back to Santana (and ignoring the common good). I guess from an investors perspective who happens to live far enough from the mine are any environmental risks just another financial risk to contemplate (as lack of Health and Safety turned with Pike River into a financial risk with quite negative outcome). I know the land and that no DOC land is concerned, but I don't know what happens if they leak accidentally cyanides or similar nasties into groundwater finding their way e.g. into the neighbours (animal or human) water supplies. But I guess its just money, its just the health or the life of some animals and possibly humans - and some hundred (or thousand) sq km of land which may or may not be destroyed for generations to come, so - who cares?
Actually - there is one more risk I forgot ... and which this press article reminded me off:
https://www.thepress.co.nz/business/350442353/controversial-central-otago-gold-mine-designated-fast-track-project
(might be paywalled)
The area houses a lot of our top South Island wineries. Just imagine something goes wrong in the mine and some of the chemical nasties required for mining leak into the water supply of the wine yards.
We might need to work on some really good advertisement campaigns:
Otagoes wine is good for your health - Yeah Right!
or what about:
Otago Pinot Noir - do you want some cyanide with that?
We even could sell mixed cases from different yards with one out of the six bottles polluted - Otago roulette!
Why would anybody want a proper environmental application process which can be challenged in court given that our administration always gets it right? Hold on, does it?
Let's just forget about the 250 well paid jobs the region desperately needs, dozens of contracting and engineering firms that benefit by hundreds of millions and the positive multiplier effect on the economy from all those firms and those employees extra spending. Far better for the environment they just keep grazing sheep on the farm such that the sheep farmer can't even afford to shear the sheep as it costs more to do so than the wool is worth.
I accept that mining of any kind has some risks, but it also has substantial economic benefits for the country. My good friend I have known for a very long time tells me the risks with water discharge are very low and treatment standards now are very good, and I am happy to take his word for it.
I get it we see things from a very different perspective and we're not going to find common ground on this issue.
https://stockhead.cmail20.com/t/d-l-eudmjl-yupddjlly-q/
Quote from: lorraina on Oct 07, 2024, 06:20 PMhttps://stockhead.cmail20.com/t/d-l-eudmjl-yupddjlly-q/
It appears the author falls to a certain hype related to the development of the gold price.
Just wondering based on which assumptions the business case for this mine works?
I had a look at the last roughly 60 years of gold price trend, and while it went overall up, there are decades of flat lining between peaks, and there have been as well substantial drops in gold price after each of the peaks.
I hope the business case still works in case the gold price falls by 50% or so after the current peak?
After the 1980 peak gold dropped by 62% until the 2001 bottom (i.e. two decades down). A long time to lick ones wounds.
After the August 2011 peak gold dropped by 44% to the Nov 2015 bottom.
If I look at the chart ... looks like a new peak is looming, doesn't it? At some stage people notice that they can't eat gold, and given that we reached already peak human, the number of people who want to buy it for status will start to drop as well.
Gold price trend - Copy.JPG
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/436488/attachment/425096/436488-425096.pdf
Base Case US$1,650 per ounce.
Please read this sad article BP. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/fears-mill-closures-could-create-ghost-towns-in-the-central-north-island/PNKCQT4YVNETJDRHLZUS55DELQ/
Of course, it goes without saying it's the exact opposite when a new employer creates 250 new jobs + all the contractor and engineering work.
Quote from: Basil on Oct 08, 2024, 11:13 AMhttps://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/436488/attachment/425096/436488-425096.pdf
Base Case US$1,650 per ounce.
Please read this sad article BP. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/fears-mill-closures-could-create-ghost-towns-in-the-central-north-island/PNKCQT4YVNETJDRHLZUS55DELQ/
Of course, it goes without saying it's the exact opposite when a new employer creates 250 new jobs + all the contractor and engineering work.
Look - I am not principally against mining of essential minerals (which we all need for our modern life), and neither against gold mining (despite the latter hardly improving our lives ...). I am however for a thorough assessments of the risks and benefits of mining activities, given that they can cause terrible damage to the environment (and there are ample of examples for mining destroying livelihoods around).
The fast track process Santana hopes to use is unproven and clearly reduces the necessary scrutiny for such a venture. Greed over environment. Our kids and grandchildren are likely to pay the bill for this folly.
Did you ever consider how many Central Otago wine yards could be killed off if Santana's tailings start to leak? I am sure this would kill off tens of quite profitable companies and more than the 250 jobs you claim Santana might create.
Always important to look at both sides of the coin.
Not saying it will happen, but I consider it reckless to just point to potential benefits without properly considering the risks. And what's worse - the potential benefits are all for the owners of Santana, while the potential risks are mainly carried by the neighbours and the environment. What's the benefit for a neighbouring wine yard or sheep farmer who carries the risk of ground water pollution through the mine? How are they reimbursed for taking this risk? Quite unhealthy balance and not good to see our government trying to avoid any scrutiny of these risks but rushing to approval. She'll be right? She rarely is ...
Apart from a little bit of subsidence with Waihi, (which the company reimbursed owners for), there have been no effects on the environment that I am aware of from the Waihi mine which has been in operation using cyanide and other chemical extraction techniques since 1988.
https://www.waihigold.co.nz/environment/environmental-management/cyanide-and-acid-drainage/cyanide/
We need gold mines so you and billions of others can buy jewelry. Yes there is some small risk that is ameliorated carefully with carefully designed water treatment systems and tailings ponds.
Okay its Friday so indulge me in some flippant comments please.
Shall we ban all cars because it's been proven beyond any doubt that just in a tiny country like N.Z., hundreds of people die every year, and thousands are injured? Shall we ban oil and gas drilling because of its risks to the environment. Oh wait, the previous numpties in power did exactly that and now we are running out of gas. Shall we ban growing sheep or cattle on that farm because of nitrogen run-off?
I know,... this is ultra safe for the environment. Maybe we could all go back to making baskets out of flax and collect the dole, how would that work out for the economy ?
Isn't the saying an apple a day keeps the doctor away...but wait, apple seeds contain cyanide so my goodness, how come we are still alive ?
My dog likes the apple cores so I give him what's left of my apple after I have eaten the good bit each morning and he eats it seeds and all, how come he's still alive and wagging his tail happily ? https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/08/20/fact-check-apple-seeds-have-cyanide-but-not-enough-kill/3359754001/
I am sure the integrity of the design of the tailing's ponds will come under really rigorous review.
Quote from: Basil on Oct 11, 2024, 06:53 PMApart from a little bit of subsidence with Waihi, (which the company reimbursed owners for), there have been no effects on the environment that I am aware of from the Waihi mine which has been in operation using cyanide and other chemical extraction techniques since 1988.
https://www.waihigold.co.nz/environment/environmental-management/cyanide-and-acid-drainage/cyanide/
We need gold mines so you and billions of others can buy jewelry. Yes there is some small risk that is ameliorated carefully with carefully designed water treatment systems and tailings ponds.
Okay its Friday so indulge me in some flippant comments please.
Shall we ban all cars because it's been proven beyond any doubt that just in a tiny country like N.Z., hundreds of people die every year, and thousands are injured? Shall we ban oil and gas drilling because of its risks to the environment. Oh wait, the previous numpties in power did exactly that and now we are running out of gas. Shall we ban growing sheep or cattle on that farm because of nitrogen run-off?
I know,... this is ultra safe for the environment. Maybe we could all go back to making baskets out of flax and collect the dole, how would that work out for the economy ?
Isn't the saying an apple a day keeps the doctor away...but wait, apple seeds contain cyanide so my goodness, how come we are still alive ?
My dog likes the apple cores so I give him what's left of my apple after I have eaten the good bit each morning and he eats it seeds and all, how come he's still alive and wagging his tail happily ? https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/08/20/fact-check-apple-seeds-have-cyanide-but-not-enough-kill/3359754001/
I am sure the integrity of the design of the tailing's ponds will come under really rigorous review.
Look Basil, you seem to invest a lot of time and words into misrepresenting my position and then leading your version of it to absurdum. Not an unusual method to quieten the other side, but not very constructive either.
Just for the record:
- I do accept and understand that mining is an essential activity to support our modern lifestyle.
- While gold mining is less essential than mining for many other minerals, I do see some benefits (like $$$ and jobs) coming even out of this activity, but there are as well significant risks which easily could (if not appropriately managed) weigh heavier than the benefits.
- Pointing to one other gold mining activity (Waihi) which by the way did go through a full consenting process (no fast track) and using this as evidence that nothing bad will happen if Santana gets fast tracked is quite below your usual argumentation standard. Its like saying: People are drink driving all the time and I know a pal who didn't had an accident despite driving under the influence, which clearly is evidence that drink driving is a safe activity.
So - I am not in principal opposed to another gold mine in New Zealand (or in Central Otago). I am however opposed to putting dangerous and not even essential activities on a fast track process to consent. Dangerous activities deserve full scrutiny - this is what I am saying and what I think we own our children.
Happy to continue the discussion, but please don't misrepresent my position again.
Fair enough BP, (I was just winding you up a bit late on a Friday afternoon lol). I note your position is mainly an objection to the fast-track process. You seem to have real doubts the same checks and balances will apply as through a normal consenting process.
Santana seem to be saying that they will still have to go through what amounts to a full consenting process, just that it will be through a focused panel of experts over a defined timeline. I guess one of your concerns is who those so-called experts are going to be, which is certainly not an unreasonable concern to have because I have learned the word expert can be defined many ways.
To be fair, it's not just Waihi that has performed without major incident. No other material environmental problems stemming from Gold mines in N.Z. come to mind and I have been investing on the NZX since 1980.
Let's just follow this and see what hoops Santana have to jump through. It will be interesting. Keep in mind this is just a pure spec play for me and a tiny proportion of my portfolio. For the record, I'm also a NIMBY and glad this development is not happening near my back yard but it is what it is, and I guess if consented, those on nearby properties are just unlucky they have to carry a degree of contingent risk with no compensation for it.
1:3 split approved, and new SP recognised on NZX - but link/MUFG haven't updated holding numbers
I'm sure they'll sort it out over the weekend. I reckon $1 is on the cards.
Quote from: Basil on Oct 25, 2024, 06:47 PMI'm sure they'll sort it out over the weekend. I reckon $1 is on the cards.
I sold some of these, doubled my money and bought LRV ,another Goldie, a stock mentioned on the other forum
It was 13c ,shot up to 35c ,I bought some,now it's 69c!
Easiest money ever.
I've just purchased a new stock,another junior goldie with some of the profits.
A gold wag is predicting 9k gold lol.
Gold and silver as commodities up very strongly this year, circa 40%. I wouldn't rule out the prospect of it continuing much higher as the US currency, long thought of as the world's reserve currency continues to lose credibility from its ever-escalating debt problem, of which neither of the parties seem particularly interested in addressing.
Quarterly report. https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/440778/attachment/430540/440778-430540.pdf
Personally have a bit of investment from early days of NZ listing.
They have some Aussie Analysts reviews on their website, latest ones clarify a few points to earlier posts. Will not get too involved to the merits or otherwise of Fast Track Bill but it will account for a 40+ month reduction in date of gold being poured. Don't see the management taking short cuts on any responsibilities.
Speculative yes but sits at ever increasing upsides to last assessments, also ASX requirements negate any assessment beyond first ten years of production. JP Morgan Funds are large early supporters, suspect much of the initial supply was drip fed from the likes of them, plus Management are personally invested at this stage.
Suspect there are plenty of old timer beliefs that there is a lot more in the Rise and Shine than they even knew in their eyes it had.
from the Santana website latest Analyst reporting, earlier Ocean Equities also some merit. https://www.santanaminerals.com/s/SMIASX-On-the-Fast-Track-100724-r8l7.pdf
hope coherent enough my initial posting on registration, I hope to get a trip to a community weekly event to personally clarify few small matters shortly.
Welcome to the forum Otago K. Great post, thankyou.
Latest Santana Minerals website detailed Shaw and Partners analyst reporting. 15 November 2024 around Pre Feasibility Reporting
https://www.santanaminerals.com/s/CR_DP_SMI_20241115_726628c967664478a57ad26b4e5534b9-4al9.pdf
The PFS adequately addresses all my initial queries to the company, still intend to get to an upcoming community weekly drop-in presentation in the coming weeks though. Further my read on the PFS is it would justify an increased confidence and earlier than initially projected timeline to production to what the market previously knew of.
There is some volatility across both the ASX and NZX listing, think the present pull back is both a matter of supply increased (ASX 18 million and NZX a million offered) coinciding with day 1 and 2 of PFS release. Also potentially some reversal of earlier hype based on spot price increases for gold and day trader activity.
In my current position I am not likely to be a further buyer on market, and am unlikely to sell until I feel the SP is going to allow some reduction in my weighted average per share funds invested.
Couple of risk factors I can not totally dispel are a Greens influenced future regulatory regime, also that Russia massively alters the global supply principally from Siberian mining in the future. Also don't see the present Gold spot prices should be too heavily relied upon in assessing a future miner share valuation which some might have in their mindset at the moment.
Great post Otago K.
My thoughts on the future direction of the gold price are that we have the US running record fiscal deficit's and eventually this must undermine confidence in their currency. Gold is real and tangible and has been a reliable store of value for thousands of years, most unlike Tulips, goats, venison, cryptocurrency or whatever else is the latest fad that's seen boom and eventual bust over the years.
Mine economics look sound to me and net present value at more than three times current market cap at today's closing price is based only on proven reserves. Plenty more in the inferred category and currently undiscovered will be found and mined as the life of mine progresses just like has been the case at the Waihi mine. I think this is an exciting development, one I am very much looking forward to supporting. I presume they will need a fresh capital raising at some point to fund the initial plant capex and I am happy to support that in addition to my existing modest holding.
Quote from: Basil on Nov 20, 2024, 06:03 PMMine economics look sound to me and net present value at more than three times current market cap at today's closing price is based only on proven reserves. Plenty more in the inferred category and currently undiscovered will be found and mined as the life of mine progresses just like has been the case at the Waihi mine. I think this is an exciting development, one I am very much looking forward to supporting. I presume they will need a fresh capital raising at some point to fund the initial plant capex and I am happy to support that in addition to my existing modest holding.
Yes I could echo your thoughts here, at current spot gold price levels they are now envisaging it would be economic to smelt ore with half the levels of gold they had been projecting 6 months back would be required. On my reading a bit between the lines I wouldn't envisage a very high likelihood of any capital raising for the plant capex, perhaps the sum will be more likely debt funded for 10 months until pay back. May then be in a position to get a maiden dividend late in calendar year 2027.
Quote from: Otago K on Nov 21, 2024, 12:30 PMYes I could echo your thoughts here, at current spot gold price levels they are now envisaging it would be economic to smelt ore with half the levels of gold they had been projecting 6 months back would be required. On my reading a bit between the lines I wouldn't envisage a very high likelihood of any capital raising for the plant capex, perhaps the sum will be more likely debt funded for 10 months until pay back. May then be in a position to get a maiden dividend late in calendar year 2027.
Anybody able to predict the gold price in 2027? If you look at past charts - it is not a one way street heading upwards ...
Neither is cryptocurrency. Would you rather own Gold with its long proven store of value that dates back thousands of years, something you can feel and touch and that's real or some electronic new currency that's currently the market darling just like Tulips were all the rage hundreds of years ago but are now ostensibly worthless? No brainer question as far as I am concerned.
Quote from: Basil on Nov 21, 2024, 01:20 PMNeither is cryptocurrency. Would you rather own Gold with its long proven store of value that dates back thousands of years, something you can feel and touch and that's real or some electronic new currency that's currently the market darling just like Tulips were all the rage hundreds of years ago but are now ostensibly worthless? No brainer question as far as I am concerned.
Of course its not cryptocurrency - who said (or implied) that?
However - if you look at the gold price over the last 100 years (i.e. including a number of the last really big global crises) - It went up and down. Unless you assume that this changes in future, I am wondering how the people felt who bought the gold at previous peaks and watched several periods with drops of up to 80%.
Just our of interest ... Gold price dropped throughout WW II.
Just imagine you are in 1980, buy gold for US$2500 an ounce and watch it dropping down to US$500 in 2000. Not funny, particularly given that it doesn't even compensate for inflation.
Gold 100yr - Copy.JPG
But absolutely - history does not repeat itself and from now on gold only will go upwards. Will it?
Amendment:
here is the live chart (scroll a bit down) - this makes it easier to see important dates in history and how gold price reacted to them:
https://www.macrotrends.net/1333/historical-gold-prices-100-year-chart
QuoteOf course its not cryptocurrency - who said (or implied) that?
Gold v Crypto was a good debate on the world's leading business network, CNBC this morning.
For mine, the important thing is to keep these sorts of speculative bets to a sensible size.
Santana shares and my physical holding of precious metal, namely silver, combined is less than 1.5% of my portfolio allocation. That's just a hobby sized allocation for me. You're quite right, both crypto and gold have traded with huge swings in the past so the future is anyone's guess but maybe worth a small punt eh mate ;)
If you are interested in being knowledgeable of the business you might be invested perhaps this Michael Laws hosted The Platform NZ 25 minutes Podcast with SMI CEO Damian Spring is worthy of a look, perhaps more good info to the non financial aspects. May end up behind a paywall after a time perhaps but I don't know.
https://theplatform.kiwi/podcasts/episode/santana-minerals-ceo-damian-spring-on-the-tarras-mine
M Laws is always interesting...lately he has been digging into all sorts of things...
hes is worth a listen ..
You Tube posted 8 days ago, I suggest highly worth viewing if SMI consideration is on your radar, admittedly I had a sense of Sam Smith being a bit of a market hype man and had preferred to watch the Damian Spring content in the past.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XF3WGg-lGGU
I haven't found the window of opportunity with real life family commitments and health considerations to make the trip to community presentations I had posted intent to in earlier posts of this thread. This might answer all my outstanding questions of the proposed operation.
The boil may have come off the stock price this month, logic would suggest a negative correlation of the price level to good or bad news the last few months, Mr Market eh, maybe the expectations of others haven't been met whereas I see otherwise. Anyways suns been up a while now so check it out if you want a bit of icing it may sweeten your portfolio for a good few years. Mining is always speculative but this video tells what might be the conceivable out-performance future IRR, c/f Macraes Operations of Oceania Gold is never likely to match. Think the random websites that refer to Mexico and ? Indonesia activities maybe obsolete, I believe one Santana operation overseas has no further financial commitment on SMI with a reduced % share, and the other has been walked away from, suspect SMI see where the value is in their previous opportunities.
At approx 4 mins "which keeps it hidden from the local community". For what reason.. theft or that it would be upsetting to snowflakes
Quote from: Habitz on Dec 15, 2024, 10:04 AMAt approx 4 mins "which keeps it hidden from the local community". For what reason.. theft or that it would be upsetting to snowflakes
Just my speculation regards the quote, firstly perhaps reflective of Sam Smith maybe not the best PR man when attempting to appease say those who have a fundamental Mining is dirty and has no place in NZ, no need to consider mitigations of my concerns, just do not do it (Mine).
I know the types of requirements for council consenting for a building on the land, will be couched in terms of whether it is normal to the visuals for the surrounding aspect etc. In essence it would need to be seen from the air or to a very restricted views likely from higher grounds not publicly free to access I suspect, around the Shepherds Creek to be aware of it.
The proportion of current cash burn being applied to appeasing other folk who hold they have rights of concern are not being skimped on, admittedly that might be to ease the submission hurdles.
All my joining dots but in a context that I have spent time on the land of one of the 3 principal Stations that are under royalty for recovery quantities of gold some 30 years ago, not really my neck of woods but have some connections nearby.
I've just been have a look at Santana. The thing that strikes me, is that management place far too bigger emphasis on the project economics assuming gold A$4k which appears to be the High Case. This produces an A$1b NPV.
The base case, using A$2.8k, is a far less attractive NPV of A$0.5m. I'm finding it hard to get excited about this project, unless of course we expect gold to remain at these levels.
Quote from: Dolcile on Jan 07, 2025, 11:30 AMI've just been have a look at Santana. The thing that strikes me, is that management place far too bigger emphasis on the project economics assuming gold A$4k which appears to be the High Case. This produces an A$1b NPV.
The base case, using A$2.8k, is a far less attractive NPV of A$0.5m. I'm finding it hard to get excited about this project, unless of course we expect gold to remain at these levels.
If you are interested in my viewpoint kindly review posts 18,38,49,54,57,and 59 which sets out my thinking and forms the basis for a very small portfolio allocation to Santana.
Others will have far more extensive gold mining investment experience than me but as I understand it they need to lay out a very conservative base case for project financing. I also understand they cannot put a valuation on anything other than probable reserves. Inferred reserves or future discoveries as they progress through life of mine cannot be encapsulated in any DCF valuation.
Gold is current trading at about $US2,650, approx $A4,200 so the high case you refer too is actually the spot price case. Like any other commodity Gold could go down, sideways or up or in any of those directions to a varying degree. Based on my research its outperformed the S&P500 since 1997.
To me, the way the US are undermining their future with running record fiscal deficits, they look like they are headed for a fiscal implosion at some point in the next decade. That and the current geopolitical environment suggest to me Gold is a good place to invest as part of a well-diversified portfolio.
Keep in mind the Marth Hill mine at Waihi started in the late 1980's, was only expected to have a very limited life but is still going and has another 10 years to go.
This is highly speculative as it hasn't even got resource consent yet but my long term prognosis is this:
I think they will find a lot more Gold as they progress through the life of mine and it will have a vastly longer lifetime than 10 years.
I suspect the Gold price will keep going up broadly in line with the S&P500 over time. In time, we could see Gold substantially higher than where it is now.
All that said, all you can do is work with the mine economics as they are currently presented. At current spot prices the mine has a forecast NPV of more than three times the market cap. That NPV is calculated using as discount rate of 10%. If things go well with this mine and the gold price keeps going up in line with the S&P500 investors today could see extremely lucrative returns over the life of mine.
Yes, its highly speculative and risky but expert commentators talking on CNBC this morning were opining that people should have as much as 20% of their portfolio in alternative assets. Traditional portfolio theory suggests having 5-10% of your portfolio in alternative assets. Whether that's Gold, some other precious commodity, crypto, art, racehorses or whatever, I'm of the opinion that one's Invesment in alternative assets needs to be based on some credible proposition that looks like it's going to make money.
Triple your money on current spot prices looks pretty good to me, (the high case if Gold doubles or triples over the next 10-15 years from here could be ten times your money), but it's just a very small stake at this stage for me. Doubling it or more at some stage down the track is something I am thinking of doing.
Santana has had a pretty decent pullback from its high of ~ $2.70 pre-split, (90 cents ex split). I'm watching and waiting for the entry point to double or perhaps triple my original modest outlay.
FWIW. I made ten times my money on a small stake in Mineral resources in the 1980's when I first started investing. It would be nice in my latter years to repeat that feat with Santana but a lot of things would have to progress favorably for that to happen. Time will tell.
Latest drill results https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/444834/attachment/435353/444834-435353.pdf
Interesting price and volume action today. Up 20% on unusually high volume. Wonder if they'll get a "speeding ticket " ?
On no news as well, pretty odd... See what happens tomorrow when Aus and Auckland are back from holiday
Quote from: raW tent Buffer on Jan 27, 2025, 04:24 PMOn no news as well, pretty odd... See what happens tomorrow when Aus and Auckland are back from holiday
Suspect it has been a bit of a delay in market attention to the 23 January issued December 2024 Quarter report.My assessment still more to the upside of what was previously in the public knowledge.
Also I don't think the share price has too much correlation to what I see as positive news days or otherwise. Maybe the boom early NZX months were hype and some FOMO, on a restricted initial supply?
As I understand it the ASX have very restrictive rules around disclosures in prospective phase when it has any questions of certainty. I am guessing the Directors probably envisaged a somewhat higher share price than of late due to some performance bonuses lapsed, certainly can not identify anything else that has fallen short on where they are projecting.
Later in 2027 is still a bit of a wait for any distribution returns but maybe anyone buying needs to watch lower $0.50 over the longer term???
Just in today more to the positive outlook I think.
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/446210/attachment/436913/446210-436913.pdf
Gold hits record high overnight, nearly $US2,900 an ounce.
The way the U.S. are debasing their currency with record fiscal deficits I think the oldest currency in the world, (gold) could continue its bull run for a very long time.
There's something very real and tangible about gold and silver that has stood the test of time for thousands of years
Santana looks well positioned to me with an exciting future ahead of it. With the economic multiplier effect I expect north of 1000 jobs to be created by the mine which will be a real boost to the region
Disc: Small holding
Quote from: Basil on Feb 05, 2025, 08:29 AMGold hits record high overnight, nearly $US2,900 an ounce.
The way the U.S. are debasing their currency with record fiscal deficits I think the oldest currency in the world, (gold) could continue its bull run for a very long time.
There's something very real and tangible about gold and silver that has stood the test of time for thousands of years
Santana looks well positioned to me with an exciting future ahead of it. With the economic multiplier effect I expect north of 1000 jobs to be created by the mine which will be a real boost to the region
Disc: Small holding
I agree that Dump works hard to remove the US and its currency from any international relevance. Nobody likes bullies. Not sure, though whether this must be a driver for the gold price. Did gold really go up during the decline of the Dutch empire or the British Empire? It certainly dropped during WW II - which would have been the decline of Hitlers one thousand year long empire (I know, time flies, when you are having fun).
I suppose the gold price is more a measure of uncertainty, and same as gold peaked between 1934 and 1937 (i.e. before the start of WW II- here is a tab: https://nma.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/historic_gold_prices_1833_pres.pdf) might the same now happen with Dumps weird attempts to bully friends and compliment fellow autocrats. While I don't doubt things might get worse for some time, peak risk (not peak pain) might well be right now.
Plenty of time left for Chump to cause chaos. The slow motion train wreck has only just started.
Quote from: Basil on Feb 05, 2025, 10:56 AMPlenty of time left for Chump to cause chaos. The slow motion train wreck has only just started.
Fair point. How do they cite Einstein? Only the universe and human stupidity is infinite, but he was not so sure about the universe. Just wondering how he knew at that stage already about the current white house dweller?
Gold continues its record breaking run. Up $46 U.S. an ounce to $2,933. Next stop $3,000. $5,000 an ounce wouldn't surprise me at some stage in the late 2020's. A price like that could make the Rise and Shine deposit worth several billion. Sure, plenty of risk here but the chance of a 10 bagger is not entirely out of the question either.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/tarras-locals-oppose-major-gold-mining-development-in-their-backyard/FL4LPOZZHVCKTG2SKOROTWZNBY/
Gold one of the few things going up in 2025. Have quietly been accumulating a few of these.
Quote from: Basil on Apr 11, 2025, 03:14 PMGold one of the few things going up in 2025. Have quietly been accumulating a few of these.
The anti mine group has only raised $2.1k last time I looked.
Quote from: Clearasmud on Apr 11, 2025, 06:17 PMThe anti mine group has only raised $2.1k last time I looked.
Great, that'll pay for the first hour of the KC's time for representing their attempt to do a judicial review, who's paying for the other 300 hours lol
A mate of mine just shared this with me. Fun fact of the day - if you took all of SMI's gold out of the ground and sold it at spot prices, it would be worth $8 Billion AUD. My comment, Let's start digging!!
Quarterly report. Much stronger cash position after option exercise. Working on revised feasibility study with much lower waste strip requirements and consequently more capital efficient upfront costs and lodgment of fast-track application for June 2025 which will include financing options. Keep some cash aside for an attractively priced cash issue is my thinking.
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/450586/attachment/442188/450586-442188.pdf
Quote from: Basil on Apr 28, 2025, 11:37 AMA mate of mine just shared this with me. Fun fact of the day - if you took all of SMI's gold out of the ground and sold it at spot prices, it would be worth $8 Billion AUD. My comment, Let's start digging!!
Quarterly report. Much stronger cash position after option exercise. Working on revised feasibility study with much lower waste strip requirements and consequently more capital efficient upfront costs and lodgment of fast-track application for June 2025 which will include financing options. Keep some cash aside for an attractively priced cash issue is my thinking.
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/450586/attachment/442188/450586-442188.pdf
I'm guessing 100 million shares at $1.
Article in herald about rare moth causing problems for Oceana expansion
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/oceanagold-otago-mine-expansion-plans-potentially-derailed-by-rare-native-moth/E7X6MVWKCJAMVIZVBFJOKA62PQ/
SMI appears to be in a break out
From memory the updated feasibility study is due sometime this month and is supposed to contain costing for development and funding proposals. Mr. market appears to be saying the economics contained in that study are compelling. Disc: Small position and happy to support a capital raise.
Bell Potter issued a note on the 29 May 2025 with a price target of A$1.30. You can see the article on the company website at https://www.santanaminerals.com/equity-research
Quote from: afc029871 on Jun 04, 2025, 07:18 PMBell Potter issued a note on the 29 May 2025 with a price target of A$1.30. You can see the article on the company website at https://www.santanaminerals.com/equity-research
Thanks for your post, the Analyst site visit seems to sit where I saw their focus was the start of March this year when I visited their Cromwell admin office community engagement regular 60 minute presentation. about 15 attending two of whom seemed to have negative perceptions, about 10 locals positive, and a few like myself who were likely investors.
The latest changes aim to enable earlier access to viable gold percentages in the ore, and an alternative staged mine pit development plan to access the recoverable gold earlier, and hence I would pick that a CR is not going to be very likely. The pre-strip amounts are about halved from the standing projections.
In hindsight the early April Mr Market drop to below 50c NZ might have been the best point to increase a shareholding. Please remember this is speculative, and in that regards more around consenting etc than any doubts of the likely amount or levels of gold here in my opinion.
Hopefully the operating subsidiary Matakanui Gold Ltd will offer NZ investors a good likelihood of an ongoing fully imputed dividend stream even potentially from Xmas 2027 after the debt levels that I anticipate will be required to be operational, are near repaid.
Looks like Bell Potter have done a good job of sniffing around down there and are really liking the economics of this proposed mine. I doubt any of the local brokers would have the technical skills to evaluate the prospects as well as they have. I agree its speculative and high risk but with high risk comes potential high reward. A 1:1 capital raise at say 50 cents is something I would really welcome. Disc, very modest ~ 2% portfolio allocation so more than happy to double it.
Quote from: Basil on Jun 05, 2025, 10:37 AMLooks like Bell Potter have done a good job of sniffing around down there and are really liking the economics of this proposed mine. I doubt any of the local brokers would have the technical skills to evaluate the prospects as well as they have. I agree its speculative and high risk but with high risk comes potential high reward. A 1:1 capital raise at say 50 cents is something I would really welcome. Disc, very modest ~ 2% portfolio allocation so more than happy to double it.
Bell Potter has SMI as one of very few realistic ASX out-performers if I recall correctly, and a while since they revised a price target.
I am thinking 10 bagger in 24 months maybe conceivable reality.
Two reasons I think they will avoid a capital raise, the quick payback on capital expenditure requirement projected, and that is now shortened, PLUS the director's proportions of ownership arising from future dated options etc would be somewhat diluted. Cook hasn't been adverse to debt in his past history also I have heard.
discl not looking to invest further so uncertain what I might end up doing if a CR was to occur. CR / Funding plans might well be indicated this month, just hope that the FTA submission is in by 25th and maybe is expediently progressed and they can get the plant operational in a timely manner, no great need to stock pile and current spot prices look to good to be missing out on.
Quote from: Basil on Jun 05, 2025, 10:37 AMDisc, very modest ~ 2% portfolio allocation so more than happy to double it.
On reflection, the very near term heavily revised feasibility study due very shortly with a circa 50% lower initial lower overburden strip rate should dramatically improve the already very compelling economics of this mine with its known reserves. I think the chances of substantial extra reserves being found in the years ahead are excellent. Bell Potter's A$1.30 valuation is based on the old prefeasibility study in Nov 2024 and old gold price of A$4,000 and will be updated with the new feasibility study.
The opportunity presented today with really decent volume on the offer at 64 cents to materially increase my position and I took advantage of that. I'm proud to support this new venture which will provide more than 250 highly paid jobs as well as being a major boost to the region. I think this is a very exciting and potentially, highly rewarding new venture. More than happy to put my hand in my pocket for a capital raise to fund capex, if required.
The gold is there. The old timers proved that!! ;D
I think the risk is all around the resource consent - especially if they find a rare moth or gecko or moa. Plenty enough gold and no doubt will be upgraded over time. Look at McRaes....still going.
Yeap, from memory in the mid 80's when the Waihi mine started up again it was supposed to have a approx 10 year mine life and they're still talking about another 10 years, 40 years later lol.
Must be one of the "Sustainable Tarras" members based in one of Tarras' outer suburbs.....
https://www.odt.co.nz/opinion/yes-all-glistens-not-always-gold
Quote from: Sideshow Bob on Jun 09, 2025, 02:55 PMMust be one of the "Sustainable Tarras" members based in one of Tarras' outer suburbs.....
https://www.odt.co.nz/opinion/yes-all-glistens-not-always-gold
Locals (and anyone living downstream) will be concerned to read this in the article.....(if it's true)
"Placing a tailings dam above the Clutha River poses significant risks. That dam will need to hold tens of millions of tonnes of toxic rock and water slurry containing cyanide, arsenic and heavy metals.
Santana reportedly trusts the schist rock is so tight the dam can be left unlined, but seepage is a forever risk. A dam rupture would potentially be catastrophic for the Clutha's wildlife, aquifers, and drinking water of the towns downstream.
Such dam failures keep occurring across the world. So do cyanide incidents.
Santana is unwilling to commit to a bond to cover long-term monitoring or the risk that the tailings dam fails. The company is also yet to commit to the "International Cyanide Code" that regulates cyanide use."
Updated feasibility study with full plans for mine development is expected later this month. Greenies positioning themselves against the mine with emotional statements about the environment is to be expected.
Quote from: Basil on Jun 09, 2025, 04:40 PMUpdated feasibility study with full plans for mine development is expected later this month. Greenies positioning themselves against the mine with emotional statements about the environment is to be expected.
Absolutely - and so is the posturing of the people who are happy to risk the environment and the livelyhoods of others living downstream of their golden goose. Who cares about the lives of ecosystems and people?
Plenty of recent examples highlighting that the the risks of gold mining are not theoretical, but they are killing killing people and ecosystems as we speak. Just lets create another desaster for the sake of some shareholders:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_gold_mining_disasters
And lets face it - our OSH regulations have been weak enough in the past allowing e.g. a greedy company to kill plenty of miners in the Pike River Mine. Sure, this was coal not gold and not too bad for the environment, but people died becaused of weak regulations and greedy owners, concerned only about profit and not safety. Our current government further reduced the regulations and cares still less about the environment and peoples lives.
What possibly could go wrong?
QuotePlenty of recent examples highlighting that the the risks of gold mining are not theoretical, but they are killing killing people and ecosystems as we speak. Just lets create another desaster for the sake of some shareholders:
I acknowledge gold mining is a controversial issue. A good friend has had a lot to do with the water treatment systems at Waihi which have been operating
without incident for about 40 years and providing hundreds of high paying jobs and hundreds of millions of dollars into contractors pockets.
Can you please provide some examples of this death you allege that has happened in N.Z. from gold mines here ?...or are you talking about third world countries that have no consenting processes for mines ?
Food for thought. Cars really do kill hundreds of people in N.Z. every single year and pollute the environment horribly but we all still drive them, including you. Why is that ? The answer is simple, the benefits outweigh the costs, risks and the damage to the environment. The Australian economy has been far more robust than ours, why, because they are not scared to dig up their back yard when it provides high paying jobs and huge benefits to the economy.
During Covid, there was a big thing in Central Otago/Queenstown about reducing the relinace on tourism and boosting other industries. But just yesterday government announced $13.5m to boost tourism numbers by 72,000.
As a local in the general area, would much rather have a gold mine (properly managed run with all adequate consents and controls), than another airport and yet more tourists!!
Quote from: Basil on Jun 10, 2025, 09:59 AMI acknowledge gold mining is a controversial issue. A good friend has had a lot to do with the water treatment systems at Waihi which have been operating without incident for about 40 years and providing hundreds of high paying jobs and hundreds of millions of dollars into contractors pockets.
Food for thought. Cars kill hundreds of people in N.Z. every year and pollute the environment but we all still drive them, including you. Why is that ? The answer is simple, the benefits outweigh the costs and risks and the damage to the environment. The Australian economy has been far more robust than ours, why, because they are not scared to dig up their back yard when it provides high paying jobs and huge benefits to the economy.
Look - one example for a gold mine without accidents is as sensible as saying that driving a car without seatbelt is safe because we know one person who did that for 40 years without an accident. You need to look at the stats, but hey, you know that as well. Amazing how the endowment effect is impacting on people.
And yes, we all accept risks - all of the time. This is part of life, and ok if we try to minimise the risks and accept the residual risks for us and our families / communities in exchange with benefits for the same group. It becomes fishy if one group of people appears to be quite happy to accept risks for a different group of people, to make the first group of people rich or happy with the second group carrying the risks. This smells like oppression and exploitation to me.
We need to find a way to have the people who are exposed to the risks are well informed about them, protected as well as possible and fairly compensated for taking the residual risks ... instead of just lowering the regulations and sweeping the risks (for others / environment) under the carpet.
Quote from: Sideshow Bob on Jun 10, 2025, 10:22 AMDuring Covid, there was a big thing in Central Otago/Queenstown about reducing the relinace on tourism and boosting other industries. But just yesterday government announced $13.5m to boost tourism numbers by 72,000.
As a local in the general area, would much rather have a gold mine (properly managed run with all adequate consents and controls), than another airport and yet more tourists!!
I hear you. Queenstown and the wider district is unbearably overrun with tourists already and ruining it for the locals from what I hear. Queenstown is nothing like the beautiful, quaint little town our family used to holiday at when I was a kid. A goldmine that's out of sight and out of mind that's going to bring billions of dollars into the local economy, provided the risks are managed carefully is probably something other locals would prefer too ?
Lets see what the mine development plans look like BP. In the meantime, if you do have any examples of gold mine incidents in N.Z. causing death or injury, please feel free to share.
Quote from: Basil on Jun 10, 2025, 10:35 AMI hear you. Queenstown and the wider district is unbearably overrun with tourists already and ruining it for the locals from what I hear. Queenstown is nothing like the beautiful, quaint little town our family used to holiday at when I was a kid. A goldmine that's out of sight and out of mind that's going to bring billions of dollars into the local economy, provided the risks are managed carefully is probably something other locals would prefer too ?
Lets see what the mine development plans look like BP.
Sure - choosing between uncontrolled mass tourism and uncontrolled mining for a sensitive area sounds like the choice between pest and cholera.
But maybe the key is the word uncontrolled.
What about sustainable tourism, sustainable agriculture and sustainable mining?
I am neither against tourism, nor against agriculture and neither against (responsible) mining. I am just saying that the current government clearly does not seem care enough about peoples or environment safety, and this is something we and our kids / grandchildren will pay for. And I would see polluted goundwater and / or larger areas of Otago not anymore safe for agriculture due to cyanide pollution of the land as too high.
One big mine disaster is all it needs.
Quote from: Basil on Jun 10, 2025, 10:35 AMIn the meantime, if you do have any examples of gold mine incidents in N.Z. causing death or injury, please feel free to share.
Many of our lakes and rivers are heavily polluted with dairy and fertilizer run-off but that's okay I suppose because its "precious Dairy" Like I said earlier BP, hundreds of people ARE dying every year from vehicles but we all drive them. Queenstown is completely overrun with tourists but we tolerate it because we have too. I'm still waiting for one example of cyanide contamination, one death or serious injury from all the existing gold mining operations in N.Z. over the decades. On the evidence to date, Gold mining is far better for the environment than tourism or dairy....At least the toxic mess is contained rather than being let rip into the environment from farming operations ! Lets drop the pretense that we are a 100% clean and green country with pristine lakes and rivers shall we ?
Macraes a good example of another mine generating enormous economic benefits to the region. More than 600 high paying jobs + hundreds of millions paid to contractors over the years and then the economic multiplier effect from all those people and contractors spending their money over the last 34 years. https://oceanagold.com/operation/macraes/ No nitrogen run off from their operations ruining our lakes and rivers so the water is undrinkable ! Please lets stop pretending dairy isn't ruining the environment shall we ?
Quote from: Basil on Jun 10, 2025, 11:22 AMMany of our lakes and rivers are heavily polluted with dairy and fertilizer run-off but that's okay I suppose because its "precious Dairy" Like I said earlier BP, hundreds of people ARE dying every year from vehicles but we all drive them. Queenstown is completely overrun with tourists but we tolerate it because we have too. I'm still waiting for one example of cyanide contamination, one death or serious injury from all the existing gold mining operations in N.Z. over the decades. On the evidence to date, Gold mining is far better for the environment than tourism or dairy....At least the toxic mess is contained rather than being let rip into the environment from farming operations ! Lets drop the pretense that we are a 100% clean and green country with pristine lakes and rivers shall we ?
You are correct. NZ went over the last 50 years or so through an amazing destruction of our environment. There was a time when it was safe to swim in (and even to drink from) our rivers. Now we are lucky if they are wadeable. There was a time when our beaches were clean and our air breathable. Try latter these days in an inversion event when farmers make their big burn offs.
So yes, agriculture and mass tourism went out of their way to destroy our environment, and clearly - our current government doesn't seem to care at all.
Not sure though I understand why this should be a free for all to further destruct our environment? Maybe we should stop the pollution instead of further increasing it?
Ah yes, and your request to get examples of gold mining destroying the environment in NZ is sort of pathetic. Have a look through the link I posted earlier today. Plenty of recent gold mining desasters all over the globe with the main culprits being Australian, Canadian and US companies running the mines. They clearly don't care about the environment and the safety of their people overseas, and I would not know, why this should be different, no matter whether they mine in the US. Canada, Australia, South America, Africa or in NZ. The only thing which counts for them is fast profits, and the only thing which might protect us are our local regulations. Unfortunately - our current government is weakening them by the year and clearly does not care about peoples safety or the environment.
Just think about our recent mining desasters ... government does not seem to mind dead people in coal mining (like e.g. PRC, they just turned work safe into a toothless tigre), and neither do they worry about gold mining deaths and a further polluted environment.
Nobody, including me wants a free for all. Lets see what Santana have to say about the proposed mine development and environmental protection systems they are planning in due course. Full planning details will be released in their updated feasibility study due out soon. Any further debate before then will just get us into circular arguments that will tire us both out as well as everyone else 😉
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/453788/attachment/446088/453788-446088.pdf
Updated Mine pre feasibility study released yesterday. Looks very good.
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/454329/attachment/446695/454329-446695.pdf
Noting much lower pre-strip, now 6.5 units less than half the 15 in the original study, much lower capex. Disc: I significantly increased my position in late June.
Hey Basil, where do you see the current value of SMI? So hard to know with these gold plays. Obvious risk seems to be not actually getting the permit to dig the stuff up.
Bell Potter valued it at A$1.30 a while back and that's modelled off their old pre-feasibility study and takes a very conservative view of the future Gold price. It will be interesting to see where they value it now given much lower upfront capex. Looking forward to seeing their revised valuation in due course.
Clearly, consent is not a foregone conclusion and is the biggest risk, although under this far more progressive Govt agenda, I think its better, perhaps much better, than a 50/50 chance. First gold if consented is not until early 2027 so this isn't without risk that's for sure and people need to consider their risk tolerance, whether this fits with their ESG beliefs and whether a new unconsented start up mine is for them and if so, what's an appropriate portfolio allocation.
On the other hand Bell Potter called them a speculative BUY and reckoned they are ripe for takeover once consented, or words to that effect and there are very few opportunities this compelling for the big Australian miners to add significantly to their reserves. I reckon a takeover is a very real chance once the mine is up and running. Hopefully that takeover is at least double the share price as it stands today, triple or quadruple your money 2-3 years from now would be much nicer. I would probably best describe my investment here as a fairly large speculative punt that's not for the faint of heart.
Thanks Basil
I spent a bit of time looking at Santana today, and ended up making a small purchase. Keen to see how this one plays out.
@Basil I like your summary of a "fairly large speculative punt". My concern with that is there will be an election before they are mining in any significant quantity and with the way the coalition is polling, it could be a disaster if Labour/Greens and heaven forbid the Maori party got in again. They'd kibosh the thing in a heartbeat and we'll all be forked. For mine, it's a 'smallish speculative punt', and a close eye on an exit if politics seems likely to get in the way. I think another eye on monitoring the gold price is warranted.
Quote from: Dolcile on Jul 03, 2025, 07:54 PMI spent a bit of time looking at Santana today, and ended up making a small purchase. Keen to see how this one plays out.
Welcome on board mate.
Quote from: Buzz on Jul 03, 2025, 08:34 PM@Basil I like your summary of a "fairly large speculative punt". My concern with that is there will be an election before they are mining in any significant quantity and with the way the coalition is polling, it could be a disaster if Labour/Greens and heaven forbid the Maori party got in again. They'd kibosh the thing in a heartbeat and we'll all be forked. For mine, it's a 'smallish speculative punt', and a close eye on an exit if politics seems likely to get in the way. I think another eye on monitoring the gold price is warranted.
Its going to be a horrendous mess if those three get into power and there will be PLENTY to worry about if they do but passing legislation to retrospectively annul what will amount to a mining operation that's well underway, albeit still in the pre-strip and commissioning phase hopefully by late 2026, is the stuff of banana republic's and not something I think even they would stoop too. They haven't tried to stop the operation of the Macres mine or the Waihi mine before so what you're suggesting as a realistic possibility is not something that concerns me as they would open themselves up to a massive compensation claim of the net present value of the mine based on the prevailing spot price of gold at the time...potentially an actionable claim for as much as $2 Billion.
https://www.thepost.co.nz/business/360742481/australian-miner-expects-38b-pre-tax-profits-nz-gold-mine-current-prices
Another article.
AROUND 20,000 (by my guess) NZ investors have bought shares in the Bendigo gold project being developed by Santana Minerals near Cromwell.
The gold discovery is of world-class dimensions, the grade unusually high, the ore easily able to be realised without the high-energy process of burning off carbon before the gold is heap-leached from the crushed rock.
The investors will be elated that the gold price has risen, converting the modelled production of gold into a giant dollar value, probably exceeding ten billion, over a decade or so.
All of this will be highly relevant to those investors.
Naturally there will be an anti-mining lobby. Quite correctly it will want assurances that the project does not create hazards (for example, water pollution), does not damage any unique flora or fauna, does not ruin the life quality of any neighbours, and does not destroy public playgrounds, like national parks.
The authorities that will assess the project are about to be called into action, the consent application to be filed soon (but no date specified).
Under the previous Act, the Environmental Protection Agency assessed the environmental issues and the economic benefits and released its judgment, approving (or not) the project. Only a court could reverse the EPA decision.
Today, the EPA simply assesses the "completeness" of the application, given 15 working days to announce that the consent is complete or not. A "complete" application respectfully acknowledges the issues, and details how these matters will be mitigated, relying on expert independent consultants.
Santana has spent $6 million, and change, on at least 12 consulting firms, one of which has yet to complete its work; hence the delay.
The EPA would not destroy its credibility by comparing mining disasters in unregulated parts of the world where engineering standards do not exist, and no heed is placed on safety or the environment. Such a scare strategy would be childish and would discredit the anti-mining lobby.
The EPA no longer has the role of assessing the economic benefits and thus is not the judge of the overall case. All it can do is refer the consent back to Santana, demanding it addresses whatever the EPA decides has not been addressed or conclude that the application should be passed on to the Fast Track panel, to approve the project, or not.
The EPA process no longer involves public submissions or public hearings. The Fast-track panel weighs the environmental cost with the economic benefit.
The modelled economic benefits at today's prices are undeniable.
Annual export of gold – $500m-800m per year
NZ Govt tax and profit share per year – $200m or thereabouts
Jobs – 300 (plus)
Minimum span of the mine – 13 years (probably 15+)
Modelled profitability – billions
NZ ownership – currently 40% plus
To date, 900 people from around Central Otago have contacted Santana applying for jobs.
The objectors have one immutable claim – that the distant valley, on private land, 3.4 kms from any house, and around 6kms from the highway, will end up with a giant hole in it, possibly 2kms long and 1km wide. No doubt soil and rotten rock will be stored and later used, and no doubt natives will be planted later, but a hole is still a hole.
Some of the objectors, holding meetings and attracting media coverage, have badly damaged their credibility with silly stuff, which has encouraged the general public to dismiss the agitators as Wallys.
One angry protest organiser has claimed she will have to look at the mine while she drives along the highway. Her driving licence should be withdrawn if she gazes into the hills looking for a distant valley six kilometres away.
Another, an unwise lawyer, wrote that all the financial benefits will go to the Australians (who own 60% of the project). The tax, amounting to billions, goes to the NZ Government, and 40% of the dividends go to the NZ shareholders. Facts are facts.
But a giant hole is a giant hole so the consenting process will be crucial in coming weeks.
That hurdle to overcome is reflected in the discounted share price, now less than one half of the value of a consented project, and less than a quarter of the value of a producer should the current gold price be stable.
All of this explains the high level of concern of current and potential shareholders. For example, the Australian institutions would rather buy later at double the price than take the risk of the consent process favouring objectors. Aussies have no respect for our anti-mining lobby.
Over the next month all Santana investors will be on high alert.
The NZ Government very firmly wants the jobs, the exports and the tax. The environmental objectors will be noisy and in some cases coherent about their reservations.
Hold on to your hats!
The next month may be a test of the Government's enthusiasm for mining.
Footnote: Santana has this week updated its feasibility study. The study is worth reading.
Chris Lee yesterday
Quote from: Basil on Jul 02, 2025, 01:32 PMBell Potter valued it at A$1.30 a while back and that's modelled off their old pre-feasibility study ...........
I suspect that the next Bell Potter publicly announced valuation will be once there is an approval into the FTA process and I am picking might well start with a $4 level. Some of the base upgrades we have had announced to the ASX / NZX I am guessing would have had them valuing over $4 in their initial valuations if in the FTA process when you read through them, and taking into account regards the overhangs possible. Think the A$1.30 was discounted from about A$2.60 as the FTA was uncertain so consequently more speculative.
The Bell Direct you tube report has it as their potentially best pick to give a ASX SP 12 month uplift from early 2025 to the end of calendar year 2025.
discl: at current SP I would be pushing my portfolio % weightings rules majorly to further invest any funds, and I am not yet happy the SP has the value that would justify any sell downs to the various entity holdings I am dealing with.
Hold up $4, that's a market cap in excess of $2.8 billion. I think we need to pump the breaks a bit - unless I'm seriously misunderstanding?!
I've got a copy of Bell Potters $A1.30 valuation here. At $A54.5 cps the market cap was $A394m which is basically where its at now.
Updated pre-feasibility study talked about a net present value of the mine of $A1.5 Billion, that's 3.81 times that share price = $A2.07 based on known reserves established to date. https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/454379/attachment/446791/454379-446791.pdf
I would think if we are fortunate enough to get mine approval, the share price would move materially north as a result of that.
Keep in mind the Marth Hill mine at Waihi was originally supposed to have a 10 year mine life in 1987 based on probable reserves known at the point of its development and 38 years later its still has a 10 year mine life. They just keep finding new veins of gold to mine. Likewise I expect the ~ 13-14 year initial mine life of Santana will be considerably longer as they find new reserves, (assuming they get approval)..
Quote from: Otago K on Jul 05, 2025, 08:41 AMI suspect that the next Bell Potter publicly announced valuation will be once there is an approval into the FTA process and I am picking might well start with a $4 level. Some of the base upgrades we have had announced to the ASX / NZX I am guessing would have had them valuing over $4 in their initial valuations if in the FTA process when you read through them, and taking into account regards the overhangs possible. Think the A$1.30 was discounted from about A$2.60 as the FTA was uncertain so consequently more speculative.
The Bell Direct you tube report has it as their potentially best pick to give a ASX SP 12 month uplift from early 2025 to the end of calendar year 2025.
discl: at current SP I would be pushing my portfolio % weightings rules majorly to further invest any funds, and I am not yet happy the SP has the value that would justify any sell downs to the various entity holdings I am dealing with.
Hey O K
Can you provide the link to that YouTube video you referenced?
Thanks
Quote from: Dolcile on Jul 05, 2025, 12:48 PMHey O K
Can you provide the link to that YouTube video you referenced?
Thanks
Hi, I will try to get around to it, will be a few days until I have the time.
Also to the detail of the overhang element into valuations, for that I think there is a paper record of it, that said I am wondering if the matter may have even been pre the 3 / 1 split. May have got a little ahead of myself, perhaps good to maintain a level of caution being warranted by others.
Hot off the press: Not that reliable but simply wall street has a downgrade to A$1.17 on basis of averaging 4 analyst reports, suspect someone has downgraded, nothing to identify an actual update as at today's date.
https://www.marketscreener.com/quote/stock/SANTANA-MINERALS-LIMITED-13314774/consensus/
Note these 12 month price targets are in $A. High estimate is $A1.40, low is $A75 cents. Average $A1.17
For what its worth, (he is not a resource management consultant), I had a good chat with my environmental engineer friend today who was extensively involved with the design of the water treatment plant at the Waihi Gold mine and has spent a lot of the last year working on the updated development plans there. His thoughts are that if for some reason Santana's application under the fast track approval process is knocked back, they still retain the option to reapply with an amended application process under the standard resource management act application process. He thought any environmental concerns could probably be addressed in an updated RMA process. I think, don't follow politics to closely, that a revised streamlined RMA Act is in the works.
This is still speculative though and there are no guarantees consent will be granted under either application process so portfolio allocation needs to be carefully considered as does whether this fits with your ESG criteria.
Quote from: Basil on Jul 06, 2025, 02:26 PMhttps://www.marketscreener.com/quote/stock/SANTANA-MINERALS-LIMITED-13314774/consensus/
Note these 12 month price targets are in $A. High estimate is $A1.40, low is $A75 cents. Average $A1.17
For what its worth, (he is not a resource management consultant), I had a good chat with my environmental engineer friend today who was extensively involved with the design of the water treatment plant at the Waihi Gold mine and has spent a lot of the last year working on the updated development plans there. His thoughts are that if for some reason Santana's application under the fast track approval process is knocked back, they still retain the option to reapply with an amended application process under the standard resource management act application process. He thought any environmental concerns could probably be addressed in an updated RMA process. I think, don't follow politics to closely, that a revised streamlined RMA Act is in the works.
This is still speculative though and there are no guarantees consent will be granted under either application process so portfolio allocation needs to be carefully considered as does whether this fits with your ESG criteria.
There was a snippet on TVNZ 29/06/2025 6pm News that started with Shane Jones stating that the Otago Local Authorities were negative about his mining plans, rest of the talk was regards the removal of Regional Councils. Might fit with the rejected FTA speculation you had heard.
Quote from: Basil on Jul 06, 2025, 02:26 PMhttps://www.marketscreener.com/quote/stock/SANTANA-MINERALS-LIMITED-13314774/consensus/
Note these 12 month price targets are in $A. High estimate is $A1.40, low is $A75 cents. Average $A1.17
For what its worth, (he is not a resource management consultant), I had a good chat with my environmental engineer friend today who was extensively involved with the design of the water treatment plant at the Waihi Gold mine and has spent a lot of the last year working on the updated development plans there. His thoughts are that if for some reason Santana's application under the fast track approval process is knocked back, they still retain the option to reapply with an amended application process under the standard resource management act application process. He thought any environmental concerns could probably be addressed in an updated RMA process. I think, don't follow politics to closely, that a revised streamlined RMA Act is in the works.
This is still speculative though and there are no guarantees consent will be granted under either application process so portfolio allocation needs to be carefully considered as does whether this fits with your ESG criteria.
TVNZ 6pm news on the 29/06/2025 snippet on the question of the point of Regional Councils starts with Shane Jones making comments that the Otago (Council?) are very negative of his mining emphasis in essence. May sit with what you had heard of a FTA rejection possibility, still would have expected to have heard if it was submitted?? speculating
To be clear, I haven't heard anything negative. All I am suggesting is there is more that one route to mining consent. Disc: I hold a significant number of shares.
Quote from: Basil on Jul 07, 2025, 10:11 AMTo be clear, I haven't heard anything negative. All I am suggesting is there is more that one route to mining consent. Disc: I hold a significant number of shares.
True but by my reckoning the FTA route is quite critical to the timelines and fundamentals around the valuation, no FTA puts it into the older RMA time frames and the ORC will likely err to the conservative / no action better than a decision that might be wrong or contestably so. Standard RMA approval runs easily into the next central government term which if it is to be influenced by a Green component is by public comments of MPs on that side of the house a blanket anti mining on any terms belief, quite contrary to anything that Shane Jones might state and seemingly even more vociferous.
The TVNZ news item comment of Shane Jones about dead moths might indicate towards a Macraes issue so might not be about Santana to be fair.
I'm committed to pray and hope and whatever to see the FTA route here to be blunt, a few years might be a few years more than 2 until commissioning otherwise I'd anticipate.
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6643ff2fd1bac338ecafb567/t/6837ebfc4c061945bc3aff6b/1748495360335/SMI+250529+%28002%29.pdf For those that haven't seen this already.
More gold, nice
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/455246/attachment/447698/455246-447698.pdf
Still require consent before they can stqart to get it out of the ground. Guess they have the right Govt in place for that to happen but I fear if approved how many appeals could there be.
NZ wants high paying jobs, well here is an opportunity in gold mining that could get crushed with constent appeals going to enviromental court etc..
Another reason why some young mechancis are leaving NZ in droves when you can earn $250k in Aust in the sector.
Chris Lee has a big stake and seems to be getting some inside gossip on progress. Mentioned in his newsletter recently they'd already had 900 applicants for the ~ 300 jobs so no shortage of applicants that's for sure and who can blame them. Such a beautiful part of the country down there and so close to Queenstown area with the almost limitless recreational activities that confers. Just a "slightly" more attractive place to work that the Australian mining outback at 45 degrees lol
Quote from: Basil on Jul 17, 2025, 11:55 AMChris Lee has a big stake and seems to be getting some inside gossip on progress. Mentioned in his newsletter recently they'd already had 900 applicants for the ~ 300 jobs so no shortage of applicants that's for sure and who can blame them. Such a beautiful part of the country down there and so close to Queenstown area with the almost limitless recreational activities that confers. Just a "slightly" more attractive place to work that the Australian mining outback at 45 degrees lol
Yeah but NZ Inc is alot more protective of the enviroment especially compared to Central Otago.
Look I hope they get consent and its not dragged thru all the courts.
We as a country are sitting on a fortune on these resources but costantly held back by enviromental courts and people complaining about a snail dying.
Quote from: Greekwatchdog on Jul 17, 2025, 12:01 PMWe as a country are sitting on a fortune on these resources but costantly held back by enviromental courts and people complaining about a snail dying.
Agree 110%.
Quote from: Basil on Jul 17, 2025, 12:04 PMAgree 110%.
Just had a thought, between the French, Spanish and Greeks maybe we could send these snails over there for consumption. Another new market!!
We can export the lizards to them too. Lizard and snail soup at your favorite French café anyone ? lol
LOL yeah, A reptile Bouillabaisse. I am sure we could find a few snakes (human kind) to through in it as well
Quote from: Greekwatchdog on Jul 17, 2025, 12:01 PMYeah but NZ Inc is alot more protective of the enviroment especially compared to Central Otago.
Look I hope they get consent and its not dragged thru all the courts.
We as a country are sitting on a fortune on these resources but costantly held back by enviromental courts and people complaining about a snail dying.
Sorry Chris Lee I've decided to diversify into 4 other Aussie gold developers which are earlier stage (except for 1) to spread my risk.
Santana is still the biggest though.
Still got high hopes for Santana.
BTW I really appreciate the lead Chris ,it has been very lucrative - so far.
Go gold.
just a quick post, not looked into yet, nor questions to other matters on this thread I have a need to still address the validity of my posts. From other site a question arises from a Sunday post on ODT reporting that the assay results maybe tainted by onsite elements to tests, from recollection of my attendance at 03/03/2025 fortnightly community engagement at the Cromwell offices of SMI, the tests were portrayed as being performed by Macraes or a non detailed West Coast facility. You may find a record into an associated NZME media easier than the ODT. I'll update if discern more detail.
I'm not losing any sleep over said media article.
Quote from: Basil on Jul 21, 2025, 09:08 AMI'm not losing any sleep over said media article.
It seems to have been a question of the testing activity had been claimed to be of an industrial nature and that it was in a rural activity area. Agree it is likely some of the anti mining element attempting to raise matters that may at the least delay progress.
Also found a Council meeting report of 25 June 2025 on page 13 item follows. https://centralotago.infocouncil.biz/Open/2025/06/CO_20250625_MIN_2494.PDF
Council Meeting Minutes 25 June 2025
Page 10
RESOLUTION
Moved: Alley
Seconded: Browne
That the report be received.
CARRIED
25.12.21 FAST TRACK ACT APPLICATION
To revoke a previous resolution and delegate the approval of the key issues report for the
application from Santana Minerals under the Fast Track Approvals Act 2024, to Council staff.
It was noted that the was an expectation from the community that although the fast track process
did not allow for community comment, elected officials should have opportunity to comment,
therefore the revocation was declined.There was consideration given to the potential for the review to be appended with feedback from
community groups.
RESOLUTION
Moved: Gillespie
Seconded: Browne
That the Council
A. Receive the report.
CARRIED
Also the post 113 regards $4 valuation prediction on page 8 of this thread was an error on my part, arose from a March 2024 Blue Ocean Valuation prior to the 3 / 1 split.
Interesting discussion on the other channel initiated from a newbie 'Tinman' (it starts here (https://www.sharetrader.co.nz/showthread.php?12933-Santana-minerals-(smi)&p=1102871&highlight=#post1102871)) who seems to have detailed knowledge of this venture, and the vagaries of getting it to production, of course much to the disdain of those who reckon (hope?) it's all plain sailing to untold riches.
Interesting and robust discussion that's for sure. I won't opine on whether I think anything that's been said is actionable other than to say one poster in the other place has certainly gone out on a limb to discredit the executives of Santana in a pretty serious way.
I think the Australian Gold mining analysts are FAR more experienced and far better placed to put a value on this company than myself or anyone else on here and of course they're valuing it with the caveat and assumption that consent is granted and mining takes place so you need to discount their average valuation by whatever amount you think is appropriate to take into account the consenting risk.
I note the average valuation of 4 Australian analysts covering Santana is A$1.235 https://www.marketscreener.com/quote/stock/SANTANA-MINERALS-LIMITED-13314774/consensus/
In terms of consenting risk and whether this gets going after possible appeals, I note this is a binary outcome situation and on a straight 50/50 assessment of the chances of successfully undertaking mining, if you discount the above valuation average by 50%, it becomes A61.75 cents = approx 67 cents Kiwi.
Maybe the shares are about fairly priced at this level ?
Quote from: Buzz on Jul 26, 2025, 07:48 PMInteresting discussion on the other channel initiated from a newbie 'Tinman' (it starts here (https://www.sharetrader.co.nz/showthread.php?12933-Santana-minerals-(smi)&p=1102871&highlight=#post1102871)) who seems to have detailed knowledge of this venture, and the vagaries of getting it to production, of course much to the disdain of those who reckon (hope?) it's all plain sailing to untold riches.
Very astute postings by Tinman. Investors beware IMO. Very high risk.
~$50m in cash on hand at the end of June and that's after investing ~ $5m in the previous quarter which was a very active period with multiple consultants paid for work done to advance the FTA and drilling to firm up the inferred resource.
They have enough cash for at least 12 further quarters, probably 4 years if they get bogged down in appeals and temporarily stop exploration work), in my opinion so its not the end of the world, (although one on the other channel seems to think it is) if they do not meet the timeline's already indicated, (first gold first quarter 2027).
Investment in Santana is clearly a bet on whether they get consent, taking a position on whether they can mine effectively at around the cost prices indicated in the updated PFS, how much they can expand the current estimated reserves through further exploration and the future gold price, among other things.
One new poster on the other channel seems to think he has a lot of answers. I'm not an experienced gold mining investor by any stretch of the imagination so prefer in this instance to rely on the professional analysts in Australia who value gold mining operations on a very regular basis and as noted above, discounting the average of 4 valuations by about 50% for consent risk seems about right to me and the market in my opinion is pricing Santana efficiently for all the known and perceived risks at this point.
I acknowledge the high risk and this is not for everyone but almost all portfolio theory I have ever read suggests investing 5-10% of your net worth into alternative asset classes. Whether that's precious metal's, miners, collectables, art, classic cars, crypto or whatever other asset class you can think of that will give you a return of one form or another. (Might not necessarily be a return in monetary terms either, for example some people get a heck of a lot of pleasure from investing in a race horse or a boat) Choose whatever alternative assets float your boat.
https://www.fool.com/research/high-net-worth-alternative-investments/?msockid=35c2492e62e8616707d15a0f637860ec
When I started investing, I made the principled decision not to invest in tobacco, gambling or mining companies. Makes me sleep easy at night. No regrets.
GLH's.
Quote from: Basil on Jul 28, 2025, 11:33 AM~$50m in cash on hand at the end of June and that's after investing ~ $5m in the previous quarter which was a very active period with multiple consultants paid for work done to advance the FTA and drilling to firm up the inferred resource.
They announced recently they are buying Ardgour Station, which I think was $18m of cash (??) - so that will go through in the next months. Will make a dent in their coffers.
Quote from: Left Field on Jul 28, 2025, 12:05 PMWhen I started investing, I made the principled decision not to invest in tobacco, gambling or mining companies. Makes me sleep easy at night. No regrets.
Its cool that you didn't exclude weapons manufacturers. We need mining companies, how for example would you be driving your car without them ? I like my Gold watch, I couldn't have one without gold mining companies.
Quote from: Sideshow Bob on Jul 28, 2025, 12:19 PMThey announced recently they are buying Ardgour Station, which I think was $18m of cash (??) - so that will go through in the next months. Will make a dent in their coffers.
Fair point, although possibly worth noting its a conditional offer until December 2025 with a $2m non-refundable deposit.
Ha Ha....Cheap shot Basil......FYI I don't invest in weapons companies .....for the same reasons as above.
I think the chance is better than 50/50, given the pro mining stance of the current govt, and I think the delay means they're making sure they have all their ducks in a row before submission, which is healthy.
A friend who doesn't post shared this thought with me.
Quote from: Basil on Jul 28, 2025, 10:07 AMInteresting and robust discussion that's for sure. I won't opine on whether I think anything that's been said is actionable other than to say one poster in the other place has certainly gone out on a limb to discredit the executives of Santana in a pretty serious way.
I think the Australian Gold mining analysts are FAR more experienced and far better placed to put a value on this company than myself or anyone else on here and of course they're valuing it with the caveat and assumption that consent is granted and mining takes place so you need to discount their average valuation by whatever amount you think is appropriate to take into account the consenting risk.
I note the average valuation of 4 Australian analysts covering Santana is A$1.235 https://www.marketscreener.com/quote/stock/SANTANA-MINERALS-LIMITED-13314774/consensus/
In terms of consenting risk and whether this gets going after possible appeals, I note this is a binary outcome situation and on a straight 50/50 assessment of the chances of successfully undertaking mining, if you discount the above valuation average by 50%, it becomes A61.75 cents = approx 67 cents Kiwi.
Maybe the shares are about fairly priced at this level ?
bit random, too some extent about my money psychology, and consequently some investment strategy contemplation, but 12 months on from investment holding at a paper gain of 40% on my holdings.
Digression to the other site poster, for myself I have a clear knowledge of from my personal situation how people may choose to distort and miss portray elements of validity, can say there is some clear statements he makes that are bullshit, don't personally need to consider anything I see as valid in his statements to reconcile with where I am with investing in Santana.
From here if it all goes rosy towards a gold pouring early calendar year 2027 it will be sub optimal for me to be placing some sell orders on SMI, but as we must appreciate there isn't anything certain in where the future Mr Market will see the valuations of traded shares. At a 40% plus 12 month uplift from week one of NZX trades when I bought in to what I always felt was an overweight SMI position I am more than happy to de-risk my holdings and particularly for what is in effect trust entity holders reduce the cash funds invested as a portfolio percentage, and consequently a lowering of the per share average, the extent of which may be somewhat determined by where the SP of SMI goes over the next month.
Digressing some what, in effect at least for one Trust Entity holder, arising from a late April 2025 KPG overweight level of buy activity, the current paper profit will warrant in the context of some beneficiary grumbles, a similar lowering of the weighted cash funds invested on a per share basis by moving to a more normalised portfolio percentage being held going forward.
I do have a few concerns which is why I have reduced my holding.
1.The facts are that they have repeatedly delayed making their FTA, since April, to end of June and in their latest PFS they said it was due mid July. Why the repeated delay's ?
They have said its because they were waiting for one last report but now we're at the end of the month that excuse doesn't really seem to hold water anymore. As a friend opined to me last week, (who is a consultant on the Waihi mine), maybe its not that the environmental report is late that's holding up the application, perhaps there's some things in there the company doesn't like ?
2. The use of a 6.5% discount rate in their latest PFS, down from 8% because the mine has been "de risked" lacks credibility. Even the original 8% discount rate to value future cash flows is quite low. Most analysts use a companies WACC and is usually 11% or thereabouts. The difference between valuing a stream of cash flows over 13 years at 6.5% or 11%, the latter gives a NPV approx 20% lower. I think they are overstating the NPV of their estimated resource by ~ 20% for this factor alone
3. In recent days, due to work pressure earlier this month I have finally had the time to invest in comparing their initial PFS with the latest one in some detail. The NPV has gone up mostly because of the increase in the price of gold and the use of the very "creative" discount rate in (2) above. Mine economics have actually deteriorated at a cost level with the all in cost jumping by ~ $430 an ounce. The size of the estimated resource has only increased marginally. I think they need to drill a lot more holes to increase the size of probable reserves.
4. Gold itself has had a huge run and is now breaking down through key technical supports. For me this factor is HUGE as a bet on this company is a big bet on the future direction of the gold price.
Finally, mine approval is a binary outcome process and with that are serious risks. Appeals including a possible judicial review could take this process out over the deadline of the election next year, Tinman has made that point and some others, quite well.
DYOR I am not, by any stretch of the imagination, experienced at investing in gold mines. In my book, any company needs to build a track record of credibility of doing what they say they will do. FTA has been delayed several times and by many months...that's made me increasingly uncomfortable as the months have ticked by.
Disc: Still holding a very small stake.
Thanks for sharing Beagle. Wise move IMO.
Anyone remember Heritage Gold years ago, I lost money on that one too.
Quote from: seaweed on Jul 31, 2025, 09:59 PMAnyone remember Heritage Gold years ago, I lost money on that one too.
Heritage kind of lives on (in an undead / zombie kind of way) as New Talisman, and it still isn't mining any gold.
For the record I've also sold out. I hadn't noticed the change in discount rate Basil, but I had uneasiness even around the previous 8%.
My change of sentiment was more to do with my own risk tolerance, together with the lack of transparency around the status of the fast track submission and my view that there is a very low margin of safety at the current valuation.
Nobody ever went broke taking a profit.
I sold half.
Mining stocks are very high risk/reward
Im thinking now it's good to have 10 of those but it needs a lot of research.
Lion selection does it for you I guess.
Ticker Lsx.
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/456150/attachment/448741/456150-448741.pdf
Haven't got time to check this properly but on a very brief glance there doesn't appear to be any new info on when the FTA will be made ?
I think shareholders are due an update and lack of transparency around this FTA process is concerning.
Yes agreed Basil, this was a post on the other channel by Tinman - very telling:
QuoteFrom their ASX releases on Fast Track submission timing:
18 Nov 2024
Santana expects to be in a position to make its submission for approvals in mid-late February 2025.
23 Jan 2025
... the submission timeline for the application has been adjusted to accommodate these updates. Applications are able to be lodged in the first quarter in 2025.
7 Apr 2025
... we are now working towards completing our submission as soon as possible but no later than 30 June 2025.
13 June 2025
... the Company will not be in a position to submit its FTAA Application by 30 June 2025 as previously announced.... in the meantime, continues to prioritise work to ensure submission of the FTAA Application at the earliest opportunity.
24 July 2025
Lodgement is now imminent and remains a top priority.
Quote from: Dolcile on Aug 04, 2025, 11:58 AM13 June 2025
... the Company will not be in a position to submit its FTAA Application by 30 June 2025 as previously announced.... in the meantime, continues to prioritise work to ensure submission of the FTAA Application at the earliest opportunity.
Agreed. Missed one. In the updated PFS recently released they had a timeline of mid July for lodging FTA.
P.S. 18 Nov 2024
QuoteSantana expects to be in a position to make its submission for approvals in mid-late February 2025.
They're now nearly six months behind !
I think the insiders know this will get up.
I think anyone would be in Lala land thinking that would be able to get a gold mine fully consented and up into development in NZ these days strictly within the indicated timelines for consenting and permits. Always going to be alot of bumps along the way.
As I've said before, the resource and potential is not in question - the risk is all around resource consents.
Latest ASX disclosure was 4th August, for an Aussy mining forum presentation, https://www.nzx.com/announcements/456150
gut tells me the pour date is now back a quarter into 2027 from where I last saw it. Don't see any indications of insiders selling, nor at current levels buying not that they would be likely to with the current investment and entitlements I would speculate. Tend to agree it would be reassuring if what might appear negative aspects were to be front foot disclosed as do the positives.
Quote from: Otago K on Aug 05, 2025, 05:49 AMLatest ASX disclosure was 4th August, for an Aussy mining forum presentation, https://www.nzx.com/announcements/456150
gut tells me the pour date is now back a quarter into 2027 from where I last saw it. Don't see any indications of insiders selling, nor at current levels buying not that they would be likely to with the current investment and entitlements I would speculate. Tend to agree it would be reassuring if what might appear negative aspects were to be front foot disclosed as do the positives.
It was up 2.5c (4.3%) yesterday in Oz. On the back of this or just normal movement??
Trading hope. Good luck holders
NZ RegCo advises that, at the request of the Santana Minerals Limited ("SMI"), it has placed a trading halt on SMI ordinary shares. The trading halt was placed prior to market open today, Thursday, 7 August 2025.
The trading halt has been put in place pending an announcement by SMI.
ex ASX, Only for a placement
https://cdn-api.markitdigital.com/apiman-gateway/ASX/asx-research/1.0/file/2924-02976028-6A1277293&v=4a466cc3f899e00730cfbfcd5ab8940c41f474b6
Getting further and further behind with multiple missed deadlines of undertakings of when FTA would be made and now a placement to keep them in funds for longer. I'm not impressed. No doubt the placement will be to parties friendly to the directors... ::)
Agreed, I'm glad to be on the sidelines. I was not expecting more dilution pre FID.
Article in the AFR
Gold miner Santana Minerals in $61m equity raising
Sarah Thompson, Kanika Sood and Emma Rapaport
Aug 7, 2025 – 11.45am
Santana Minerals, a gold miner capitalised at $455 million on the ASX, was out pitching investors for fresh cash days after its management preached its prospects at the Diggers & Dealers conference
in Kalgoorlie.
Gold miners are making the most of their perky share prices in launching cash calls.
Street Talk understands Santana is seeking to raise $58 million in an institutional placement priced at 58¢ a share, or a 7.9 per cent discount to the last traded price.
It equates to 14 per cent of the company's issued capital. Santana also plans to run a $3 million share purchase plan for retail shareholders.
Lead manager and bookrunner Canaccord Genuity was calling for bids by 5pm Thursday for Asia Pacific investors to return the stock to trading on Monday.
Santana is developing the Bendigo-Ophir gold project in New Zealand's Central Otago Goldfields, and has described its discovery as the "most significant" in the country in 40 years. Construction is expected to begin in early 2026, with base-case modelling offered to investors claiming a $780 million net present value and a 2.6-year payback timeline.
It had $47.5 million cash at June 30, and shares have risen more than 40 per cent over the past 12 months.
Fund managers were told proceeds from Thursday's raising would accelerate preparations needed for the final investment decision at the Bendigo-Ophir project; help kick off early infrastructure civil works and order long-lead items; and expand exploration to nearby targets. Also under consideration are M&A opportunities.
"The company is currently in negotiations to acquire freehold title to parcels of land neighbouring and underlying its Bendigo-Ophir Gold Project, already the subject of access arrangements. Any formal agreements will be subject to various conditions precedent, including but not limited to NZ Overseas Investment Office approval where required," the term sheet noted.
The price of gold has jumped more than 40 per cent over the past year to $5200 per ounce, leaving many ASX-listed gold miners and hopefuls with spectacular share price gains.
A few thoughts and concerns.
This seems like a very strange point to be raising capital. Why wouldn't you just get on with the FTA, de-risk the project, get consent and then raise capital ? Just thinking out loud here. The cynic in me thinks they've gone into full concealment mode. They're not explaining the repeated delay's in FTA process so as I suggested recently maybe there's something in those environmental reports that the company doesn't like ? Maybe that's the reason they're looking to buy up more land ? The steady increase in the share price in recent days looked a bit "orchestrated" to me, parties friendly to the directors artificially pumping up the price prior to the capital raise ? The discount on offer here is very modest and in fact it wasn't long ago at all the shares were trading at 58 cents Australian. If the capital raise proceeds at the price indicated, which will be about 64 cents Kiwi, I am strongly disinclined to give them any more money. The lack of transparency here around the FTA is really off-putting. To ask for more capital while contemporaneously giving no transparency about the huge delay's in the FTA....Crickey, they've got a bloody nerve...
All sounds good, however they still need Resourse Consent, and if approved you can just imagine the uproar from these Greenies on the left complaining about a few miss placed animals not to mention complaining locals...
Enviromental courts could get busy..
Quote from: Basil on Aug 07, 2025, 04:10 PM.....A few thoughts and concerns.
This seems like a very strange point to be raising capital. Why wouldn't you just get on with the FTA, de-risk the project, get consent and then raise capital ? Just thinking out loud here. The cynic in me thinks they've gone into full concealment mode. They're not explaining the repeated delay's in FTA process so as I suggested recently maybe there's something in those environmental reports that the company doesn't like ? Maybe that's the reason they're looking to buy up more land ? The steady increase in the share price in recent days looked a bit "orchestrated" to me, parties friendly to the directors artificially pumping up the price prior to the capital raise ? The discount on offer here is very modest and in fact it wasn't long ago at all the shares were trading at 58 cents Australian. If the capital raise proceeds at the price indicated, which will be about 64 cents Kiwi, I am strongly disinclined to give them any more money. The lack of transparency here around the FTA is really off-putting. To ask for more capital while contemporaneously giving no transparency about the huge delay's in the FTA....Crickey, they've got a bloody nerve...
Another classic 360 degree turn by you Basil. How can you be surprised???.....Many posters warned you of the risks..... but you knew better.... LOL reading back on this forum! Classic stuff.
Quote from: Left Field on Aug 07, 2025, 04:46 PMAnother classic 360 degree turn by you Basil. How can you be surprised???.....Many posters warned you of the risks..... but you knew better.... LOL reading back on this forum! Classic stuff.
I have never claimed to be experienced in investing in junior mining stocks. I actually thought they would lodge the FTA by late June given the delay's previous to that. I could accept some wiggle room around that, so thought in the updated PFS mid July was passably okay. When they missed that deadline it was a case for me of three strikes and you're basically out. Nobody ever went broke taking a profit. My average cost was in the low 50's and average sale price in the mid 60's. Its been an interesting experience and I still have a very small hobby sized stake.
Quote from: Basil on Aug 07, 2025, 04:10 PMArticle in the AFR
Gold miner Santana Minerals in $61m equity raising......
A few thoughts and concerns.
This seems like a very strange point to be raising capital. Why wouldn't you just get on with the FTA, de-risk the project, get consent and then raise capital ? Just thinking out loud here. The cynic in me thinks they've gone into full concealment mode. They're not explaining the repeated delay's in FTA process so as I suggested recently maybe there's something in those environmental reports that the company doesn't like ? Maybe that's the reason they're looking to buy up more land ? The steady increase in the share price in recent days looked a bit "orchestrated" to me, parties friendly to the directors artificially pumping up the price prior to the capital raise ? The discount on offer here is very modest and in fact it wasn't long ago at all the shares were trading at 58 cents Australian. If the capital raise proceeds at the price indicated, which will be about 64 cents Kiwi, I am strongly disinclined to give them any more money. The lack of transparency here around the FTA is really off-putting. To ask for more capital while contemporaneously giving no transparency about the huge delay's in the FTA....Crickey, they've got a bloody nerve...
Think the land being purchased from Ardgour maybe about security of legal freehold title over the location of some infrastructure build and logistics of access surety 24 / 7, with the possible conflicts with farming operation. Hope I am correct that it might see a lower royalty sum to be paid to the Ardgour Station owners?? hopefully coherent .
Paying 5%, a cool $A3m underwriting and management fees to raise $A60m Nice work for the underwriters !
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/456510/attachment/449196/456510-449196.pdf
Share purchase plan of A$3m to existing shareholders to ostensibly cover the placement costs. Can apply for up to $A30,000 of shares at A58 cents for those that are keen.
Money is flowing.
Gold is hot.
Gee those underwriters do alright.
Should be unlocked from yesterdays edition, not yet read through and probably doesn't explain what the potentially one report outstanding that goes to the non submission under the FTA regime.
https://www.odt.co.nz/regions/central-otago/blasting-massive-hole-conservation-area-not-done-thing
Potentially I may encounter some folk at an imminent funeral who have personal connections into the Santana staffing, might see if I can glean a sense of the reality / word on the street, should they be aware.
Was having a nosy at NZ stocks tradable through CMC as CFD's and noticed Santana had been added recently.
Might add to volumes traded as they will have to hedge there book.
I can't see anything in today's presentation regarding the status of the Fast Track Approvals Submission.
Glad I'm out.
They just keep pushing out the timelines and concealing the reasons for FTA delays.
Locals not happy with Santana. Surprise. Surprise.
https://www.odt.co.nz/regions/central-otago/santana-'completely-failed'-share-mine-info
Quote from: Left Field on Aug 27, 2025, 08:09 AMLocals not happy with Santana. Surprise. Surprise.
https://www.odt.co.nz/regions/central-otago/santana-'completely-failed'-share-mine-info
Given the community, the response was always going to be fraught. With the make up of their Board, it's no surprise that Santana hasn't done well with managing the narrative. That's now biting them on the bum.
Quote from: Hectorplains on Aug 27, 2025, 10:25 AMGiven the community, the response was always going to be fraught. With the make up of their Board, it's no surprise that Santana hasn't done well with managing the narrative. That's now biting them on the bum.
The locals response to the proposed Tarras International airport provides an indication of the depth of feeling that can be aroused.
Here's another report https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/business/571161/otago-locals-range-from-curious-to-staunchly-opposed-on-giant-gold-mine
Their latest presentation indicates application for mine license by the end of Sept...I presume this is FTA. It also has images of the tailings dams which is something new. First gold by midway through Q2 2027. Hmmm Disc: VERY small hobby sized position and not participating in the capital raise. Really arrogant, asking for more capital while concealing the reasons for FTA delay's, in my opinion.
Underground mine the only option imo,can backfill the spoil etc later..
A friend who spends alot of time in small goldies est that
re 218 million tonnes of rock spoil( mostly overburden) would need to removed to recover 1,093,494 Oz of gold, all what ; being within 4 km from the top of the lake.?
Partly a reminder for those who see benefits to apply into the offer it's the last day today, you will need to meet the verification on payment requirements through NZ banking system and all. It is available at quite a lot lower than the Mr Market, SP levels over last 3 days ever higher so must be heavy scaled back. There maybe some speculation of justification to FTA delays, but for me they are still baked in and they might well influence the valuation projections I have.
Discl currently an active seller down, might even get to a Nil Funds Invested sleep easy situation if momentum builds today. Is this current SP merely frothy or a bubble even based on the current Gold spot price???
Quote from: Otago K on Sep 03, 2025, 10:13 AMPartly a reminder for those who see benefits to apply into the offer it's the last day today, you will need to meet the verification on payment requirements through NZ banking system and all. It is available at quite a lot lower than the Mr Market, SP levels over last 3 days ever higher so must be heavy scaled back. There maybe some speculation of justification to FTA delays, but for me they are still baked in and they might well influence the valuation projections I have.
Discl currently an active seller down, might even get to a Nil Funds Invested sleep easy situation if momentum builds today. Is this current SP merely frothy or a bubble even based on the current Gold spot price???
Do you believe this will be an underground mine at best case?
Interesting no time scale or cost estimates to this notice.
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/458169/attachment/451360/458169-451360.pdf
Quote from: Clearasmud on Sep 03, 2025, 06:44 PMDo you believe this will be an underground mine at best case?
Think that is all premised about what might be palatable to the public court of opinion, certainly not what I perceive the Santana team would consider, would be sub optimal on the dollars benefit to investors and government revenues, and ultimately the total gold to be extracted I suspect.
I do see that the proposed mine design will not be a great detraction to what is to be seen. Perhaps at a distance from very limited vantage points it will be a visual that some may choose to consider not what they want to see, not pristine to desired image.
In my reality of adjoining properties and it was from 35 to 25 years in the past, on the ground, might have been very likely barren to the eye, and would move with the scurrying rabbits as they were disturbed, was like a flock of birds or fish as they move as one to the eye. Compared to a mine ultimately well remediated and managed wouldn't bother me at all. If there is anything there of environmental value it survived or recovered post rabbits scourge, why would a mine be a bother??
If I retain what I feel as a rational mindset no not underground until deeper and seams are clearly thinner and defined, but what I think matters little.
Purely posted for disseminating information to hand via a Simply Wall St watch listing advice on Friday 5th NZ time.
Price target increased by 11% to AU$1.30
Up from AU$1.17, the current price target is an average from 4 analysts.
• New target price is 93% above last closing price of AU$0.68.
• Stock is up 14% over the past year.
I can not see any updated equity research on Sanatana website to Identify who the likely analyst may be.
Discl: I still see merit or value in this entity but agree there are elements of concern to consider, and are in the process of sell downs, currently hold Trust entity holdings at a funding cost average of under 10c NZ and for other entities the figure stands around 26c, with a plan to get these to nil, another market lift anywhere near the magnitude of the past week will achieve this goal and see the remnant holdings destined for the bottom drawer, to await what will be will be, with no real skin in the game. On reflection I was amiss to miss out on an arbitrage gain by partaking in the offering and to have sold a commensurate dollar sum of existing holding from July 2024 BUYs.
We are in a gold bull market mate so this is the time to hold long,strong and hope for intergenerational wealth.
I have reduced by half and am free carried.
Most of my NZ stocks have been transferred to Australian gold developers and explorers.
Stuff the nz market although there are a few good ones.
For anyone interested few latest developments
TV3 News think Sunday 21 09 2025 6pm exert
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GtEjlUj2Pk0
Ex Platform site item by Michael Laws ( I think also the ORC chair, incidentally ) interview of CEO Damian Spring
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nlxw-I_V8x0
ex Santana website some FTA submission materials including July 2025 visualisations as referenced in the Laws You Tube above https://www.santanaminerals.com/ftasubmissionreports
Latest nzx disclosure to extended underground mine projection I might anticipate.
https://www.nzx.com/announcements/459217
No recent valuation updates on the Santana site but Simply Wall Street has had a couple of analyst's updated to higher targets over the last 4 weeks. Not suggesting anything other than own research and assessing what it means for your own circumstances to be clear, Discl: I am currently carrying SMI at a nil own $ invested basis having sold down around 60% of initial shareholdings across my portfolios.
Quote from: Otago K on Sep 23, 2025, 04:21 AMFor anyone interested few latest developments
TV3 News think Sunday 21 09 2025 6pm exert
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GtEjlUj2Pk0
Ex Platform site item by Michael Laws ( I think also the ORC chair, incidentally ) interview of CEO Damian Spring
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nlxw-I_V8x0
ex Santana website some FTA submission materials including July 2025 visualisations as referenced in the Laws You Tube above https://www.santanaminerals.com/ftasubmissionreports
Latest nzx disclosure to extended underground mine projection I might anticipate.
https://www.nzx.com/announcements/459217
No recent valuation updates on the site but Simply Wall Street has had a couple over the last 4 weeks updated to higher targets. Not suggesting anything other than own research and assessing what it means for your own circumstances to be clear, Discl: I am currently carrying SMI at a nil own $ invested basis having sold down around 60% of initial shareholdings across my portfolios.
I did the same mate but used the proceeds to buy 4 other goldies.
Again latest updates to hand in addition to the nzx website Annual Report announcement, including Chairman Peter Cook updated comments to FTA submission
23 September Blue Oceans Equity Analysts report on the Santana website
https://www.santanaminerals.com/equity-research
Latest RNZ reporting on the Imminence of FTA filing
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/574609/santana-minerals-close-to-lodging-application-for-4-point-4-billion-central-otago-gold-mine
I do notice a discontinuation post July 2025 of their website monthly newsletters.
IMHO There remains the question of delays or disruption with the minority Tarras action group views.
DYOR as always, for me there remains a question of amending a pending SELL at slightly above the current SP I had placed in contemplation, that FTA delays or issues that arise around it might see a SP drop, at which time I might determine a BUY back in of the value of the trade, bit of a dollar each way for 45% of one portfolio holding.
Obviously no mining licence means huge uncertainty.
We await, cautiously optimistic.
It helps to have 4 or 5 other positions.
Latest SMI disclosure, at bottom of page 1 detailing of post September quarter activity there is reference to FTA having been submitted I take it.
https://www.nzx.com/announcements/461781
It appears so, Chris Lee has sent out a notification saying Santana have lodged their Fast Track Application. Can't find any mention in media of it yet
Quote from: teabag on Oct 31, 2025, 06:24 PMIt appears so, Chris Lee has sent out a notification saying Santana have lodged their Fast Track Application. Can't find any mention in media of it yet
It was mentioned in their quarter report released today.
"Lodgement of the Project's consent application under the new Fast-track Approvals Act commenced following
the collation of all required technical works and studies, and payment of the application fee, marking a major
milestone toward development and commercialisation."
https://www.chrislee.co.nz/taking-stock
Quote from: lorraina on Nov 06, 2025, 11:30 AMhttps://www.chrislee.co.nz/taking-stock
Just wondering, whether the 2% of holdings is impacting on his views? Jeez - 2% - this is something like NZ$14m ... a lot of money in a goldmine not even fully licenced and certainly not producing.
I normally like his posts (no matter whether I agree with the particular issue), but this feels a bit conflicted.
Latest ASX notice trading halt missed NZX Friday trading hours, should be disclosed Monday ASX trading hours.
https://app.sharelinktechnologies.com/announcement/asx/8b79c2ea54e64b3b64e66ec3486bf8bb
Other recent developments a rather positive Chairman's report in the AGM reporting
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/462967/attachment/457093/462967-457093.pdf
Another extended extent of the future underground probable margins on the main Rise And Shine resource
https://api.nzx.com/public/announcement/462829/attachment/456947/462829-456947.pdf
Sure it will be easy enough to find that the Greens have adviced they will reverse anything issued under the Fats Track Act for various categories including the Bendigo Ophir Project of Santana when they are elected.
I'll probably edit tidy up in the weekend. Discl Holder.
Gold continues to rise making Santana a great investment opportunity.
This article is another perspective we don't see on the investment thread. Momentum is with the miners for now, but the coming election could have a significant effect on SMI not everyone is pro mining and the greenies have been surprisingly quiet so far, from what I read.
https://www.stuff.co.nz/nz-news/360927629/ian-taylor-dear-chris-bishop-not-kind-future-we-should-fast-track
Anyone watching/investing Manuka minerals? I haven't as I don't agree with mining the ocean floor, but its had quite the debut on the nzx.
Quote from: Apollo on Jan 22, 2026, 08:22 AMGold continues to rise making Santana a great investment opportunity.
...
Goldprice is basically a measure of global uncertainty. At the moment its high, and goldprice is high. As soon as the bullets really start flying and the fighting teams arrange with whom and against whom to fight, economic risks will drop again and gold price will follow. Just have a look at goldprice before and during WW2.
So - I guess if you invest now with gold already at its highest level into goldmining you are basically saying that you believe gold price will rise for years to come. And sure, its possible, but is it really an investment opportunity or just another high risk gamble?
As soon as Trump, Putin, Xi and some of their followers bite the dust and the US$ effectively lost its currency leadership, things will settle again and notebanks will find better things to store reserves ....
Quote from: BlackPeter on Jan 22, 2026, 09:33 AMGoldprice is basically a measure of global uncertainty. At the moment its high, and goldprice is high. As soon as the bullets really start flying and the fighting teams arrange with whom and against whom to fight, economic risks will drop again and gold price will follow. Just have a look at goldprice before and during WW2.
So - I guess if you invest now with gold already at its highest level into goldmining you are basically saying that you believe gold price will rise for years to come. And sure, its possible, but is it really an investment opportunity or just another high risk gamble?
As soon as Trump, Putin, Xi and some of their followers bite the dust and the US$ effectively lost its currency leadership, things will settle again and notebanks will find better things to store reserves ....
SMI is a speculation on the price of gold and I have no idea what the future holds but as gold rises in price companies that produce gold (or will in the future) become better investments as they sell their production at higher prices.
Wouldn't everything tend to be at or near its highest price in dollars terms in an inflationary world?
Didn't gold become a Teir 1 reserve asset in May 2025. If I understand what this means correctly banks can now hold gold as a reserve at 100% of its value rather than 50% making it a more attractive reserve asset to hold for banks.
https://www.usfunds.com/resource/basel-iii-makes-it-official-gold-is-money-again/
Will the USD retain reserve currency status or will the BRICS "unit" become relevant if it does it requires their central banks to have 40% gold backing their currencies which would be a return to a gold standard.
How many billions of dollars is the Federal Reserve printing monthly currently? Will this affect the price of gold and everything else in dollar terms. Is US and Japanese govt debt sustainable and if so does it need inflation to help manage the debt?
Will interest rates rise significantly making holding gold less attractive?
Gold prices can be very volatile so this could all change tomorrow so apologies for suggesting SMI is a great investment opportunity. Surprising the greenies have not already put the kibosh on this project.
If you wanted to point out a more disturbing gold chart I think 1979-1980 the price of gold fell by 50% over a long time and did not regain those 1979 highs until around about when they gave up on fiat currencies and printed during the GFC 2008-2009. Who has over 20 years to wait for a price recovery?
Silver is where the serious money has been made in the last 12 months, it's tripled.
Quote from: Apollo on Jan 22, 2026, 02:13 PMSMI is a speculation on the price of gold and I have no idea what the future holds but as gold rises in price companies that produce gold (or will in the future) become better investments as they sell their production at higher prices.
I'd like to add a caveat to that statement. Any mining stock is speculation on both the commodity price and also the performance and efficiency of the mine itself. Even more so with a miner like SMI who have not yet even begun construction of the mine.
Quote from: BlackPeter on Jan 22, 2026, 09:33 AMGoldprice is basically a measure of global uncertainty. At the moment its high, and goldprice is high. As soon as the bullets really start flying and the fighting teams arrange with whom and against whom to fight, economic risks will drop again and gold price will follow. Just have a look at goldprice before and during WW2.
So - I guess if you invest now with gold already at its highest level into goldmining you are basically saying that you believe gold price will rise for years to come. And sure, its possible, but is it really an investment opportunity or just another high risk gamble?
As soon as Trump, Putin, Xi and some of their followers bite the dust and the US$ effectively lost its currency leadership, things will settle again and notebanks will find better things to store reserves ....
IMO - Gold is also where people who think Fiat money is done put there money. the more Fiat money printed the more it devalues - need more fiat money to buy things. People are buying assets to hedge.
We are in a commodity boom - first gold, then silver - copper moving, nickel is starting to move, lithium is back up, uranium - oil like to move soon as well.
Silver has gone up nicely partly due to "you can buy more of it than gold" and usage for solar panels has increased from 5% to 30% in the last 5 years.
Quote from: Raven on Jan 22, 2026, 03:13 PMI'd like to add a caveat to that statement. Any mining stock is speculation on both the commodity price and also the performance and efficiency of the mine itself. Even more so with a miner like SMI who have not yet even begun construction of the mine.
Ignore if you are aware of this but its valuable to be aware of the Lassonde curve when investing in mining companies.
The Lassonde Curve, named after mining investor Pierre Lassonde, is a graph showing a mining project's value journey from discovery (high risk, high excitement) through development (trough of disillusionment/funding), to profitable production (high value), and eventual decline, helping investors understand risks and timing at each stage of a mine's lifecycle. It highlights how early exploration sparks huge interest, but most projects fail, leading to investor apathy, while successful ones eventually reach production value.
Stages of the Lassonde Curve
Concept/Exploration (Discovery Peak): High risk, high reward; speculative excitement, early drilling, land acquisition.
Development/Feasibility (Trough): Value dips as costs rise, projects face technical/permitting hurdles, investors lose interest.
Production (Production Peak): Successful projects generate revenue, confirming resource value and leading to significant value creation.
Decline: Resources deplete, operations wind down, value decreases.
Why it's important
Risk Management:
Helps investors assess risk/reward at different stages.
Investment Timing: Guides entry/exit points for junior mining stocks.
Strategic Tool: Shows how companies navigate from speculative exploration to generating real returns.
Following is some transcript Ex ODT article today's print edition, Not sounding great regards SMI expectations that what had initially been submitted should shorten the Standard 90 days review not justify extending to 140 days.
"AN Australian mining company's bid to fast-track its Central Otago gold mine has faltered at the first hurdle after government agencies raised significant environmental concerns and lambasted it for poor planning. The agencies said Santana Minerals' bid for a decision to be made in 30 days was unrealistic, the Otago Regional Council (ORC) calling for a 140-day decision-making period."
Sorry too busy in real life to search out justification / basis to what follows, please do your own research,
Quote from: Apollo on Jan 22, 2026, 08:22 AMpost 195..
... Momentum is with the miners for now, but the coming election could have a significant effect on SMI not everyone is pro mining and the greenies have been surprisingly quiet so far, from what I read.....
Post 198
Quote from: Apollo on Jan 22, 2026, 02:13 PMpost 198
........ Surprising the greenies have not already put the kibosh on this project......
Actually I'm fairly certain Green Party MPs currently in the house via a televised press conference on parliament grounds Nov / Dec 2025 have made a statement of intent to overturn certain FTA approved applications that include all the mining ones post next election
Quote from: Raven on Jan 22, 2026, 03:13 PM...... and also the performance and efficiency of the mine itself. Even more so with a miner like SMI who have not yet even begun construction of the mine.....
While you will not know what it is you don't know, some indications are that the pre-strip project will actually be high probability to be relatively simple and quick with the technical data they have already. Anecdotally an ex Otago mine school graduate comments at a BBQ I was attending. Also if some delays should occur when the smelter plant is ready to go live there is a stack of alluvial tailing from past old timers that had included some richness in their finds to consider for re-processing.
More info' on recent opposition by various Otago institutions being faced by SML
https://cruxnz.substack.com/p/bendigo-mine-fast-track-application
the ORC memo is good at listing at what it sees are the big issues. https://www.fasttrack.govt.nz/__data/assets/pdf_file/0017/19115/Memorandum-for-Otago-Regional-Council-BOGP-Convener-Conference-FTAA-2507-1089_signed-16-Jan-2026.pdf see paras 13-38. and esp. from 21. ORC says there is "a relatively large number of principal issues in contention".
the big issues from its perspective fall under the headings of: "Engineering and natural hazards", "Water modelling (quality and quantity) and groundwater effects", "Water quality and aquatic ecology", and to a lesser extent "Wetlands" & "Terrestrial ecology" seem like lesser issues. Helpfully, ORC says it "...expects that potential air quality effects are likely to be manageable with diligent application of mitigation measures and suitably robust consent conditions". Landscape and bond also seem not too contentious.
I'm not sure conservation issues are that critical since the proposed mine is on privately owned land.
but overall, my impression is that despite submitting 9000 pages there is a lot of work for SMI still to do. the approval process looks hard and may not be fast.
GLTAH
From the Sanatana website latest Blue Oceans Analysts Equity Research valuation is in, I note the date they have based an increased likelihood of FTA approval being positively determined at around June 2026.
https://www.santanaminerals.com/equity-research
That June date actually being ahead of perhaps what SMI have now conceded would likely be late October 2026, https://www.nzx.com/announcements/467015 also I'm mindful the general election is set for about a week or two later, and what chance the Greens have a ability to rescind some mining approvals under FTA regime as they have indicated in late 2026 television media they will sought to do once elected to power. For me the gold is there, but the previous negatives to be resolved first are still just as indeterminable as to timeframe and further conditions imposed so it's still with some risk beyond what I feel some foresee.
I agree. For the mine to go ahead they not only need approval under the FTA process but also a National lead coalition to win the election.
Even if these two independent events are 60% probability each of occurring, the combined chance of both occurring is only 36%.
If they're each two thirds chance of happening that's still only a 44% chance of both happening.
In my opinion there's only a very small chance a lunatic left coalition would allow the FTA ruling to stand if it's positive.
Then there's the chance of appeals, a judicial review or even possible treaty claims
Putting all this together I reckon the chance of the mine ever getting into production is 50/50 at best. Too much risk for my liking .
Sam Niell's recent video take on the SMI mining proposal
https://bendigo.nz/?fbclid=IwY2xjawQBvIVleHRuA2FlbQIxMABicmlkETJ1S1R2bHoydTBBVXh0N0Y5c3J0YwZhcHBfaWQQMjIyMDM5MTc4ODIwMDg5MgABHoWQ52IbFvgRIQqj9iifkxStGQmZ7hiTwypdssJ6YEou-_4Z8-T3I7YjWomJ_aem_ADUo9W9k1T4lOL1RB1AOyw
Quote from: Left Field on Feb 18, 2026, 10:38 AMSam Niell's recent video take on the SMI mining proposal
https://bendigo.nz/?fbclid=IwY2xjawQBvIVleHRuA2FlbQIxMABicmlkETJ1S1R2bHoydTBBVXh0N0Y5c3J0YwZhcHBfaWQQMjIyMDM5MTc4ODIwMDg5MgABHoWQ52IbFvgRIQqj9iifkxStGQmZ7hiTwypdssJ6YEou-_4Z8-T3I7YjWomJ_aem_ADUo9W9k1T4lOL1RB1AOyw
Interesting. Mining dams need to stay forever - and their actual breakagerate is higher than the breakrate of e.g. water dams.
Ah yes, and if they do break? Well, all the stuff in the tailing dam which isn't good for the environment will go somewhere. No matter whether this is in 5 years, 10 years, 20 years, 50 years or say in 10,000 years.
Sounds like an amazing investment into NZ's future, doesn't it?
Quote from: BlackPeter on Feb 18, 2026, 01:55 PMAh yes, and if they do break? Well, all the stuff in the tailing dam which isn't good for the environment will go somewhere. No matter whether this is in 5 years, 10 years, 20 years, 50 years or say in 10,000 years.
Sounds like an amazing investment into NZ's future, doesn't it?
Simple gravity makes it likely that contaminated spoil from a tailing dam leak will make its way into the Clutha River - the second longest river in NZ and largest river by volume, a vital source of fresh water for downstream towns such as Cromwell, Clyde, Alexandra, Roxburgh. Beaumont and Balclutha.
In the extreme long run I agree there is a risk but tailings dams are built to very robust standards. Extreme earthquake is probably the major risk.
Quote from: Basil on Feb 18, 2026, 03:12 PMIn the extreme long run I agree there is a risk but tailings dams are built to very robust standards. Extreme earthquake is probably the major risk.
It is right next to a fault line as builders of the Clyde Dam found at their cost (ie NZ taxpayers.)
There are also huge uncharted underground water flows as again highlighted by the remedial work required in the Cromwell gorge to protect the dam from major slips.
It aint as simple as it seems Basil, ask any local.
Fair enough Left Field. I'm sure this issue has already been addressed at great length in the 9,000 + pages of technical reports accompanying the FTA and will be a subject of great debate by various experts from both sides.
Skipping over the rights and wrongs of the Project, bar to say the local ODT rag is very much at an editorial level moved to a position of saying such matters are best sorted in the existing regulatory system by those with some expertise, which the SMI CEO followed up in an article this week that included some "colloquial" references to Sir Ian Taylor, who has had a bit of a bun fight response sequence, and towards Sir Sam Neill as profile opponents to such mining activities.
Latest SPP offering to calculate at AUD90c has information to detail to come this week for shareholders (if ASX give a waiver for a subsequent SPP within 12 months the application date will be sooner than 1 April,) but does have some disclosures already from the SMI CEO https://www.nzx.com/announcements/467602
extracted content from page 1
Damian Spring, Executive Director and CEO of Santana, commented:
"This is a strong show of support for Santana and its proposed development of the Bendigo-Ophir
Gold Project. This placement essentially fills the equity component of funding for the development
with discussions on the remaining debt funding advancing well.
The funds raised will enable us to accelerate our pathway to production by enabling early works
and major equipment deposits to enable an immediate start on receipt of our final resource
consents which are due at the end of October 2026."
And extracted content from page 4 I found interesting personally
Without limiting its discretion pursuant to the terms of the SPP, Santana also advises that in the event
that the SPP is oversubscribed, in considering any necessary scale-back and allocation of shares
Santana will have regard to the extent to which any Eligible Shareholders sell shares prior to the Closing
Date and any Eligible Shareholders who sell such shares are unlikely to receive any allocation under
the SPP.
SPP at AUD90c last application date set for Friday this week for any investors desiring to participate.
Online application with completion of a direct debit authority to a NZ denominated transactional bank account.
Current exchange rate of about 0.84 if is the same at close of trade cross rate on Friday might mean NZ holders are allocated shares issued at around NZD$1.07, also note that latest ASX trading has been below the AUD$0.90 issue price.
Financials for 26HY1 to 31 December 2025 will be loaded to NZX announcements today https://www.nzx.com/announcements/468951
Why participate when they are cheaper on market and the retail part is only about 10% of the raising...
Opposition growing........ a new web site opposing SMI's mining application FYI.
https://naturalcapital.co.nz/
Quote from: Left Field on Apr 07, 2026, 02:43 PMOpposition growing........ a new web site opposing SMI's mining application FYI.
https://naturalcapital.co.nz/
No details of those involved.
Collective - could be 2 people??
Quote from: Sideshow Bob on Apr 07, 2026, 07:26 PMNo details of those involved.
Collective - could be 2 people??
true - the webpage does not offer a lot of names ... actually - it doesn't offer any contact.
On the other hand ... the recent article from Otago Times offers at least a spokes person:
https://www.odt.co.nz/regions/central-otago/new-anti-mine-group-takes-aim-tailings-dam-failure-risk
Zoe Hawkins, which may or may not be the same Zoe Hawkins in Auckland who states that she is a highly experienced writer.
"My name is Zoe Hawkins. I am a highly experienced writer, communications expert, marketer and events manager with specialisations in the marine industry and marine environment."
I guess the writing style appears to be similar. Maybe just the way to get a job?
But anyway - maybe just ask her about the people running the orgajnisation she is talking for?
Parliamentary Commissioner for the environment shares concerns on SML's proposals.
https://www.fasttrack.govt.nz/__data/assets/pdf_file/0020/23474/26_Parliamentary-Commissioner-for-the-Environment-comments-on-application_Redacted.pdf?fbclid=IwY2xjawRKivRleHRuA2FlbQIxMABicmlkETFZNEltNXZDMlg5bUtLdU0xc3J0YwZhcHBfaWQQMjIyMDM5MTc4ODIwMDg5MgABHlvRETsBzmqU7WDReHYswaQ34SXbM9UF1esMDXyxDrul--M4VjGhH0NOmeVI_aem_oWSlsyughOM9TBmIIpHHVA